›

Revive Carley!

GreenGreenGreenGreen
edited November 2012 in The Walking Dead
I was utterly shocked when Lilly shot Carley ... I tried everything to save her I mean I really liked her and she was pretty much the only reason I was playin this game and yet she dies by such ... I understand telltalegame's intentions, it's a zombie apocalypse and most favourite characters are supposed to die to shock a player but ... I lost a reason to play it as many others did when I googled a way to save Carley ... So, ok - you shocked players but for damn's sake she was shot on her left cheek! It could be a scratch and she just passed out, that way she could still be alive along with the storyline, so how about reviving her in the 5th episode? That would bring a lot attention onto that game. I'm just really holding on that hope now :( What's your opinion about that?
«1

Comments

  • JesseC25JesseC25
    edited November 2012
    Anyone that thinks she's alive is fucking stupid (no offense) if she was SCRATCHED why the fuck would everyone leave her... Shes dead. I was upset too when she was shot but she is dead dead dead and never coming back. The walkers probably devoured her body because they were very close.

    It's a zombie apocalypse, don't play it I'd you can't handle pixelated fictional characters being killed.
  • VainamoinenVainamoinen Moderator
    edited November 2012
    JesseC25 wrote: »
    Anyone that thinks she's alive is fucking stupid (no offense)

    Congratulations, that IS offensive. Watch your words a bit more.

    Still, it's correct that bringing Carley back for episode 5 would ridicule the whole franchise. No miraculous healings. You can hope for a flashback scene or a little Carley bit in the credits, but that really is it.
  • QuarterPounderVladQuarterPounderVlad
    edited November 2012
    Okay, I'll act as this ... Bleh.. Theory.. Is actually real. We left her, maybe she's alive. But she'd get eaten by walkers anyways... Maybe a group found her, Saved her, And gave her sanctuary. Maybe they just ate her alive.

    ...There's an extremely low chance that she's alive. But reviving her would just drift me apart from the series.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    check out my fan fic top of the page via my save carley link in my sig

    if you want to keep her alive..

    other wise i agree with jesse and vain, a bit harsh but soooo true
  • DemonseedDemonseed
    edited November 2012
    I'm sure she is dead as it would be a serious travesty to the entire group of survivors who couldn't diagnose an unconscious person from a dead one. Carly is dead and just like IRL sometimes, crazy shit happens such as Lilly going bonkers, we all seen it coming we just didn't know how or when it was going to happen.
  • CooperalCooperal
    edited November 2012
    My opinion is that the OP was setting himself up for disappointment if (in his words) "the only reason" he played the game was for a scripted love story with only trivial hardships involved.

    This is The Walking Dead. Everything is ALWAYS going worse than it seems. Especially if it seems like it's going good.

    Frankly I don't know why people have gotten so clingly just for Carley. She only had some small windows of time to get into peoples hearts and yet she managed it. She was relegated to being a minor character from the point you chose her over Doug. Absent for the main portion of Ep. 2, killed off fairly early in Ep. 3.

    I'm not normally the type of person to say such a cliche thing but: I think some members of the community could do with a bit more female contact to strengthen their emotions a bit. :p
  • TheNNerdGamerTheNNerdGamer
    edited November 2012
    if someone is shot in the head, good luck reviving her/him.
    the brain keeps you alive and you kill it, good luck surviving that
  • MalphaxisMalphaxis
    edited November 2012
    Ithink it was pretty obvious that she was dead. Now if you really wanted a li'l Carley action, she wasstill warm and there was no chance of her turning as shewas shot thru the head. But try explaining that one to Clem.
  • Stanley ChipmanStanley Chipman
    edited November 2012
    Killing Carley was really unexpected event, so that`s why I think it was cool solution from TellTale(even I like Carley, but I have to admit, her death was very dramatic, memorable and sad). So good job TellTale!
    P.S. Please stop "reviving Carley" it is not clever, she died,that is fact. Developers tell THEIR story. If she didn`t die you would not be so shocked and upset...I`m trying to say that it means TellTale do their job rather well, if you care so much about game characters.
    P.P.S. Sorry for my English :-)
  • GreenGreenGreenGreen
    edited November 2012
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    check out my fan fic top of the page via my save carley link in my sig

    if you want to keep her alive..

    other wise i agree with jesse and vain, a bit harsh but soooo true


    What?
    You mean this -> http://www.facebook.com/SaveCarley ?
  • The_Cheshire_CatThe_Cheshire_Cat
    edited November 2012
    can't get attached.
  • mkane24mkane24
    edited November 2012
    Am I the only one sick and tired of see these save Carly threads?
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    GreenGreen wrote: »
    What?
    You mean this -> http://www.facebook.com/SaveCarley ?

    what else would i mean...
  • GreenGreenGreenGreen
    edited November 2012
    Milosuperspesh wrote: »
    what else would i mean...

    but how does it allow to keep her alive? ...
    Some mod ?
  • KartonnendozenKartonnendozen
    edited November 2012
    Just make a stinking mod where you revived Carley with a Phoenix down or something. With Carley the white turning all moon princess unleashes some super attack. obilverating all the zombies. And have a sexy time mini game.

    Off course you can also do this with Doug.
  • TWDFTWTWDFTW
    edited November 2012
    You would of thought that they would of checked her to make sure. But she isn't coming back because if she did then it would cheapen my emotions and shock for her being possibly dead, as with many people. If she didn't get killed she would of either been eaten my zombies because you saw those zombies coming up the road. Or she would of died of starvation. And plus she probably doesn't know where you are so she will never come back. So yeah guys, telltale won't do it. Carley is gone forever, I loved Carley and I was shocked when she died, but that is where it ends for me, she isn't coming back!
  • The_Cheshire_CatThe_Cheshire_Cat
    edited November 2012
    GreenGreen wrote: »
    but how does it allow to keep her alive? ...
    Some mod ?

    LOL!

    HAHAHAHA!

    hell naw...

    you funny guy. you damn funny. Please post more often.
  • MilosuperspeshMilosuperspesh
    edited November 2012
    GreenGreen wrote: »
    but how does it allow to keep her alive? ...
    Some mod ?

    oh wow dude wow...

    i said 'fan fic' aka my own 'fan' made fiction story on carley surviving to live on..

    seriously...wow
  • GrimfangoGrimfango
    edited November 2012
    I say get over it. She's dead dead DEAD. I don't see what the big deal with Carley was anyway - she couldn't even put batteries in a radio. I chose clever ol' Doug over her in ep 1!
  • MalphaxisMalphaxis
    edited November 2012
    Grimfango wrote: »
    I don't see what the big deal with Carley was anyway !

    mammalian protuberances
  • HiggsBoson2142HiggsBoson2142
    edited November 2012
    Yeah.....no. Bullet holes are bullet holes. Deceased are deceased, and that's just the way it is.
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited November 2012
    You must be new here. Welcome to the forums. Yeah, Carley's dead. The only possible ways we can see her character again is through a dream or hallucination by Lee. Her voice actress is listed for episode 5 at IMDB, and so is Doug's. However, take this source as a grain of salt as Lilly, Duck, and Katjaa's voices are also listed.
  • deleted1139962deleted1139962
    edited November 2012
    I'm getting so mad all these Carley Might Be Alive threads, why can't you put the fact that she is dead in your brain!!!
  • PhotonCCPhotonCC
    edited November 2012
    Zeruis wrote: »
    You must be new here. Welcome to the forums. Yeah, Carley's dead. The only possible ways we can see her character again is through a dream or hallucination by Lee. Her voice actress is listed for episode 5 at IMDB, and so is Doug's. However, take this source as a grain of salt as Lilly, Duck, and Katjaa's voices are also listed.

    Do you think this might be for the credits or epilogue? We might here from other characters (even if they are just thoughts).
  • DemonseedDemonseed
    edited November 2012
    TWDFTW wrote: »
    You would of thought that they would of checked her to make sure. But she isn't coming back because if she did then it would cheapen my emotions and shock for her being possibly dead, as with many people. If she didn't get killed she would of either been eaten my zombies because you saw those zombies coming up the road. Or she would of died of starvation. And plus she probably doesn't know where you are so she will never come back. So yeah guys, telltale won't do it. Carley is gone forever, I loved Carley and I was shocked when she died, but that is where it ends for me, she isn't coming back!

    Are you serious or just trolling???? Do you really think they wouldn't have checked her to see if she was alive??? Really?

    Just because you didn't see them doing it doesn't mean it didn't happen, they just chose to save the time showing what we already knew. Stop being so theatrical and accept it, Carly is dead cause Lilly was nuts.
  • DemonseedDemonseed
    edited November 2012
    xXNinjaScoreXx wrote: »
    I'm getting so mad all these Carley Might Be Alive threads, why can't you put the fact that she is dead in your brain!!!

    Yes, I agree, people are so ridiculous sometimes it makes me laugh.....these people are just denying reality (well game reality) and expect a re-write for there personal benefit.

    No, the story is the story deal with it. I am upset over certain peoples deaths too, but I move on...as you should.
  • GreenGreenGreenGreen
    edited November 2012
    that saddens me :(
  • HelloCthulhuHelloCthulhu
    edited November 2012
    Btw, this is who all the carly fan boys are fawning over:
    MV5BMTMwNjg2NzMyM15BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNDI5NjYxNQ@@._V1._SX200_SY238_.jpg
    Not sure people would be asking for her back if they knew how much of a train wreck she looked like.
  • BlankCanvasDJBlankCanvasDJ
    edited November 2012
    HelloCthulhu wrote: »
    Not sure people would be asking for her back if they knew how much of a train wreck she looked like.

    Because I'm sure you're supermodel material.
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited November 2012
    xXNinjaScoreXx wrote: »
    I'm getting so mad

    And?
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    No! Why cant people learn she is dead. No.
  • HelloCthulhuHelloCthulhu
    edited November 2012
    BlankCanvasDJ wrote: »
    Because I'm sure you're supermodel material.
    Because this is totally a thread about me. And no one is fawning over me, and rightfully so. Seriously, its a character...a rather minor character really...
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited November 2012
    Carley was minor?


    I must have played a different game.......
  • zgamerzgamer
    edited November 2012
    Yeah, ain't gonna happen. Dead is dead in this universe, so Carley is a goner. It's sad, but that's TWD. She lives in legend because of her tragic death.
  • HelloCthulhuHelloCthulhu
    edited November 2012
    DreadMagus wrote: »
    Carley was minor?


    I must have played a different game.......
    Apparently... I mean really, when it comes down to it, what exactly was her impact on the overall story? What was her impact on decisions in general? Like I said... rather minor really.
  • Sweater SnakeSweater Snake
    edited November 2012
    Grimfango wrote: »
    I say get over it. She's dead dead DEAD. I don't see what the big deal with Carley was anyway - she couldn't even put batteries in a radio. I chose clever ol' Doug over her in ep 1!

    I did not choose the Doug life.


    The Doug life chose me.
  • bdawgnit1785bdawgnit1785
    edited November 2012
    Anytime we hear the Voice Actors's voice they will get credited for being in the episode...even if it's only in the previously ons....Larry was credited for episode 4 I believe and we all know what happened to him....both versions:p
  • HelloCthulhuHelloCthulhu
    edited November 2012
    Maybe they are going to do a Supernatural-style "The Road So Far..."
  • DreadMagusDreadMagus
    edited November 2012
    HelloCthulhu wrote: »
    Apparently... I mean really, when it comes down to it, what exactly was her impact on the overall story? What was her impact on decisions in general? Like I said... rather minor really.

    Your opinion, your privilege, I guess.......
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    HelloCthulhu wrote: »
    Apparently... I mean really, when it comes down to it, what exactly was her impact on the overall story? What was her impact on decisions in general? Like I said... rather minor really.

    Carleys impact = That your powerless in this world.

    And to make ppl thing ur gonna get it on with her but nope.
    SHES DEAD! GET OVER IT. Carley fans. i have drew a diagram showing her dimise :) your welcome
    Carleys head ( /-_-)
    Bullet= =
    Gun= ---
    /
    --- = --> = (/=_-)
    /
This discussion has been closed.