Who would you rather...

edited January 2014 in The Walking Dead

Who would you guys rather have alive Kenny or lilly? In my opinion I woupd rather have kenny.

«1

Comments

  • Kenny, fuck Lilly.

  • fuck them both,it's either omid or christa

  • I think both are alive, but I suppose I'd prefer Kenny, even though both might be beneficial to Clementine. Kenny seems the most interesting choice though, also I don't know why Clementine would assume Lily dead.

  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator

    Kenny and his god like mustache

  • Lilly. All the way.

    Never rooted for, or sided with, Kenny ONCE in S1.

  • From a thematic point of view, Lilly. For me Kenny's story arc ended in that alley, and I still don't think there's a satisfying explanation for him being able to make it out of there.

    I'm still holding out for Christa to return for a full-time role though.

  • None of the above.

  • edited January 2014

    Not a huge fan of either of them but for the sake of an interesting story, I would lean a bit more towards Lilly. It would depend on the characters that they've become over the timeskip, though.

    From what I saw of them in Season 1, Lilly would be the more interesting character to bring back because even though Clem knows her, she's proven to be extremely untrustworthy and unstable in the past. Bringing her back would keep me on edge a lot more than Kenny, who, while a jackass at times, has shown in his last scene of S1 that he can care about people other than himself and his family. I would especially be interested in a "redeemed" Lilly who at least tries to be more of a decent person than she was before.

    Kenny, though, might have also had an interesting character development over the past few years. If Kenny were to come back, I would want to see him drastically changed in some way. Maybe he's a bit off his rocker. Maybe he's grown more cold and calculating than he was before. Maybe he doesn't have his mustache. Something.

    So basically, I would be fine with either Kenny or Lilly back, so long as they're no longer entirely themselves

  • Lilly for returning, Kenny got a chance for redemption (in my story at least) so i think Lilly should have one too, or at least attempt one. Leaving a character on such a hated note is never a good thing.

  • I remember Omid was killed within the first 10 minutes of the episode so I'm fairly confident it wasnt him. Christa is a possibility. We never saw her fate. Same with Lily and Kenny.

    Herodriver posted: »

    fuck them both,it's either omid or christa

  • I played the opposite.. Not as a Kenny fan but I wanted the boat.. so I sided with him.. However, I believe it's Lily,

    ohhau posted: »

    Lilly. All the way. Never rooted for, or sided with, Kenny ONCE in S1.

  • I agree, but I think its lily because if you imagine a fort let's say with survivors, I could see Lily forming and leading that. I guess Kenny could to, but my gut say's Lily!

    DomeWing333 posted: »

    Not a huge fan of either of them but for the sake of an interesting story, I would lean a bit more towards Lilly. It would depend on the chara

  • Lilly. Kenny was my favorite character aside from Lee in season 1, but Lilly would definitely be better.
    Would be so much more interesting with the added fact that she hated my Lee's guts when she left.

  • edited January 2014

    Maybe he doesn't have his mustache

    Don't you even joke about that, you lunatic.

    DomeWing333 posted: »

    Not a huge fan of either of them but for the sake of an interesting story, I would lean a bit more towards Lilly. It would depend on the chara

  • edited January 2014

    Lilly seemed to be pretty unstable last time we seen her. Then again, so was Kenny, but atleast Kenny was trustworthy.
    No doubt i would want Kenny to return, i would be hesitant to trust Lilly if she does return, dispite the situation.

    Though, I must admit, i wonder how Lilly would get along with Rebecca, might be entertaining.

  • I think this is a rather easy answer for most of the people , if you are looking for real competition it should have been Kenny or Lee

  • edited January 2014

    Miraculously bringing Lee back after season 1's emotional payoff would be one of the worst twists they could make...

    SaltLick305 posted: »

    I think this is a rather easy answer for most of the people , if you are looking for real competition it should have been Kenny or Lee

  • kenny bells, lilly smels, clemmie lays an egg, larry died, lilly cried, mustache all the way!!

    my prediction for episode 2 (excluding the larry part)

  • What about GLENN?

  • A snake for a tongue? Or lobster claws for hands?

  • I pick Kenny he's the best Lilly I just don't like her.

  • that's a good one @dylanvdg

    dylanvdg posted: »

    kenny bells, lilly smels, clemmie lays an egg, larry died, lilly cried, mustache all the way!! my prediction for episode 2 (excluding the larry part)

  • Kenny and his godly mustache. Let's hope he doesn't grow a beard. Please let Kenny have warm water, razors and beard foam!

  • I find it more believable that Kenny survived the darkened building than the alley. Unless he found a manhole under Ben's body or something. I considered maybe having either of them return depending on how they were lost, but then I realized TTG wouild need to make them both have the same storyline in S2 or the branching storylines would be too complicated.

  • thanx bro

    James101 posted: »

    that's a good one @dylanvdg

  • What about the girl that "dies" in the beginning of the episode?

    WowMutt posted: »

    I remember Omid was killed within the first 10 minutes of the episode so I'm fairly confident it wasnt him. Christa is a possibility. We never saw her fate. Same with Lily and Kenny.

  • Im not saying it should be accurate , I mean it like even if it involves wishful thinking, it would interesting to see who has more fans

    Mikejames posted: »

    Miraculously bringing Lee back after season 1's emotional payoff would be one of the worst twists they could make...

  • I would choose Kenny any day

  • How about both? Kenny because his death wasn't exactly clarified and he was the 3rd most important character in season one, Lilly because....well, being honest i hated Lilly but we need something to know how her story ends.

  • Oh, you mean the one that dies? Yeah, she's dead. For realsies.

    Stolenmango posted: »

    What about the girl that "dies" in the beginning of the episode?

  • Clemmie lays an egg? That sounds wrong...... lol

    dylanvdg posted: »

    kenny bells, lilly smels, clemmie lays an egg, larry died, lilly cried, mustache all the way!! my prediction for episode 2 (excluding the larry part)

  • edited January 2014

    Definitely Kenny, despite me being an anti-kennazi. Lilly's a bitch.

  • OBVIOUSLY the lobster hands, Leland!

    Omid posted: »

    A snake for a tongue? Or lobster claws for hands?

  • Neither Kenny nor Lilly. Return to me, Molly.

  • It's most likely the juice.

  • cool story bro, CoolStoryBro

    It's most likely the juice.

This discussion has been closed.