Carver and Rebecca are on the floor. Carver is bleeding out and Rebecca is about to go into labor. You then find out Carver stole Kenny's mustache. Who do you kill?
Ok, I have another one. In Episode 2's cliffhanger, Nate reappears in a creepy way. In Episode 3, he plays a type of SAW game with you. He has Carlos and Shel tied up. The people who are in front of him are beaten and have obviously been raped by Nate. He says you have to choose who lives and who dies. Who do you choose Sarah or Becca(They are tied up as well).
Ok here's my idea (it's a bit long):
Let's say Christa was saved from the bandtis by Carver's group. The main group is attacked by Carver's… more group and Clemetine, Carlos and Luke are captured. WHen they are looking them in rooms from some house they use as a prison there are only two rooms left so Christa (never letting Carver's group know she knows Clem) lets Clem pick whith whom she's stuck so she can know to wich room she will come to rescue her later. Latter in the game. After a long bonding happens between Clementine and the person she's stuck with and the person who you didn't choose constantly being tortured for information (wich you can hear the screams) the rest of the group would attack the camp and break your rooms window to save you, but, at the same time, Christa opens the door with Carlos/Luke (the person being tortured) by her side and will say that you have to go with her and the guards have noticed the keys were gone. Now you ha… [view original content]
I don't like either of them, but I'm guessing this happens after you have time to create a bound with Shel and Becca as well. Because if don't you are asking for Clementine to save someone she knows for someone she doesn't know.
I would choose to save Sarah if you don't get to bound with them before I will obviously (as Clementine), because Clementine knows her and Carlos. If we get to bound it would depend a lot on how changed Shel and Becca are, but I guess I would save Sarah also. I guess I just like Sarah more than Becca just because Sarah is still a kid and Becca is a little more grown up.
Ok, I have another one. In Episode 2's cliffhanger, Nate reappears in a creepy way. In Episode 3, he plays a type of SAW game with you. He has… more Carlos and Shel tied up. The people who are in front of him are beaten and have obviously been raped by Nate. He says you have to choose who lives and who dies. Who do you choose Sarah or Becca(They are tied up as well).
i always thought save luke or save kenny(if he comes back)maybe you would choose luke cause hes not broken or kenny because you want to give him a second chance to protect his family.I love Luke but Kenny all the way
Another idea I have.
Clementine joins a cult in episode 4 which is strict but protects her. The cult is always being attacked by Tavias ca… moremp, and many members of the cult die because of this. The cult decides to go to war with Tavias camp. All the 400 days characters you brought as Tavia will be there. So the more people that came, the harder the war.
This decision is only there if Shel and Becca came. Becca and Clementine fight and Clementine ends up stabbing her in the chest. Becca lays there dying and Shel comes and tries to kill Clem but another cult member rescues her by killing Shel. Becca lays on the floor dying, decision:
Leave her OR shoot her.
This would satisfy all those who hate Becca and want her to die!
That would be hard to make... I never liked Kenny is season 1 but I understood what he made, so him, coming back in season 2, whould depend on how he's... But choosing between someone I know I might consider a jerk and might not like, but I respect and know he can protect Clem (Kenny) and someone I just met and besides him seeming kind off nice to Clem I don't know I well he can protect Clem (Luke)...
I guess I would go with Kenny if I had to choose now without any more interaction with Luke or Kenny
i always thought save luke or save kenny(if he comes back)maybe you would choose luke cause hes not broken or kenny because you want to give him a second chance to protect his family.I love Luke but Kenny all the way
You are being hunted by a group of scavengers, when a series of military helicopters start to pass over. Do you light a flare? Will the military ignore you? Will the scavengers see the flare?
I did kind of steal this one from JESSEC25..... Except its a bit different.
In Episode 2, Vernon returns and apologizes. He has a heart to … moreheart with Clementine and Vernon is no longer hated. Than, Victor the bandit guy shows up. He will thank you for the water if you gave it to him. He says that he and his group didn't mean to hurt anyone. They were just paranoid due to an incident with Carvers group. He got separated from the rest of his group. Later, you are on the Ski- Lift. You are on the lift with Victor and Vernon. The Ski- Lift limit is read and the lift will fall. Who do you push off? Victor or Vernon?
I don't like either of them, but I'm guessing this happens after you have time to create a bound with Shel and Becca as well. Because if don't… more you are asking for Clementine to save someone she knows for someone she doesn't know.
I would choose to save Sarah if you don't get to bound with them before I will obviously (as Clementine), because Clementine knows her and Carlos. If we get to bound it would depend a lot on how changed Shel and Becca are, but I guess I would save Sarah also. I guess I just like Sarah more than Becca just because Sarah is still a kid and Becca is a little more grown up.
AH AH just kidding, assuming we had a flare, I would not light it, it would atract scavengers attention too and I'm guessing they would get to me faster than the guys in the military helicopters I would just hide and wait for the helicopters to come back or follow the direction they were going....
You are being hunted by a group of scavengers, when a series of military helicopters start to pass over. Do you light a flare? Will the military ignore you? Will the scavengers see the flare?
Something I thought would be really cool if done properly would be inadvertedly picking who dies on a later episode. What I mean is that there's an important choice early in the season (which would appear at the end of the episode) that would trigger a series of events that lead to one of two character dying, depending on what you did earlier.
For example, let's say Christa joins the group early in episode 2 just so that I can make some sense out of what I'm saying. Also, let's say Nick survives no matter what you picked in the river while Pete only survives if you picked him. If you saved Pete, he'll immediate strike up a friendship with Christa but she has a hard time forgiving Nick for his behaviour in the first episode. As the season progresses Christa will become even better friends with Pete (again, if you saved him) but will remain cold towards Nick. On episode 4/5, Christa and Rebecca will find themselves in some sort of trouble and only Nick, you and possibly Pete can save them. If only Nick is there, he'll go after Rebecca no matter what you tell him. However, if Pete is there, he'll go after Christa (he could die in the process) and Nick will, for some reason (maybe you'll assist Pete instead of Nick), fail to.save Rebecca. To summarize, having Pete in the group means Christa lives while not having him means Rebecca lives.
Decisión (Episode 1): Go after Pete or Nick in the river.
Result (Episode 4/5): If you picked Pete, Rebecca dies. If you picked Nick, Christa dies.
Even if you don't like my example, it's the general idea I'm proposing. This would have to be done VERY well so as not to pest people off but I think Telltale could do it. It would definitely make people get paranoid about their choices and would catch us by complete surprise.
Some really good decisions in this thread.
Luke and Crista would be hard for me. Luke and Pete are the only new characters I like at the mo… morement but then Crista has known Clem longer and has become a bit more like a mother figure to Clem so I would really struggle with this decision.
Kenny and Crista, I'll choose Crista everytime (likewise I'll choose Luke over Kenny everytime). Kenny and Lily, I'd have to go with Kenny. Cannot forgive Lily for shooting Carley!
You have to pick a side. I'm assuming that event would be near the end of episode 3, throughout episode 4 everyone on both sides besides Clem ends up killing each other (the leaders die in the conflict) besides one or two people from either group, leading to Clem and those 2-4 people grouping up out of necessity, putting the story back on the rails, but still heavily influencing reactions/interactions from those 2-4 characters depending on your choice for the last two episodes.
I also like the idea of being able to choose neither side, or trying to stop the fighting.
For lack of a better example of main well known characters that hate each other, I'll just use Kenny and Lilly. This idea could work with any major characters they introduce into the season however. I think the Kenny/Lilly version is more intense though.
EG Kenny's group and Lilly's group in the background are about to annihilate each other (they aren't the leaders of their group btw), they are wrestling/trying to hatchet each other over a handgun, Clem gets the gun, and they each tell Clem to shoot the other. If Clem shoots Kenny, Lilly and one other of her friends from her group that she saves from the conflict will be travelling with Clem for the other half of the episode. If she shoots Lilly, It's Kenny and one of his friends. If Clem shoots one of them, they are non fatally wounded, and Clem and the other one escape and rescue on of their own friends from their own group.
Near the end of episode 4, the 'friend' character is killed by walkers or circumstance, and the person Clem shot shows up at the beginning of episode 5, with the other character taking pity on their injured state and taking them along. Episode 5 is a 3 character episode, Clem, Kenny and Lilly, with their attitudes and reactions changed according to Clem's/your actions so far in the story.
Alternatively, Clem can (by pointing the mouse at Clem's head instead of at Lilly or Kenny) can threaten them to drop her weapons or she will kill herself. In this route, Kenny and Lilly stay with Clem throughout the remainder of episode 4 and 5. Kenny and Lilly in their attempt to save Clem from herself, cannot save their other two friends from their own groups, who perishes in the battle without their assistance.
With everyone else dead and their commitments to their respective groups gone, Kenny and Lilly have nothing else to do but try to take care of Clementine.
Another idea I have.
Clementine joins a cult in episode 4 which is strict but protects her. The cult is always being attacked by Tavias ca… moremp, and many members of the cult die because of this. The cult decides to go to war with Tavias camp. All the 400 days characters you brought as Tavia will be there. So the more people that came, the harder the war.
This decision is only there if Shel and Becca came. Becca and Clementine fight and Clementine ends up stabbing her in the chest. Becca lays there dying and Shel comes and tries to kill Clem but another cult member rescues her by killing Shel. Becca lays on the floor dying, decision:
Leave her OR shoot her.
This would satisfy all those who hate Becca and want her to die!
Another idea I have.
Clementine joins a cult in episode 4 which is strict but protects her. The cult is always being attacked by Tavias ca… moremp, and many members of the cult die because of this. The cult decides to go to war with Tavias camp. All the 400 days characters you brought as Tavia will be there. So the more people that came, the harder the war.
This decision is only there if Shel and Becca came. Becca and Clementine fight and Clementine ends up stabbing her in the chest. Becca lays there dying and Shel comes and tries to kill Clem but another cult member rescues her by killing Shel. Becca lays on the floor dying, decision:
Leave her OR shoot her.
This would satisfy all those who hate Becca and want her to die!
Comments
Carver and Rebecca are on the floor. Carver is bleeding out and Rebecca is about to go into labor. You then find out Carver stole Kenny's mustache. Who do you kill?
Ok, I have another one. In Episode 2's cliffhanger, Nate reappears in a creepy way. In Episode 3, he plays a type of SAW game with you. He has Carlos and Shel tied up. The people who are in front of him are beaten and have obviously been raped by Nate. He says you have to choose who lives and who dies. Who do you choose Sarah or Becca(They are tied up as well).
I don't like either of them, but I'm guessing this happens after you have time to create a bound with Shel and Becca as well. Because if don't you are asking for Clementine to save someone she knows for someone she doesn't know.
I would choose to save Sarah if you don't get to bound with them before I will obviously (as Clementine), because Clementine knows her and Carlos. If we get to bound it would depend a lot on how changed Shel and Becca are, but I guess I would save Sarah also. I guess I just like Sarah more than Becca just because Sarah is still a kid and Becca is a little more grown up.
i always thought save luke or save kenny(if he comes back)maybe you would choose luke cause hes not broken or kenny because you want to give him a second chance to protect his family.I love Luke but Kenny all the way
Whoa...
That would be hard to make... I never liked Kenny is season 1 but I understood what he made, so him, coming back in season 2, whould depend on how he's... But choosing between someone I know I might consider a jerk and might not like, but I respect and know he can protect Clem (Kenny) and someone I just met and besides him seeming kind off nice to Clem I don't know I well he can protect Clem (Luke)...
I guess I would go with Kenny if I had to choose now without any more interaction with Luke or Kenny
You are being hunted by a group of scavengers, when a series of military helicopters start to pass over. Do you light a flare? Will the military ignore you? Will the scavengers see the flare?
Vernon! Obvious!
Sarah is older than Becca. Sarah is 15 and Becca is either 12 or 13. And you would get to bond with Becca.
Really? In my heda Becca is like 17 or something :P
I would save Sarah I guess, it's a hard one
Where did I get the flare? :P
AH AH just kidding, assuming we had a flare, I would not light it, it would atract scavengers attention too and I'm guessing they would get to me faster than the guys in the military helicopters I would just hide and wait for the helicopters to come back or follow the direction they were going....
Something I thought would be really cool if done properly would be inadvertedly picking who dies on a later episode. What I mean is that there's an important choice early in the season (which would appear at the end of the episode) that would trigger a series of events that lead to one of two character dying, depending on what you did earlier.
For example, let's say Christa joins the group early in episode 2 just so that I can make some sense out of what I'm saying. Also, let's say Nick survives no matter what you picked in the river while Pete only survives if you picked him. If you saved Pete, he'll immediate strike up a friendship with Christa but she has a hard time forgiving Nick for his behaviour in the first episode. As the season progresses Christa will become even better friends with Pete (again, if you saved him) but will remain cold towards Nick. On episode 4/5, Christa and Rebecca will find themselves in some sort of trouble and only Nick, you and possibly Pete can save them. If only Nick is there, he'll go after Rebecca no matter what you tell him. However, if Pete is there, he'll go after Christa (he could die in the process) and Nick will, for some reason (maybe you'll assist Pete instead of Nick), fail to.save Rebecca. To summarize, having Pete in the group means Christa lives while not having him means Rebecca lives.
Decisión (Episode 1): Go after Pete or Nick in the river.
Result (Episode 4/5): If you picked Pete, Rebecca dies. If you picked Nick, Christa dies.
Even if you don't like my example, it's the general idea I'm proposing. This would have to be done VERY well so as not to pest people off but I think Telltale could do it. It would definitely make people get paranoid about their choices and would catch us by complete surprise.
Cool idea. +1 to you.
Cool idea. Here's mine:
You have to pick a side. I'm assuming that event would be near the end of episode 3, throughout episode 4 everyone on both sides besides Clem ends up killing each other (the leaders die in the conflict) besides one or two people from either group, leading to Clem and those 2-4 people grouping up out of necessity, putting the story back on the rails, but still heavily influencing reactions/interactions from those 2-4 characters depending on your choice for the last two episodes.
I also like the idea of being able to choose neither side, or trying to stop the fighting.
For lack of a better example of main well known characters that hate each other, I'll just use Kenny and Lilly. This idea could work with any major characters they introduce into the season however. I think the Kenny/Lilly version is more intense though.
EG Kenny's group and Lilly's group in the background are about to annihilate each other (they aren't the leaders of their group btw), they are wrestling/trying to hatchet each other over a handgun, Clem gets the gun, and they each tell Clem to shoot the other. If Clem shoots Kenny, Lilly and one other of her friends from her group that she saves from the conflict will be travelling with Clem for the other half of the episode. If she shoots Lilly, It's Kenny and one of his friends. If Clem shoots one of them, they are non fatally wounded, and Clem and the other one escape and rescue on of their own friends from their own group.
Near the end of episode 4, the 'friend' character is killed by walkers or circumstance, and the person Clem shot shows up at the beginning of episode 5, with the other character taking pity on their injured state and taking them along. Episode 5 is a 3 character episode, Clem, Kenny and Lilly, with their attitudes and reactions changed according to Clem's/your actions so far in the story.
Alternatively, Clem can (by pointing the mouse at Clem's head instead of at Lilly or Kenny) can threaten them to drop her weapons or she will kill herself. In this route, Kenny and Lilly stay with Clem throughout the remainder of episode 4 and 5. Kenny and Lilly in their attempt to save Clem from herself, cannot save their other two friends from their own groups, who perishes in the battle without their assistance.
With everyone else dead and their commitments to their respective groups gone, Kenny and Lilly have nothing else to do but try to take care of Clementine.
I would put more emphasis on the mercy kill or walk away option. Like Sam, is the mercy killing worth the effort? Can you bring yourself to do it?
Can you bear to walk away and just leave her there to die painfully?