She wasn't robbing her at gunpoint, she was merely holding the gun while asking her to give the hat to her, she never 'Pointed' it at Clem or even acted like she was going to shoot her.
That was exactly right. It is possible Lilly died (especially if you leave her by the road in Episode 3), but there's nothing to suggest she's… more dead. if it is here, I'd probably get a sense of deja vu. The same thing happened to Merle in the show. He gets left behind, and is forgotten until Season 3. The same thing might be happening here.
Also, what's taking so long to release Episode 2? I'd at least expect Telltale to confirm a release date by now, or is this a tradition of theirs?
This is just my thoughts like saltlick said. People are rude always. I hate when people call threads that are people's thoughts trolling. For … morethe 40th time i'm not a troll . I find it funny that people in this community never call threads with people posting weird pics of Kenny or characters and also making threads about paul walker trolling. It's always the threads with thoughts people call trolling and be rude as hell. If you think my threads are trolling don't comment at all dammit. Also if you don't agree don't comment rude things.
Since when has The Walking Dead been a world full of fairness? Even if it is very unlikely, it is still within the realm of possibility that Michelle has survived. That would be interesting to see how Clem would react, or rather how would you react as Clem. I'd probably be re-considering my "Do not kill, if all possible." philosophy.
Yeah, uh...no.
Christa unloaded both barrels of a shotgun into Michelle at point-blank range - not to mention that Christa would have proba… morebly popped ANOTHER round into Michelle's head, although I could see her leaving Michelle to reanimate just for the sake of revenge. For Telltale to restore her to life and not Omid would go beyond mere trolling.
To be honest, I'm miffed enough at Telltale for making Clementine indirectly responsible for Omid's murder (i.e. not allowing the player to take the gun to the bathroom stall), just so they could pursue some vague story angle about Clem's "survivor guilt". Michelle's death was the only comfort I got out of that opening. Let's leave it at that.
She totally was pointing it at her. From when she saw Clem in the stall up until she was startled by Omid, she was definitely pointing the gun at Clem. And telling Clem that she would "pop" her is Michelle saying that she would shoot Clementine.
She wasn't robbing her at gunpoint, she was merely holding the gun while asking her to give the hat to her, she never 'Pointed' it at Clem or even acted like she was going to shoot her.
I can't speak for xboxplayer_12, but I personally think that it's not Lilly because Clementine has no reason to believe she's dead. Depending … moreon how you played it, she either steals the RV or is left on the side of the road. Clem never sees her die. It might be that Clem just thought she was dead because it had been so long, but that's quite an assumption to make given that Clementine had made it for that long and she's just a child. I'm betting on Kenny myself. Hopefully, we won't have to sit on pins and needles much longer if TTG would just go ahead and release Episode 2.
Why the hell did this get 10 downvotes ? Its just a thought for god's sake you don't have to like it its just something that came fo her mind , Some of us need to grow up...
This is not the world of fairies and unicorns, people can actually die in this game and getting shot in the gut can not be survived without a medical operation and who has the knowledge and technical devices to do that in a world like this? And why should they help some shot down ugly toilet girl?
Not a shotgun.
http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Winchester_Model_70
Since when has The Walking Dead been a world full of fairness? Even… more if it is very unlikely, it is still within the realm of possibility that Michelle has survived. That would be interesting to see how Clem would react, or rather how would you react as Clem. I'd probably be re-considering my "Do not kill, if all possible." philosophy.
This is just my thoughts like saltlick said. People are rude always. I hate when people call threads that are people's thoughts trolling. For … morethe 40th time i'm not a troll . I find it funny that people in this community never call threads with people posting weird pics of Kenny or characters and also making threads about paul walker trolling. It's always the threads with thoughts people call trolling and be rude as hell. If you think my threads are trolling don't comment at all dammit. Also if you don't agree don't comment rude things.
I hope she comes back. I am going to peel her like a potato and then throw her convulsing body into a vat of hydrochloric acid.
But really, this would be extremely anticlimactic and no one actually wants to see her return. Her death was the only joyful moment of the first episode.
So thats how you express your opinion ? Instead of telling her why you don't agree with this just dislike it like if she was gonna know it was you , Good one Jerk
I think the model you mean was used in the: "Previously on The Walking Dead" - Part at the very beginning of episode 1. As much as I hope Kenny returns, this is probably just the model from the beginning.
It's not her, that's as confirmed as Lee's death. I got a question for you, why do you hope it's someone that Clem and Christa met during the 16 months period?
So thats how you express your opinion ? Instead of telling her why you don't agree with this just dislike it like if she was gonna know it was you , Good one Jerk
Shotgun, Winchester, at the end of the day Michelle still got blasted in the gut. Anything else is just nitpicking.
Since when has The Walking Dead been a world full of fairness? Even if it is very unlikely, it is still within the realm of possibility that Michelle has survived.
No, no, and no. That wouldn't be simple, indifferent "unfairness", that would be deliberate, calculated meanness on the part of the scriptwriters. If Michelle were to come back in the next episode, then the WALKING DEAD world is one purely inclined to outright evil than a so-called "chaotic" world were good and bad people alike can be killed in a heartbeat. It's the sort of shallow, one-sided pessimism that made me sick of the comics and the tv show.
The moment I see Michelle's loathsome countenance again, I will flat-out refuse to play the rest of the season, and try to get a refund for my season pass in the process. I'm sure Telltale won't lose any tears over my departure from the franchise, so who really cares?
Not a shotgun.
http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Winchester_Model_70
Since when has The Walking Dead been a world full of fairness? Even… more if it is very unlikely, it is still within the realm of possibility that Michelle has survived. That would be interesting to see how Clem would react, or rather how would you react as Clem. I'd probably be re-considering my "Do not kill, if all possible." philosophy.
She totally was pointing it at her. From when she saw Clem in the stall up until she was startled by Omid, she was definitely pointing the gun at Clem. And telling Clem that she would "pop" her is Michelle saying that she would shoot Clementine.
I've heard about this glitch before, but never experienced it. Never heard about Kenny being one of the people there though, only Nick. Never … moreanything about Carver though. How could you be sure it was Carver? We haven't seen him yet. Could be any individual you meet in Episode 2.
I'm just pointing out the possibility of the game being absolutely cruel sometimes. S1 SPOILER Take Carley/Doug getting suddenly shot. Especially after the brewing romance between Lee and Carley, Telltale goes "Yoink! Nope! You're not gonna have that."
Hell, even I wouldn't bet on seeing Michelle again. I believe she's dead as dead can be but there's always a possibility.
"It's the sort of shallow, one-sided pessimism that made me sick of the comics and the tv show." On this I'm fully, 100% with you. This game needs to have hope in it to remain engaging for me.
Shotgun, Winchester, at the end of the day Michelle still got blasted in the gut. Anything else is just nitpicking.
Since when has The W… morealking Dead been a world full of fairness? Even if it is very unlikely, it is still within the realm of possibility that Michelle has survived.
No, no, and no. That wouldn't be simple, indifferent "unfairness", that would be deliberate, calculated meanness on the part of the scriptwriters. If Michelle were to come back in the next episode, then the WALKING DEAD world is one purely inclined to outright evil than a so-called "chaotic" world were good and bad people alike can be killed in a heartbeat. It's the sort of shallow, one-sided pessimism that made me sick of the comics and the tv show.
The moment I see Michelle's loathsome countenance again, I will flat-out refuse to play the rest of the season, and try to get a refund for my season pass in the process. I'm sure Telltale won't lose any tears over my departure from the franchise, so who really cares?
I think the model you mean was used in the: "Previously on The Walking Dead" - Part at the very beginning of episode 1. As much as I hope Kenny returns, this is probably just the model from the beginning.
It's not her, that's as confirmed as Lee's death. I got a question for you, why do you hope it's someone that Clem and Christa met during the 16 months period?
We don't really know that 100%. I think Michelle could have done it. She may have been startled at shooting Omid because maybe she had thought he was a walker and maybe she freaked out when she realized he wasn't.
Yes, at the Motor Inn, and also in the Overall-Shot of Crawford. Don't get me wrong, I sure hope it means more and that it actually IS a new model. One Question: How did the model look? What clothes did it wear?
Because if it wears the same clothes as in Season 1, I can't see this as a Season 2 model.
Kenny never appeared on the "Previously on The Walking Dead" for me. He might show up on alternate choices though...?
EDIT: Oh wait, just remembered that it showed the part when Larry was saying that he knew your secret. Saw Kenny then.
I'm sure that when she said she'd pop Clem, that she was just meaning she'd give Clementine a nice refreshing bottle of soda pop since she looked thirsty.
She totally was pointing it at her. From when she saw Clem in the stall up until she was startled by Omid, she was definitely pointing the gun at Clem. And telling Clem that she would "pop" her is Michelle saying that she would shoot Clementine.
Lilly - possible - if you left her on the side of the road there's a reason for Clem to think she's dead. If she stole the RV, no real reason for Clem to think she's dead. She was in a better position to survive than the group was at that point.
Kenny - possible - you never actually see him die and there's a slim possibilty that he made it out of there, plus Clem might have thought everyone except Omid and Christa had died
Ben - slimly possible but very, very unlikely - in some cases he's torn apart by zombies. In one scenario you don't actually see him die but he's impaled and zombies are surrounding him and Kenny, so VERY unlikely it's him.
Michelle - was shot in the stomach by Christa, not the head. Slight possibility she survived and got to someone who healed her, or was found by someone and healed up (hey it happened with Carl) - unlikely only because I'd be surprised that Christa didnt shoot Michelle in the head afterwards.
Lee - very unlikely, but there's still a slim possibility if they're using the scenario where Clem leaves him instead of shooting him in the head since you just see him keel over. Assumed dead but could have been like Herschel in the TV show.
Andrew St. John - possible but unlikely since in one scenario, he can be killed by Lee
Danny St. John - possible but unlikely since in one scenario, he can be killed by Lee
The Stranger - very, very, very unlikely - in all but one scenario he's shot in the head (either by Clem or Lee). Only chance it would be him is if, after Lee chokes him, Lee chooses to not shoot him and Clem and him leave before he reanimates, but he wasnt actually dead from the choking.
Nick - if you choose to save Pete, Nick is pursued into the woods, with zombies right on him. Clem could have thought he was dead
People it could be but not sure why Clem would have thought they were dead:
Glenn - no real reason for Clem to think he's dead - plus unlikely since he's probably with the Atlanta survivors at this point
Molly - of all the people in Savannah, she's the least likely for Clem to think was dead - mega survivor
Christa - very possible, but no real reason for Clem to think she's dead unless she finds something in episode 2 to make her think Christa is dead
Herschel - no real reason to assume he's dead - plus he'd probably be with the Atlanta survivors at this point
Andre - the cop from Season 1 episode 1 - possible, though Clem only meets him if Lee and Clem leave her house at night - no reason to think he's dead though
Chet - Shawn's friend from Season 1 episode 1 - possible, though Clem only meets him if Lee and Clem leave her house during the day - no reason to think he's dead though
People it could NOT be:
Duck - he gets shot no matter what after being bit
Katjaa - she shoots herself no matter what
Charles - Lee saw him dead in the sewers being eaten
Jolene - she gets shot in the head, either by Lee or by Danny St. John
Brenda St. John - you see her as a zombie no matter what (zombified Mark eats her)
Mark - you see him as a zombie no matter what
Travis - he gets eaten by zombies no matter what
David - he dies, either from zombies or when he dies in the Motor Inn
Larry - totally and utterly dead no matter what - top half of his head gone
Carley - either shot in the head by Lilly or eaten by zombies - not alive no matter what
Doug - either shot in the head by Lilly or eaten by zombies and ripped apart - not alive no matter what
Beatrice - dead no matter what - plus Clem would have never even known her anyway
Clem's parents - she saw them as zombies
Shawn - dead no matter what - eaten by zombies
Lee's brother - dead - you see him as a zombie
Vernon - dead - stated by Boyd in 400 days that he died
Boyd - dies in 400 days, plus no reason for Clem to have thought othewise anyway
Brie - dead - torn apart by zombies in the school
Omid - I can't see Christa having left Omid if he wasnt dead, and she probably would have shot him in the head so he didnt turn afterwards
Depends:
Pete - IF you choose to save Nick, you see Pete killed by zombies. If you choose to save Pete, you wouldnt be surprised to see Nick (assuming he survives the bite and amputation) or Pete (since you'd have saved him in the first place, unless he does something afterwards to make Clem think he's dead in episode 2)
Comments
She wasn't robbing her at gunpoint, she was merely holding the gun while asking her to give the hat to her, she never 'Pointed' it at Clem or even acted like she was going to shoot her.
Its been confirmed, first week of February
So much hate
Agree with you , Keep posting whatever comes to your mind , downvotes ain't gonna kill you just ignore people like that it hurts more
Not a shotgun.
http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Winchester_Model_70
Since when has The Walking Dead been a world full of fairness? Even if it is very unlikely, it is still within the realm of possibility that Michelle has survived. That would be interesting to see how Clem would react, or rather how would you react as Clem. I'd probably be re-considering my "Do not kill, if all possible." philosophy.
What if the chance of Michelle surviving provides you with a chance to blow her head off personally? Would you do it, or spare her?
I think that scenario would raise a lot of emotion and discussion. Maybe even more so than Kennys/Lillys/Christas presumptive return.
She totally was pointing it at her. From when she saw Clem in the stall up until she was startled by Omid, she was definitely pointing the gun at Clem. And telling Clem that she would "pop" her is Michelle saying that she would shoot Clementine.
After two years... i would totally think that she's dead even if she didn't die right there.
TWAU... : /
If I don't have to like it, I can dislike it. And to express my opinion I use the dislike button.
This is not the world of fairies and unicorns, people can actually die in this game and getting shot in the gut can not be survived without a medical operation and who has the knowledge and technical devices to do that in a world like this? And why should they help some shot down ugly toilet girl?
Kirkman would personally assasinate them for doing shit like that. And the people working there aren't stoned highschool-dropouts.
I am confused as to if you think I am calling you a troll or not. As I am not, just to make that clear. Your thread is a valid theory in my opinion.
I hope she comes back. I am going to peel her like a potato and then throw her convulsing body into a vat of hydrochloric acid.
But really, this would be extremely anticlimactic and no one actually wants to see her return. Her death was the only joyful moment of the first episode.
So thats how you express your opinion ? Instead of telling her why you don't agree with this just dislike it like if she was gonna know it was you , Good one Jerk
She's dead and she should stay dead.
I think the model you mean was used in the: "Previously on The Walking Dead" - Part at the very beginning of episode 1. As much as I hope Kenny returns, this is probably just the model from the beginning.
It's not her, that's as confirmed as Lee's death. I got a question for you, why do you hope it's someone that Clem and Christa met during the 16 months period?
The dislike button was made for that purpose. And if I'm a jerk then you are a dumbass.
Shotgun, Winchester, at the end of the day Michelle still got blasted in the gut. Anything else is just nitpicking.
No, no, and no. That wouldn't be simple, indifferent "unfairness", that would be deliberate, calculated meanness on the part of the scriptwriters. If Michelle were to come back in the next episode, then the WALKING DEAD world is one purely inclined to outright evil than a so-called "chaotic" world were good and bad people alike can be killed in a heartbeat. It's the sort of shallow, one-sided pessimism that made me sick of the comics and the tv show.
The moment I see Michelle's loathsome countenance again, I will flat-out refuse to play the rest of the season, and try to get a refund for my season pass in the process. I'm sure Telltale won't lose any tears over my departure from the franchise, so who really cares?
Yes, but obviously she would not have shot her, she freaked out when she shot Omid, she was not a killer
Sorry, Carlos not Carver.
No need to get dramatic.
I'm just pointing out the possibility of the game being absolutely cruel sometimes. S1 SPOILER Take Carley/Doug getting suddenly shot. Especially after the brewing romance between Lee and Carley, Telltale goes "Yoink! Nope! You're not gonna have that."
Hell, even I wouldn't bet on seeing Michelle again. I believe she's dead as dead can be but there's always a possibility.
"It's the sort of shallow, one-sided pessimism that made me sick of the comics and the tv show." On this I'm fully, 100% with you. This game needs to have hope in it to remain engaging for me.
...
Sometimes I like nitpicking!
Kenny never appeared on the "Previously on The Walking Dead" for me. He might show up on alternate choices though...?
EDIT: Oh wait, just remembered that it showed the part when Larry was saying that he knew your secret. Saw Kenny then.
i don't know
YES. Ice Brie!
We don't really know that 100%. I think Michelle could have done it. She may have been startled at shooting Omid because maybe she had thought he was a walker and maybe she freaked out when she realized he wasn't.
right... not sure how giving my opinion was hate but alright, thanks.
Yes, at the Motor Inn, and also in the Overall-Shot of Crawford. Don't get me wrong, I sure hope it means more and that it actually IS a new model. One Question: How did the model look? What clothes did it wear?
Because if it wears the same clothes as in Season 1, I can't see this as a Season 2 model.
I'm sure that when she said she'd pop Clem, that she was just meaning she'd give Clementine a nice refreshing bottle of soda pop since she looked thirsty.
Riiiiiiiiiiight
People it could be
Lilly - possible - if you left her on the side of the road there's a reason for Clem to think she's dead. If she stole the RV, no real reason for Clem to think she's dead. She was in a better position to survive than the group was at that point.
Kenny - possible - you never actually see him die and there's a slim possibilty that he made it out of there, plus Clem might have thought everyone except Omid and Christa had died
Ben - slimly possible but very, very unlikely - in some cases he's torn apart by zombies. In one scenario you don't actually see him die but he's impaled and zombies are surrounding him and Kenny, so VERY unlikely it's him.
Michelle - was shot in the stomach by Christa, not the head. Slight possibility she survived and got to someone who healed her, or was found by someone and healed up (hey it happened with Carl) - unlikely only because I'd be surprised that Christa didnt shoot Michelle in the head afterwards.
Lee - very unlikely, but there's still a slim possibility if they're using the scenario where Clem leaves him instead of shooting him in the head since you just see him keel over. Assumed dead but could have been like Herschel in the TV show.
Andrew St. John - possible but unlikely since in one scenario, he can be killed by Lee
Danny St. John - possible but unlikely since in one scenario, he can be killed by Lee
The Stranger - very, very, very unlikely - in all but one scenario he's shot in the head (either by Clem or Lee). Only chance it would be him is if, after Lee chokes him, Lee chooses to not shoot him and Clem and him leave before he reanimates, but he wasnt actually dead from the choking.
Nick - if you choose to save Pete, Nick is pursued into the woods, with zombies right on him. Clem could have thought he was dead
People it could be but not sure why Clem would have thought they were dead:
Glenn - no real reason for Clem to think he's dead - plus unlikely since he's probably with the Atlanta survivors at this point
Molly - of all the people in Savannah, she's the least likely for Clem to think was dead - mega survivor
Christa - very possible, but no real reason for Clem to think she's dead unless she finds something in episode 2 to make her think Christa is dead
Herschel - no real reason to assume he's dead - plus he'd probably be with the Atlanta survivors at this point
Andre - the cop from Season 1 episode 1 - possible, though Clem only meets him if Lee and Clem leave her house at night - no reason to think he's dead though
Chet - Shawn's friend from Season 1 episode 1 - possible, though Clem only meets him if Lee and Clem leave her house during the day - no reason to think he's dead though
People it could NOT be:
Duck - he gets shot no matter what after being bit
Katjaa - she shoots herself no matter what
Charles - Lee saw him dead in the sewers being eaten
Jolene - she gets shot in the head, either by Lee or by Danny St. John
Brenda St. John - you see her as a zombie no matter what (zombified Mark eats her)
Mark - you see him as a zombie no matter what
Travis - he gets eaten by zombies no matter what
David - he dies, either from zombies or when he dies in the Motor Inn
Larry - totally and utterly dead no matter what - top half of his head gone
Carley - either shot in the head by Lilly or eaten by zombies - not alive no matter what
Doug - either shot in the head by Lilly or eaten by zombies and ripped apart - not alive no matter what
Beatrice - dead no matter what - plus Clem would have never even known her anyway
Clem's parents - she saw them as zombies
Shawn - dead no matter what - eaten by zombies
Lee's brother - dead - you see him as a zombie
Vernon - dead - stated by Boyd in 400 days that he died
Boyd - dies in 400 days, plus no reason for Clem to have thought othewise anyway
Brie - dead - torn apart by zombies in the school
Omid - I can't see Christa having left Omid if he wasnt dead, and she probably would have shot him in the head so he didnt turn afterwards
Depends:
Pete - IF you choose to save Nick, you see Pete killed by zombies. If you choose to save Pete, you wouldnt be surprised to see Nick (assuming he survives the bite and amputation) or Pete (since you'd have saved him in the first place, unless he does something afterwards to make Clem think he's dead in episode 2)