I'm pretty sure this poll was made before Episode 5, which is why I voted for Duck. I'd change it to either Kenny or Lee though, because they were bros in my game and seeing both of them go in the same episode really got to me.
I know this poll was created before my first choice died, but here's my reasoning anyway.
I had to pick Other because it was Lee - not necessarily because he died, but because of the last conversation. That was so hard to watch - I could put myself in both Lee's shoes, only worried about Clem being OK, or I could put myself in Clem's shoes, watching her father figure die minutes after seeing her real parents as walkers.
Second was probably Duck. Kenny's "death" got me because I wanted to see him through to the end, but watching Katjaa and Kenny watch their little boy die was heartbreaking. You could literally watch them go through all of the stages of grief throughout the episode. And then when you come across the little boy in the mansion - watching Kenny's face was tough.
I have cried at many points, I cried when Carley died, not on the spot but when Katjaa talked about her. I cried when Ben and "Kenny" died, and of course the end.
Carley: I was horrified at the suddenness of her death, and how it came from within the group. (no regrets leaving Lilly behind. No way I'm having Clem around a crazy woman who shoots people in the head over an insult)
Kenny: In my playthrough he sacrificed himself to save Christa. Just made me tear up since there was that symmetry to it; he couldn't save his own wife and child so he gave up his life to save another man's wife and child....
And now that I'm done....
Lee: I decided not to make Clem kill me. Seems kind of pointless, but I spent my game building my relationship with her and I didn't want her to have to kill someone she liked.
Carley's pissed me off so much, I just wanted to shoot Lilly in the face.
Duck's and Katjaa's broke my heart and I thought it couldn't get worse but I lost my shit when Lee died, I'M WELLING UP JUST THINKING ABOUT IT. God I've never cried at a game so much.
I was pissed when the Stranger tried to make me feel bad for ditching Lilly. The woman shot someone in the face for calling her out on her bullshit. Definitely don't want anyone that unstable in my group. She'd probably survive on her own since she's so trigger happy.
The first time I heard that I thought it was the girl at the beginning of Episode 3, the one with the choice. When I found out he meant Lilly lets just say I was unhappy.
The first time I heard that I thought it was the girl at the beginning of Episode 3, the one with the choice. When I found out he meant Lilly lets just say I was unhappy.
Now that you mention it, I did feel pretty upset with the girl's death in episode 3. I chose not to shoot her and the game punished me by playing the audio of her screaming....and screaming.....and screaming.....
I am legitimately interested if anyone felt emotional over people like the Saint Johns, I felt maybe a little bit bad but that's it.
I killed Danny because he was so messed up. However Clementine saw it and it made me feel bad so I decided not to kill the mum or Andy..... I thought it was crueller to leave him alive, but I was feeling really depressed by the end of that episode.
I am legitimately interested if anyone felt emotional over people like the Saint Johns, I felt maybe a little bit bad but that's it.
Only bad thing I felt about 'em was, that they, well... at least Andrew seemed like a more than okay guy, he was quite the kind, decent type of man I guess, well you know, despite being a cannibal.
Someone who could have been useful as well, as he seemed to maintain the generators just fine, but things turned out for the worse I guess. After what they've done, death is what they deserve though...
Comments
I think this poll was made before the final episode was released, so that might explain why Lee's not in it.
Mark's was the most upsetting because they had locked him up and were torturing him to death. That episode made me really squeamish...
Also, Irene's death was quite sad. (The woman in episode one who wanted to commit suicide)
I had to pick Other because it was Lee - not necessarily because he died, but because of the last conversation. That was so hard to watch - I could put myself in both Lee's shoes, only worried about Clem being OK, or I could put myself in Clem's shoes, watching her father figure die minutes after seeing her real parents as walkers.
Second was probably Duck. Kenny's "death" got me because I wanted to see him through to the end, but watching Katjaa and Kenny watch their little boy die was heartbreaking. You could literally watch them go through all of the stages of grief throughout the episode. And then when you come across the little boy in the mansion - watching Kenny's face was tough.
Kenny: In my playthrough he sacrificed himself to save Christa. Just made me tear up since there was that symmetry to it; he couldn't save his own wife and child so he gave up his life to save another man's wife and child....
And now that I'm done....
Lee: I decided not to make Clem kill me. Seems kind of pointless, but I spent my game building my relationship with her and I didn't want her to have to kill someone she liked.
Katjaa: Poor woman
Duck's and Katjaa's broke my heart and I thought it couldn't get worse but I lost my shit when Lee died, I'M WELLING UP JUST THINKING ABOUT IT. God I've never cried at a game so much.
Now that you mention it, I did feel pretty upset with the girl's death in episode 3. I chose not to shoot her and the game punished me by playing the audio of her screaming....and screaming.....and screaming.....
I killed Danny because he was so messed up. However Clementine saw it and it made me feel bad so I decided not to kill the mum or Andy..... I thought it was crueller to leave him alive, but I was feeling really depressed by the end of that episode.
Only bad thing I felt about 'em was, that they, well... at least Andrew seemed like a more than okay guy, he was quite the kind, decent type of man I guess, well you know, despite being a cannibal.
Someone who could have been useful as well, as he seemed to maintain the generators just fine, but things turned out for the worse I guess. After what they've done, death is what they deserve though...