›

Was carley alive?

aaron1290aaron1290
edited November 2012 in The Walking Dead
when carley went all banshee on lilly... when the '' incident '' went down... was carley alive after getting shot? im not the best person at bullets and guns and stuff like that... so was carley alive when she got shot and bled to death or she just died? or did the bullet like make a some blood get not travel to her brain and she died? and wouldnt she come back if her brain wasnt damaged O_o

how can you people not understand...

i mean did the gunshot kill her because it didnt hit her brain... or did she live for like 5 mins after...

Comments

  • zeke10zeke10
    edited November 2012
    She got shot in the head dude
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    zeke10 wrote: »
    She got shot in the head dude

    wasnt it the face?
  • zeke10zeke10
    edited November 2012
    aaron1290 wrote: »
    wasnt it the face?

    Maybe its been a while it was either the face or temple
    Also sorry for coming down a lil hard i thought you were like "Omg carley is alive!!!!"
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    zeke10 wrote: »
    Maybe its been a while it was either the face or temple
    Also sorry for coming down a lil hard i thought you were like "Omg carley is alive!!!!"

    XD np
  • Snake LiquidSnake Liquid
    edited November 2012
    She's dead man. She didn't survive that gun shot to the head. Even for the sake of arguing, let's say she survived. There was a walker just down the road, that is especially pointed out if you leave Lilly there. If Carley was alive at all, she just got ravaged to death by that walker when it came over to eat her. I prefer to believe the gunshot did the job.
  • zeke10zeke10
    edited November 2012
    Snake Liquid wrote: »
    She's dead man. She didn't survive that gun shot to the head. Even for the sake of arguing, let's say she survived. There was a walker just down the road, that is especially pointed out if you leave Lilly there. If Carley was alive at all, she just got ravaged to death by that walker when it came over to eat her.

    I hear people talking about how the walker looks like doug i saved doug so is it true?
  • DoctanianDoctanian
    edited November 2012
    Carley ain't dead.
  • TWDFTWTWDFTW
    edited November 2012
    Ugh, I loved Carley! But seriously!! It's time to stop posting these threads about how she might be alive... She is gone! She isn't gonna make anymore appearances in the game! I have written this so many times so this is the last time I'm gonna write it!

    If TTG brought her back it would cheapen my feelings for her, and I would feel sort of like 'well they obviously ran out of ideas' I'm not trying to sound mean but she was shot in the face and she fell down! She would of died of blood loss, hunger, zombie group, she was pretty unprotected and if you chose to leave Lilly behind then you would of seen her running trying to get away from those zombies coming up the road, they would of smelt her and chewed her up. She would of had to of gotten up pretty to quick to get away from the group of zombies coming her way.


    Plllleeeeaaaassssseeeeee stop posting these threads, it's getting tedious because season 1 has ended and they won't bring her back into season 2 because it would be ridiculous! If you guys keep posting for no reason then fine but don't expect nice replies because most people like me are too pissed off that you guys keep posting this threads....

    Bye :)
  • zeke10zeke10
    edited November 2012
    Doctanian wrote: »
    Carley ain't dead.

    Ben ain't either
    Cough HiggsBoson2142 COUGH
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited November 2012
    larry lives
  • zeke10zeke10
    edited November 2012
    thestalkinghead wrote: »
    larry lives

    The horseless headless horsemann
  • The13thRoninThe13thRonin
    edited November 2012
    She had a piece of supersonic metal violently enter through the side of her head from a distance of three feet away and destroy her brain...

    What do you think?
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    TWDFTW wrote: »
    Ugh, I loved Carley! But seriously!! It's time to stop posting these threads about how she might be alive... She is gone! She isn't gonna make anymore appearances in the game! I have written this so many times so this is the last time I'm gonna write it!

    If TTG brought her back it would cheapen my feelings for her, and I would feel sort of like 'well they obviously ran out of ideas' I'm not trying to sound mean but she was shot in the face and she fell down! She would of died of blood loss, hunger, zombie group, she was pretty unprotected and if you chose to leave Lilly behind then you would of seen her running trying to get away from those zombies coming up the road, they would of smelt her and chewed her up. She would of had to of gotten up pretty to quick to get away from the group of zombies coming her way.


    Plllleeeeaaaassssseeeeee stop posting these threads, it's getting tedious because season 1 has ended and they won't bring her back into season 2 because it would be ridiculous! If you guys keep posting for no reason then fine but don't expect nice replies because most people like me are too pissed off that you guys keep posting this threads....

    Bye :)


    you realise i ment - did the gunshot kill her as soon as the bullet hit her or she died bleeding
  • RainbowSprinklzRainbowSprinklz
    edited November 2012
    Well, she was shot in the head. One can assume that was an insta kill
  • SutinenSutinen
    edited November 2012
    Are you fucking serious?
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    RainbowSprinklz wrote: »
    Well, she was shot in the head. One can assume that was an insta kill

    Wasnt it the face?
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited November 2012
    aaron1290 wrote: »
    Wasnt it the face?

    just below the left eye to be exact, but unfortunately the brain is behind the face so it got that aswell
  • george1120george1120
    edited November 2012
    no she just became a walker
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    thestalkinghead wrote: »
    just below the left eye to be exact, but unfortunately the brain is behind the face so it got that aswell

    ok so bullet hit her brain well atleast she didnt suffer... but what was that heavy breathing when she got shot
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited November 2012
    aaron1290 wrote: »
    ok so bullet hit her brain well atleast she didnt suffer... but what was that heavy breathing when she got shot

    it was a zombie, the noise was happening before she was shot
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    thestalkinghead wrote: »
    it was a zombie, the noise was happening before she was shot

    OooOoooOoooooOOOoohh!!!!
  • ZeruisZeruis
    edited November 2012
    She got shot in the left cheek. Without immediate medical attention, yeah... She's dead.
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited November 2012
    Too bad she wasn't standing between Lilly and the RV. That thing could've used a new coat of paint. I mean, did any of you actually take a look at the thing?
  • DildorDildor
    edited November 2012
    Rock114 wrote: »
    Too bad she wasn't standing between Lilly and the RV. That thing could've used a new coat of paint. I mean, did any of you actually take a look at the thing?

    Fuck....


    :(
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited November 2012
    lee and clementine have a conversation about how she wont come back because she was shot in the brain, lee probably looked down a the gruesome hole in the back of carleys head and knew she was not coming back
  • DeákDeák
    edited November 2012
    Rock114 wrote: »
    Too bad she wasn't standing between Lilly and the RV. That thing could've used a new coat of paint. I mean, did any of you actually take a look at the thing?

    Well to be honest, Carl got headshot right in eye with third of his head missing. Few issues later he is kicking ass. But bringing her back would be cheap, bitch-queen slapped and killed her, no need for plotholes.
  • SiniistarSiniistar
    edited November 2012
    i freeze framed and lowed down the footage of her death, she was shot cleanly through the cheek under her left eye(similar to how Carl was shot but he survived with bare minimum medical attention) and an exit wound was sort of behind her jaw on the same side.

    I immediately thought that scene was an allusion to the comics and she would come back eventually...but her voice actor confirmed she was dead for good D:


    so yeah she's gone bros
  • CarScarCarScar
    edited November 2012
    Oh Carley, I miss you.

    She reminded me so much of Robin Scherbatsky from How I Met Your Mother... I bet you if the zombie apocalypse were to happen in How I Met Your Mother, Robin would essentially be Carley.
  • dustpuffsdustpuffs
    edited November 2012
    Yep, she was alive. Right before she died.
  • The13thRoninThe13thRonin
    edited November 2012
    Just for clarifications sake Carly was not shot in the eye. She was shot while she was turning and the shot hit her square in the temple.
  • ToastyToasty
    edited November 2012
    Even in the bullet didn't kill her, it still would have caused her extreme brain damage, probably making her brain dead.
  • CTCCocoCTCCoco
    edited November 2012
    aaron1290 wrote: »
    Wasnt it the face?

    What if I shoot you in the face and I let you nowhere in the forest and we see if you can survive with every place full of cannibals.

    Oh wait, you would be instantly dead !
  • ZombieGoBoomZombieGoBoom
    edited November 2012
    CTCCoco wrote: »
    What if I shoot you in the face and I let you nowhere in the forest and we see if you can survive with every place full of cannibals.

    Oh wait, you would be instantly dead !

    So would cutting your own arm off with nothing but bandages to stop the bleeding or how about the realism of seeing a 100 pound girl doing batman like leaps between buildings with a 40 pound car battery in her backpack. TT plays fast and loose with real world logic and if they have enough wiggle room, they can do anything they want.
  • aaron1290aaron1290
    edited November 2012
    CTCCoco wrote: »
    What if I shoot you in the face and I let you nowhere in the forest and we see if you can survive with every place full of cannibals.

    Oh wait, you would be instantly dead !

    wow didnt i word my first post correctly... well i ment did the bullet kill ker straight away or did she bleed to death?
  • VainamoinenVainamoinen Moderator
    edited November 2012
    This thread is as dead as Carley.
This discussion has been closed.