Don't be surprised if it's Herschel.

13»

Comments

  • edited February 2014

    Hershel leaves his farm after it gets too dangerous and lives in a prison with a bunch of other survivors. They get attacked by a guy calling himself the Governor. The Governor drives a tank through the prison's fences and shoots Hershel in the face when he surrenders.

    Speaking as someone who has never read the comics, how does herschel end up in prison ? - and how'd he die there.

  • Season two takes place two years later. At this time in the comics Hershel is dead, why are you arguing when all the evidence is against you?

    Sadly my friend it could actually be him. He hasn't left his farm in the game yet, or we do not know.

  • bubbledncrbubbledncr Telltale Alumni

    Confirming, for those who had doubts.

    DougGreene posted: »

    Comic Glenn and Comic Hershel are the same as Game Glenn and Game Hershel. The game just takes place months prior to the comic.

  • Game, comic and tv world are the same, but TV series are based to the comics, so is game too. When glenn leaved, he went to Atlanta, found rick and (. SPOILER. ) now he is dead. Hershel is also dead. Get over it.

    So you really believe the game and the tv show world are mixed together? So you believe that when Glen left us in like ep. 1 or beginning of e

  • It's almost as if the closer we get to the release of episode two or the further we get away from the release of episode one, the theroys get stupider and or crazier.

  • You are right my "theroy' is so stupid and crazy.

    MegaMoto posted: »

    It's almost as if the closer we get to the release of episode two or the further we get away from the release of episode one, the theroys get stupider and or crazier.

  • edited February 2014

    Look out we have a grammar badass over here!

    Seriously, its your opinion man, but please for the love of all things good make a valid argument and quit with the grammar nitpicking. Its just annoying and doesn't add to the discussion of who it may be that's still alive.

    You are right my "theroy' is so stupid and crazy.

  • In fairness if it wasn't due to be disproven by the canon your theory would otherwise be fairly plausible.

    You are right my "theroy' is so stupid and crazy.

  • edited February 2014

    Alt text

  • Well when you think about it man you should have your grammar in check a little before you insult someone.

    Look out we have a grammar badass over here! Seriously, its your opinion man, but please for the love of all things good make a valid argum

  • I think that its Kenny-mostly because they have kinda foreshadowed his return with the picture that Clem keeps of Lee and Kenny. This tells me that it is most likely Kenny.

    Either that or its Lily and Telltale is once again fucking with us while we wait for the release of the next episode

    DogRocket23 posted: »

    In my opinion the most likely person is Lilly. No matter your choice with Lilly in season 1 she gets away. She seemed like a woman who would

  • edited February 2014

    Excuse me for not making sure my grammar is %100 before telling you your idea is stupid and crazy. Guess what though ? Grammar being wrong doesn't make the argument invalid... Well unless it's like Heshle is't ded. Anyway I'm not insulting you, I don't even know you. I am however insulting your idea that doesn't even work on the canonical level.

    Well when you think about it man you should have your grammar in check a little before you insult someone.

  • edited February 2014

    I don't get it... Clem has never thought that Herschel was dead. She has not even talked or thought about him.

  • I don't think it's Hershel. Look at Clementine's reaction, she doesn't really look happy, more shocked.

  • I think it could be... Lilly or Christine

    I don't think it's Hershel. Look at Clementine's reaction, she doesn't really look happy, more shocked.

  • You just made me burst out laughing.

  • But that's the question I keep asking myself, would Clem have any reason to believe that either Lilly or Christa to be dead? I, in my opinion, believe that Kenny would be the only option as to the fact that you never actually see him die but have to guess his fate. Lilly was resourceful and even if you just left her on the road side I think she would gave had more than a fighting chance at survival, and Christa could have just been taken hostage because Clem still claims that she's separated from her group. But I could be wrong this is just my opinion and I could be wrong, for all I know it could be Andy St.John if that's even possible.

    HasongLee posted: »

    I think it could be... Lilly or Christine

  • [removed]

  • Cuz Clem heard the gun shot after she ran away from Christa while she was in danger. And... yeah.. Lilly could not be important to Clem.. There's no one that Clem can expect, even Kenny is not, cuz she didn't even saw him dead or survived.

    But that's the question I keep asking myself, would Clem have any reason to believe that either Lilly or Christa to be dead? I, in my opinion,

  • Let this thread die.

  • That is fucking aweful lol

  • I didn't even think of the gunshot. Gonna have to do another play through to refresh myself. Thank you for the info that may lead to an plausible choice of who it could be.

    HasongLee posted: »

    Cuz Clem heard the gun shot after she ran away from Christa while she was in danger. And... yeah.. Lilly could not be important to Clem.. There's no one that Clem can expect, even Kenny is not, cuz she didn't even saw him dead or survived.

  • bubbledncrbubbledncr Telltale Alumni

    We follow the comics as cannon, yes. In both Season 1 and Season 2.

  • And by surrender you mean lose the will to live? :P

  • Not to be a critic but the governor cut Hershel's head off. And don't forget about Maggie's sister Beth :).

  • edited February 2014

    No the game is tied with the comic not the tv show Hershel is shot in the comic and Beth does not exist in the comics

  • edited February 2014

    Umm not to burst your bubble but according to Kevin Bruner the game is NOT CANON with the comics or the television show.

    https://www.telltalegames.com/community/discussion/51778/things-confirmed-from-the-reddit-discussion/p2

    You can follow the links to the REDDIT interview where Kevin Bruner confirms that. Perhaps the office water has been spiked? It would explain these ridiculous wait times between episodes.

    bubbledncr posted: »

    We follow the comics as cannon, yes. In both Season 1 and Season 2.

  • The comic and game are set in the same universe, not game and tv show -.-

  • bubbledncrbubbledncr Telltale Alumni

    Clicked the link and searched the entire interview for the word "comic," only relevant thing I found was Dan saying

    "Well the game will be in canon and we are always looking for ways to connect to the Comic and Show but haven't found the right fit yet."

    Glanced through most of the Kevin responses and didn't see anything related. So I dunno. I just know from working on the game, that yes, it's cannon to the comics.

    CiscoKidd81 posted: »

    Umm not to burst your bubble but according to Kevin Bruner the game is NOT CANON with the comics or the television show. https://www.tellta

  • Well I will take that. Thanks for going that extra mile. Don't forget to party like a rock star this weekend.

    bubbledncr posted: »

    Clicked the link and searched the entire interview for the word "comic," only relevant thing I found was Dan saying "Well the game will be

  • edited February 2014

    From Kevin:

    Comment on 'Things Confirmed from the REDDIT Discussion'

    Hey Guys,

    My canon comment was supposed to be about The Wolf Among Us (which IS canon in the Fables universe), not The Walking Dead, which is obviously NOT canon.

    October 29, 2013 06:43 PM

    I'd like to help to link the post, but this forum (or me) is so obtuse I can't do it.

    bubbledncr posted: »

    Clicked the link and searched the entire interview for the word "comic," only relevant thing I found was Dan saying "Well the game will be

  • Can a mod kill this thread already?

  • edited February 2014

    Alt text

Sign in to comment in this discussion.