Well from my prospective she never did anything good, Lee was a better leader, she should not have been in charge after Larry died and she murdered a very close friend, and that is the short version, but to each his own.
She trained group in combat skills. She also distribute a food thus I think that Kenny would give food for everyone everytime. And she made her personal list of supplies thanks of it we know that someone betrayed. Yes, she has bigger balls than others. It wasn't easy to keep group alive and in good relations.
But I think most of players just don't see it because it isn't showed in game so much, just a few dialogues.
I will begrudgingly admit that Lilly did have some admirable qualities. After a few playthroughs, I kinda 'got' her.
HOWEVER, taking it upon herself to snap-execute Ben, thereby accidentally killing Doug or murdering Carley for calling her on her bullshit, is unforgivable.
Well from my prospective she never did anything good, Lee was a better leader, she should not have been in charge after Larry died and she murdered a very close friend, and that is the short version, but to each his own.
To be fair, she wasn't exactly destined for greatness in this game when we(at the time anyway) knew the events lead up to her (comic book spoilers, not game spoilers)
I used to refuse to believe that Lilly is not Lilly Caul, until I realized that meant she can come back so I can finish her off, that is why I am indifferent to who she is now, if it means her death, then I will believe it.
Well, as someone who strongly dislikes (not hate, that's a bit too strong for me) Lilly, I actually DO see some of the stuff she did right. Like rationing the food, and keeping her own count of the supplies. Also, looking into the theft of said supplies. That was all smart stuff. BUT, I dislike her for reasons stated above by Bio. Plus, she screws the group over by stealing the RV (after you've given her a second chance), and leaves Lee and Clem behind after saying that she'd take them with her (even if you have always taken her side). I left her behind on the road, and I'm not sorry. She was out of the group the moment she pulled that trigger.
All that said, I won't be trying to kill her in Season 2 if she shows up. Assuming she survived, she's been punished enough by being abandoned with no supplies in the middle of nowhere. Unless she gives me a REASON to blow her head off, I won't be trying to kill her.
I think IF she appear in season 2 she would be changed. When you said "drop it!" after killing Carley/Doug she looks sad. And when she is handcuffed in the RV she looks confused too. Maybe that was a lesson for her, just like Katjaa's nad Duck's death for Kenny.
I think IF she appear in season 2 she would be changed. When you said "drop it!" after killing Carley/Doug she looks sad. And when she is handcuffed in the RV she looks confused too. Maybe that was a lesson for her, just like Katjaa's nad Duck's death for Kenny.
Yep she learned her lesson alright... That's why she stole the RV, right? Because she is such a good person now?
She stole the RV because she wasn't a member of the group anymore and (like everyone) cares about her survival. RV was her chance to survive. Our group got the train.
I don't mean she became good. I mean she learned to treat people well and not be such a bitch.
Czego oczekujesz od forum opanowanego przez sekte wasatego samoluba? To niedorzeczne i dziecinne. Kenny juz na farmie Hershela pokazal, ze troszczy sie tylko o swoich, a reszte ma w gleboko dupie. Co to za przyjaciel, ktory podlicza co robiles po jego mysli?
Lilly byla tragiczna postacia, ale duzo wiecej warta niz Ken. Nie byla zla, rozumiem, co doprowadzilo ja do ostatecznosci. Ci tutaj zaznaczaja Lilly jako most evil osobe w TWD. Smiechu warte. :mad:
RV ukradla, bo na piechote by jej nie pozwolili uciec. Nie godzila sie na bycie wiezniem.
Czego oczekujesz od forum opanowanego przez sekte wasatego samoluba? To niedorzeczne i dziecinne. Kenny juz na farmie Hershela pokazal, ze troszczy sie tylko o swoich, a reszte ma w gleboko dupie. Co to za przyjaciel, ktory podlicza co robiles po jego mysli?
Lilly byla tragiczna postacia, ale duzo wiecej warta niz Ken. Nie byla zla, rozumiem, co doprowadzilo ja do ostatecznosci. Ci tutaj zaznaczaja Lilly jako most evil osobe w TWD. Smiechu warte. :mad:
RV ukradla, bo na piechote by jej nie pozwolili uciec. Nie godzila sie na bycie wiezniem.
The forum is possessed by one thing . Opinion .
Everybody has different opinions , not everybody is going to love Lilly and hate Kenny .
And they treated her like a prisoner because she murdered DOUG/CARLEY AND BOTH OF THEM WERE INNOCENT .
The forum is possessed by one thing . Opinion .
Everybody has different opinions , not everybody is going to love Lilly and hate Kenny .
And they treated her like a prisoner because she murdered DOUG/CARLEY AND BOTH OF THEM WERE INNOCENT .
Sure. Opinions. I still have right to write mine.
Never said I love Lilly. And I didn't really hate Ken. Felt sorry for him. But facts are facts - Kenny was awkward.
I know what Lilly did. I played the game.
Comments
But I think most of players just don't see it because it isn't showed in game so much, just a few dialogues.
HOWEVER, taking it upon herself to snap-execute Ben, thereby accidentally killing Doug or murdering Carley for calling her on her bullshit, is unforgivable.
To be fair, she wasn't exactly destined for greatness in this game when we(at the time anyway) knew the events lead up to her (comic book spoilers, not game spoilers)
I still like to think that she was comic Lilly,as even though she did COMIC SPOILERS
All that said, I won't be trying to kill her in Season 2 if she shows up. Assuming she survived, she's been punished enough by being abandoned with no supplies in the middle of nowhere. Unless she gives me a REASON to blow her head off, I won't be trying to kill her.
I don't mean she became good. I mean she learned to treat people well and not be such a bitch.
Czego oczekujesz od forum opanowanego przez sekte wasatego samoluba? To niedorzeczne i dziecinne. Kenny juz na farmie Hershela pokazal, ze troszczy sie tylko o swoich, a reszte ma w gleboko dupie. Co to za przyjaciel, ktory podlicza co robiles po jego mysli?
Lilly byla tragiczna postacia, ale duzo wiecej warta niz Ken. Nie byla zla, rozumiem, co doprowadzilo ja do ostatecznosci. Ci tutaj zaznaczaja Lilly jako most evil osobe w TWD. Smiechu warte. :mad:
RV ukradla, bo na piechote by jej nie pozwolili uciec. Nie godzila sie na bycie wiezniem.
The forum is possessed by one thing . Opinion .
Everybody has different opinions , not everybody is going to love Lilly and hate Kenny .
And they treated her like a prisoner because she murdered DOUG/CARLEY AND BOTH OF THEM WERE INNOCENT .
Sure. Opinions. I still have right to write mine.
Never said I love Lilly. And I didn't really hate Ken. Felt sorry for him. But facts are facts - Kenny was awkward.
I know what Lilly did. I played the game.