Gnome Appearances [Spoilers]

Graywing

I've got the feeling the Gnome Appearances puzzle answer is incorrect.. from my recollection of space thingies, the moon orbits earth in a counter-clockwise direction, but the game only accepts the answer to be given clockwise.

The answer would be correct if either you're supposed to submit the answer chronologically reversed, or the moon passed 90% of its previous orbit with each picture.

(don't pin me on this one, I know the gnomes are also part of the solution neither am I an expert on big orbiting space rocks)


Figure 1: The directions of the orbits of the earth and moon.

source

henke37

Imagine that Fig 1 was a photo taken from a camera in outerspace at distance X from the sun. Now imagine a similar photo taken at distance -X from the sun, on the other side. Problem solved.

Graywing

henke37 wrote: »

Imagine that Fig 1 was a photo taken from a camera in outerspace at distance X from the sun. Now imagine a similar photo taken at distance -X from the sun, on the other side. Problem solved.

if the view is upside down (southpole) the moon would indeed orbit clockwise. It is possible but not really common sense.

Molokov

In space, there is no up and down North & South are earth-based designations. Why would pictures showing the moon revolving around the earth from the south pole be any less common-sense than one from the north pole?

Ignatius

I failed this puzzle a first time because i order the pictures in a counter-clockwise order.

Failed it a second time when i thought that maybe the gnomes were leaving earth instead of arriving.

It was at the very last that i thought on a clockwise orbit.