If you could change the walking dead s1 story..
What would you change, what dialogue options would you add, what choices would you add, would you change outcomes of some decisions?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
What would you change, what dialogue options would you add, what choices would you add, would you change outcomes of some decisions?
Comments
Was there ever any doubt? And yes, i think i would've changed some more things as well. But first things first.
I'd like the option to play as Freddy Krueger and to toy with Rebecca in her dreams eventually leading to her demise.
Kenny rides in on his flaming tiger at the end with the cure to the zombie virus and saves Clem and Lee, then resurrects Chuck and they all fly into the sunset.
Lee would survive. As in, not get bitten in the first place so he can keep his arm.
If I wrote season 1, it probably wouldn't have won game of the year. That narrative was one of the best in gaming history.
One thing I'd change is Chuck getting killed in episode 4.
I'd have him surviving to help Lee find Clemintine.
To me, Chuck was a good guy, and I think it's a damn shame that his character was killed off so quickly.
I'd also change Lee's death.
Instead of it being him and Clementine, I'd have Kenny by his side as well.
After Lee dies, I'd have the player take control of Kenny and lead Clementine out of the store.
And have him be the next playable character of season 2, and Clementine's new guardian.
Lee would survive, Carley would survive as well. Ben would have died right off the bat.
I would have the option to kill Larry WAAAAY earlier. Like right after you leave the pharmacy.
Another thing I'd change is, having the option to go on more supply runs.
And being able to run into more survivors.
Have the option of questioning them, and then based on those questions, decide whether or not to let them join or not.
I would have Molly return in episode 5, and possibly save Kenny.
That's how they should have survived!
On a serious note thoug...i hated the "supposed" Kenny death scene when you decided to save Ben. They could have just shot him and get out of the alleyway. The scene where Kenny saved Christa was a much better way for him to get his Redemption.
But it's not quite as full of redemption as part of that is in him saving Ben....
Ideally the situation would have been the same, just Ben would have jumped into the building instead of Christa.
I seriously would not change a thing it's good the way it is.
The best would have been if Kenny did just put Ben out of his myseri and saying something emotional like " I forgive you" and then let the Christa scene happen afterwards.
Hmm. It's a really fantastic game just as it is. Something that could be interesting though would be if Lee had actually survived but we'd still play as Clem in this season. That Lee, I this season, acted based on how we played him last season. I don't know if it would work, and people might not be as happy about playing as Clem if that was the case. But I still think it could have been interesting.
Imagine if finding the pills for Larry in the drugstore was on a timer, so if you took too long he would just die.
I would have just saved Glenn and then sat out front joking with Doug until Larry died.
One word. Aliens
Shawn, Chuck and Larry are savable.
Liberty city
Who said she didn't? You can't disproof it!
I think that would be interesting actually. I would love to see Lee and Clem together again.
Save Duck or Shawn, Neither, Save Carley or DucK, Neither, Save Pete or Nick? Neither
I prefer this scenario.
But...no Staches involved in this Scenario! Please rethink your decision again!
I'd like for Doug to die in the same place but Carley to actually live a bit longer, maybe to make the choice matter, and then have Carley save Ben, but Kenny still "sacrifice" himself to give them enough time.
Then the S2 group would've been Christa, Omid, Carley, and Ben... Well, maybe Ben.
And in the situation where Christa falls, everything goes the same, except Carley is still alive obviously.
Also, spoiler possibly, I'd like Omid to live in S2...
Clearly the unicorn was living in Kenny's moustache the whole time. Therefore, Kenny's UnicornStache is directly involved.
True...it's so obvious! Why didn't i think about it? I gues you are right after all!
You don't have to save Shawn or Duck, you can just stand there. Eventually Kenny will get Duck then Shawn will yell for your help again but if you stand there for a few seconds then you don't do anything and the game continues with Shawn dying.
I think it could've been interesting to have Larry last longer depending on your choices. Conflict with Kenny might reach a new height, but Lilly remains stable, etc. And Larry might reveal some hidden depth as he grows to hate you slightly less.
Also, I would have changed up Kenny's ending scenario with Ben. Unless Kenny was conclusively wanting to die, it was clearly avoidable. Either follow through with the sentiment of "I either save the kid or get to see her," and have him ready to end things in the alley, or make saving Ben seem less impossible.
If the chances to save Ben were plainly low but still had a slight chance (like having him impaled and caught on his shoulder instead), trying to stay with him would be less suicidal, and having to finally put him out of his misery before the walkers came would have been more tragic.
and How the hell did he get under the tractor?
The walkers were attracted because Duck accidentally started the tractor while nobody was watching him, it went forward and crushed Shawn's leg.
I had this idea about a bonding/frienship score system in the game, which would've determined the ending. You could earn points by choosing the best possible answer in every scene, and my theory is that If you always chose the best answer for Clem throughout the whole season - thought it's hard to tell which one would qualify as best, I would say the one that made her feel the best in that given situation, so sometimes you would've had to lie - thus gaining maximum bonding points, then at the end after Clem shoots/lets Lee turn she eventually takes her own life.
I know, dark shit.
...I'm not saying she didn't, I'm saying I would have liked to see it if she did.
In fact, Molly saving Kenny is just about the only logical way that Kenny could survive, in my opinion.
There are alot of ways he could have survived in the scene where he saved Christa....it was a dark room with many doors and windows and we never saw him dieing or heard any eating sounds. It's a little bit trickyer at the Ben scene. There was one window aswell and there also was a sewer intro where he could have jumped in, but it just seemed alot harder to accomplish.
mean shawn was not frosty when the truck started