Clem drowns, what do you do?
A lot can be said about Kenny and Lilly's loyalty to family members. They constantly put the group at risk and make decisions seemingly solely based on who they're related to sometimes, but what would you do?
Here's the hypothetical: Clem is drowning and you pull her out. She's not breathing and you can't feel a pulse.* You're trapped on a boat so you can't leave. Also, everybody in the group is weak from lack of food.
The group wants to kill her before she turns. You could try giving her CPR or back off and let them kill her. What do you do?
*Young children may have a mammalian diving reflex. When they are suddenly immersed in cold water less than 68F (20C), they can stop breathing, slow their heart rate dramatically, and shunt all the blood flow to the heart and brain. Though not common, these children may be resuscitated and return to normal function. Cases have been reported of survival, even after being underwater for an hour.
Here's the hypothetical: Clem is drowning and you pull her out. She's not breathing and you can't feel a pulse.* You're trapped on a boat so you can't leave. Also, everybody in the group is weak from lack of food.
The group wants to kill her before she turns. You could try giving her CPR or back off and let them kill her. What do you do?
*Young children may have a mammalian diving reflex. When they are suddenly immersed in cold water less than 68F (20C), they can stop breathing, slow their heart rate dramatically, and shunt all the blood flow to the heart and brain. Though not common, these children may be resuscitated and return to normal function. Cases have been reported of survival, even after being underwater for an hour.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Admirable and brave. She could turn and bite your mouth off when you're giving her mouth to mouth. Then again, she could live. Bold gamble.
So you take the pragmatic choice and kill Clem. That's tough.
I would recommend a spotter, preferably helping to hold her down. Walkers aren't known for moving fast, even the cop had small movements prior to lurching to life.
Worry about the rest later.
I think it would be an interesting way to end the season.
You choose to kill Clem then you have to live with that. You choose to save her, it's random if she turns or lives. You may get as close to a happy ending as possible or she turns and kills Lee.
No matter what happened, what you choose, you wouldn't forget the end. I doubt Telltale has the guts to do this, though it would be epic.
well it might be too late in that situation.
I doubt anyone will forget the Mass Effect 3 ending any time soon, that doesn't necessarily make it a good ending though.
duck and larry i understand, but lil cute innocent clem ?!
i'd give her some arm bands or make sure she could swim first heck even going in with her just incase..
if i had to do cpr i'd give her till i was exhausted and then if she turned just accept it my life is over i could never get over killing her regardless of reason..( a child doesn't need as much strength compared to an adult.. )
so i'd leave it to the group if was in one then hate them all for ending her 'suffering'
i'm sicken by you 'kill clem' people...
That is what I would do too.
Kill the girl. I would kill my own mother if it meant saving others.
IN TWD?
Save.
Save.
Save.
Save.
And then try multiple options 8)
That's true. I think were mad that there was no epilogue also.
And what I'm suggesting is a little different is there is way to live or even if you choose the risky route you can live. Shepard was a goner regardless.
I don't know if that will make a difference. People hate to see beloved characters die. It does tend to upset them.
It doesn't and in fact isn't recommended for adult heart attack patients. For children, especially near-drowning, it is needed.
Source: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/23884566/ns/health-heart_health/t/no-mouth-to-mouth-required-new-cpr-rules/
Lee is a college professor, and Kenny is a redneck.
If your average forum going internet-ite knows... you can assume they know.
Clem is dead or on the verge of death, do you really want to take the time to try to beat Kenny up? Clem may not have that kind of time.
Maybe Lilly puts a shotgun to Kenny's head or if you helped Kenny kill Larry, she doesn't. That would suck! Some people would be going back to replay from episode 2 just to save Clem!
Most wouldn't though because most chose to try to save Larry.
The characters seemed to know that in regard to Larry.
We were wrong though! haha
Researching, I think there is some confusion and lack of knowledge on my part. So to clarify, for an adult having a heart attack, it's not needed. For a child that is near-drowning, it is needed.
"In a major change, the American Heart Association said Monday that hands-only CPR — rapid, deep presses on the victim’s chest until help arrives — works just as well as standard CPR for sudden cardiac arrest in adults.
"A child who collapses is more likely to primarily have breathing problems — and in that case, mouth-to-mouth breathing should be used. That also applies to adults who suffer lack of oxygen from a near-drowning, drug overdose, or carbon monoxide poisoning. In these cases, people need mouth-to-mouth to get air into their lungs and bloodstream."
Source: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/23884566/ns/health-heart_health/t/no-mouth-to-mouth-required-new-cpr-rules/
True Enough Carley can pull a gun on Kenny or Lily can. or both . Still I'm not going to try resucitation knowing Kenny might smash her head in. If he did I'd knock his ass down then kill Kaatja and Duck in front of him before killing him last.
well jesus.:eek: I mean yeah me too for sure but you dont type that out...darkness has to stay in the dark
people have talked about doing much worse to duck. I didn't say kaatja and ducks demises would be slow and painful. But Kenny would learn in his last moments what he had done to l/mee. I don't trust kenny near clem at all anymore.
I pray to Odin you mean that in a way of telling us to shut up.
Well, is very TWD to fuck you mind like that isn't? You protect her, but she still dies in the end.. (-_-)> <(click)
The first in kick his mom off the boat!? xD Well, kill xP
If children need mouth to mouth, I would quickly try to brace her mouth open with something so that she could not close her jaw in order to bite me. Barring that you could try forcing the mouth shut and forcing oxygen through the nose.
attempt everything to save her. Anyone tries to kill her, bullet in the head.
She isn't real, its fine.
"Excuse me Milo.. Could I talk to you over here in private. What's that?? Yeah, right over here... By this salt lick."
joking/not real aside
ttg would be taking a huge risk killing any kid in a game.
i don't understand why anyone would justify killing children turning/undead/dying or other wise..
it's just plain wrong..part of my upbringing i guess..
what are the mods view on it ??