And sometimes I'm of the same opinion as Lilly and sometimes Kenny and when possible, I tell them both to grow up. I suspect that's how a lot of people play.
Exactly, its hard for me to take a side because since reading all the threads, I can appreciate both of them equally. Lily's bad attitude rubs alot of people the wrong way, jading their view of her (even though I think she is the better of the two) but, she doesnt have a spouse and child to look after and that is why I can respect Kenny's stance just as much as Lily's. If people werent so put off with her mouth, I think they would see that to Lily, the group is her family.
Not in a Hallmark moment kind of way, but in that she is looking out for them all equally.
Let's not go turning this thread into yet ANOTHER Lilly V Kenny thread. I've seen enough of those to make my hair go gray.
Agreed.
It's possible to rationalize any decision you make in this game and because they are all questionable (i.e. killing, stealing), everyone defends their decisions in order to feel justified in making them.
It will be interesting to see how Telltale makes these decisions count.
I shot her. What's the point of living if you have no humanity? Might as well be the walkers.
What does living have to do with having no humanity? Take the shot and you attract walkers which could have easily surrounded the building and killed you both. That lady was dead already. We had people (including Clem) to get back to.
Not only from the moral implications (leave her to die painfully or mercifully spare her the pain), I think it adds a lot more tension to the looting part because it forces you to act fast. That way you can really push yourself to see how much you can gather on a time limit.
I had to get supplies for the group, and she was going to die anyway. No point in risking me and Kenny's lives just to put a random girl out of her misery, especially since she would die anyway seconds later.
Okay so when Lee and Kenny are out hunting for supplies and the girl comes out screaming, and you have the choice to either shoot or not shoot, what did you decide and how does it effect the story?
I chose to leave her as a distraction, I thought the zombies might come after me.
I chose to shoot her and then Kenny started berating me so I wondered if I made a mistake. I just didnt want to use this poor woman as bait.
I shot her and I gathered most of the supplies (do not remember how much exactly). Later Kenny tried to use it against me in the argument with Lilly "Lee, here, shot a girl instead of letting her being eaten alive". Lilly, Katjaa and Carley looked at him as if he had gone mad.
In my opinion Kenny is becoming more of a monster with each episode.
It will be interesting how far he'll go now when his family is dead. Is he gonna wake up or actually get even worse?
Go back and listen carefully to what he says, Kenny says it was the first *Smart* thing you've done in awhile, implying he thought it was the right thing to do, he was using it against lily, not you.
I shot her, but the situation didn´t make sense. Those zombies are slow and she run very well, so she can join the group if want... why did she just stays waiting for dead? Stupid.
I let her die. I kinda considered saving her, but then she got bitten.
From the point of view of both the bitten person and the man with the gun, I can say I'd be happy with that decision. If I'm bitten, I'm dead. That's it, Game Over. The only thing you can really do to help me is making my death less painful, but if that's at the possible cost of the well being of people who actually have a chance to survive? Leave me to die. No sense in getting yourselves killed, as well. I have the same way of thinking from Lee's point of view
...At least, that's how I think of it in the theoretical sense. If this were an actual scenario, who knows how I'd react?
I shot her, but the situation didn´t make sense. Those zombies are slow and she run very well, so she can join the group if want... why did she just stays waiting for dead? Stupid.
She was surrounded and probably not thinking straight. Also, she was bitten in the leg shortly after running out of the store, so she couldn't join the group even if Lee and Kenny had somehow killed all the walkers.
This was one of the toughest choices for me, along with not killing Larry and taking Lilly with me.
I'm not sure if I made the right choice in this matter, but truthfully, is either choice 'right'? In one option we put down a girl who will die regardless so she won't suffer. But doing so, we risk our lives and the lives of our group.
The first time I shot her, but I didn't want to get on Kenny's bad side, since he was already mad at me about not helping him kill Larry. He's one of my closest friends. Plus I only gathered 9 things.
I then with back to try again. This time, I didn't shoot her. I got 17 things. I felt so guilty as I listened to her screams, but otherwise we could die. And if we die... What about the rest of the group?
I have to say, I went with the second choice. I wouldn't of if she hadn't been bitten, but...
I let her be eaten (my mother did, also) because my group and its well-being is far more important than a basically-dead woman running around in circles and screaming at the top of her lungs. I don't see how she survived for so long.
I left her because she was screaming so freaking loud, she could've easily outran those few zombies. I felt bad though because Kenny bragged about it to the whole group =.=
Besides affecting Kenny's disposition towards you, TTG could have actually made the scene in the pharmacy a lot harder if you did shoot the girl. As it stands right now, you can still loot everything whether you shot Beatrice or not if you click fast enough.
I shot her. I put myself in her shoes, I'd want someone to shoot me in that situation so I treated her like how I'd like to get treated. It's as simple as that.
I shot her. I stand by my signature, and i try to never let another survivor suffer as best i can. As CarScar said, if i too were there surrounded by walkers and had been bitten, i would hope someone would end my suffering rather than let me die in pain and misery.
I left her, If she had not been bitten of course I would try to save her, plus I was playing my 'Kenny's Bitch' playthrough. Perhaps when I do 'Lily's Bitch' I'll shoot her.
Shot her and still got enough supplies to make everyone happy. Next run left her got all the supplies because I was curious to see if it affected the story...it didn't. The choice to shoot or not really has no significant bearing on the outcome of the story and is meant to serve as a moral test. Are you like Lee who still feels compassion for his fellow human beings, or are you like Kenny who is steadily losing it? Shoot her or not, though, it does'nt affect the outcome. However much you bring back, its all still lost to the bandits after your escape during the raid.
Left her, she gives you more time to loot the shop, I wasn't gonna shoot her and then gain uneccesary attention to myself. Our group is more important than one stupid woman who clearly decided to get herself into that position and either way she would have ended up dead. And Kenny then goes and tells the group about it well, if I remember rightly he was the one who said to leave her.
Kenny is a bit off sometimes but I can't help but like him... But I left that woman she was just a distraction to allow me to get as much as I could from the shop.
I mercy killed her. From a zombie survivalist point of view, it was a stupid move that would have gotten Lee and Kenny killed, but I didn't regret it one bit.
At least I knew that I spared a complete stranger from having to face an unnecessarily long and painful death, just for a risky chance that I might have a little more time to scavenge a few more items out of the shop before we were inevitably found.
I left her, since she was dead either way. If she hadn't been bit and/or Lee was alone, it would've been a more difficult choice.
I took it as a case where morality was in the eye of the beholder. Would it have been any less moral to immediately risk the life of the guy I was with (and I don't like Kenny in the least) and potentially the rest of the group for the sake of a "clear" conscience?
Like a lot of the choices, I saw it as a choice of whether I wanted my poo sandwich on wheat or white bread.
I shot her the first time by accident...i was trying to clear out a running lane for her and restarted the system right when i shot her...i was like WTF??
next time around...i realised it was a moral decision and you cant saver her life...so i chose to save ours. i left her.
stupid girl every first person shooting gamer knows to serpentine SERPENTINE!
Comments
ROFL.
Indeed.
Exactly, its hard for me to take a side because since reading all the threads, I can appreciate both of them equally. Lily's bad attitude rubs alot of people the wrong way, jading their view of her (even though I think she is the better of the two) but, she doesnt have a spouse and child to look after and that is why I can respect Kenny's stance just as much as Lily's. If people werent so put off with her mouth, I think they would see that to Lily, the group is her family.
Not in a Hallmark moment kind of way, but in that she is looking out for them all equally.
Agreed.
It's possible to rationalize any decision you make in this game and because they are all questionable (i.e. killing, stealing), everyone defends their decisions in order to feel justified in making them.
It will be interesting to see how Telltale makes these decisions count.
What does living have to do with having no humanity? Take the shot and you attract walkers which could have easily surrounded the building and killed you both. That lady was dead already. We had people (including Clem) to get back to.
I had to get supplies for the group, and she was going to die anyway. No point in risking me and Kenny's lives just to put a random girl out of her misery, especially since she would die anyway seconds later.
I chose to shoot her and then Kenny started berating me so I wondered if I made a mistake. I just didnt want to use this poor woman as bait.
these are important things to know. Not everybody is worth saving.
Go back and listen carefully to what he says, Kenny says it was the first *Smart* thing you've done in awhile, implying he thought it was the right thing to do, he was using it against lily, not you.
my record is 15 items.... almost there
From the point of view of both the bitten person and the man with the gun, I can say I'd be happy with that decision. If I'm bitten, I'm dead. That's it, Game Over. The only thing you can really do to help me is making my death less painful, but if that's at the possible cost of the well being of people who actually have a chance to survive? Leave me to die. No sense in getting yourselves killed, as well. I have the same way of thinking from Lee's point of view
...At least, that's how I think of it in the theoretical sense. If this were an actual scenario, who knows how I'd react?
She was surrounded and probably not thinking straight. Also, she was bitten in the leg shortly after running out of the store, so she couldn't join the group even if Lee and Kenny had somehow killed all the walkers.
Those freaking screams, man. Kudos to the voice actress.
she could've ran in a straight line silently and survived, she died because she ran in GODDAMN circles...
How did she even make it this far?
I'm not sure if I made the right choice in this matter, but truthfully, is either choice 'right'? In one option we put down a girl who will die regardless so she won't suffer. But doing so, we risk our lives and the lives of our group.
The first time I shot her, but I didn't want to get on Kenny's bad side, since he was already mad at me about not helping him kill Larry. He's one of my closest friends. Plus I only gathered 9 things.
I then with back to try again. This time, I didn't shoot her. I got 17 things. I felt so guilty as I listened to her screams, but otherwise we could die. And if we die... What about the rest of the group?
I have to say, I went with the second choice. I wouldn't of if she hadn't been bitten, but...
Hopefully I made the right decision.
Also.....
Cuz running in circles was such a smart plan
Kenny is a bit off sometimes but I can't help but like him... But I left that woman she was just a distraction to allow me to get as much as I could from the shop.
At least I knew that I spared a complete stranger from having to face an unnecessarily long and painful death, just for a risky chance that I might have a little more time to scavenge a few more items out of the shop before we were inevitably found.
I took it as a case where morality was in the eye of the beholder. Would it have been any less moral to immediately risk the life of the guy I was with (and I don't like Kenny in the least) and potentially the rest of the group for the sake of a "clear" conscience?
Like a lot of the choices, I saw it as a choice of whether I wanted my poo sandwich on wheat or white bread.
Nice metaphor!
I shot her my first playthrough, left her my second.
Hilarious!!!
I shot her the first time by accident...i was trying to clear out a running lane for her and restarted the system right when i shot her...i was like WTF??
next time around...i realised it was a moral decision and you cant saver her life...so i chose to save ours. i left her.
stupid girl every first person shooting gamer knows to serpentine SERPENTINE!