›

Kenny heart-attack...

DomingezDomingez
edited May 2013 in The Walking Dead
What would you guys do if it was Kenny who had a heart-attack in meat locker? I imagine that you'd be probably the only one who would want to help him. It's easy to think that Larry would have killed him on the spot just, but what would Lilly do?

Comments

  • ZeroShootZeroShoot
    edited May 2013
    Lilly would be shocked by her dad's action. She didn't like Kenny much, and she has done things, that let her look like a cold, heartless person. But she isn't like that, she wouldn't want Kenny to die, especially since he is a husband and father. Lilly wouldn't have been grieving or something like that, but there would have been a lot of tension between her and her dad, her and Kat/Duck, and her dad and Kat/Duck.
    Asides from that I can't tell how things would've turned out on the side of the road, or at the train.
  • Mark$manMark$man
    edited May 2013
    In truth, I think Lee would have possibly killed Larry, because yeah you can get on Kenny's bad side, but only Larry shows true anger and threatens you at that point. The fact of it was that Kenny having a heart attack would possibly be easier to handle in Kenny's case, but still probably would kill him.

    I think Kenny would be killed by Larry, Lee possibly kill Larry, and then hostility between Lilly and Lee and Katjaa/Duck to Lilly would arise
  • DomingezDomingez
    edited May 2013
    ZeroShoot wrote: »
    Lilly would be shocked by her dad's action. She didn't like Kenny much, and she has done things, that let her look like a cold, heartless person. But she isn't like that, she wouldn't want Kenny to die, especially since he is a husband and father. Lilly wouldn't have been grieving or something like that, but there would have been a lot of tension between her and her dad, her and Kat/Duck, and her dad and Kat/Duck.
    Asides from that I can't tell how things would've turned out on the side of the road, or at the train.

    Ok she'd defend Kenny, because of Kat/Duck. But would she really go against /stop her dad in killing Kenny? Even when Larry thought Duck was bit, all Lilly did was trying to talk him down which didn't really work.
  • ProfanityProfanity Banned
    edited May 2013
    If Lee tried killing that giant, I have a feeling that the second salt lick would take permanent residence in Lee's noggin.
  • SLH1222SLH1222
    edited May 2013
    Maybe if Larry died FIRST, then Lilly would probably kill Kenny. Probably not before though.
  • Kiel555Kiel555
    edited May 2013
    Domingez wrote: »
    What would you guys do if it was Kenny who had a heart-attack in meat locker? I imagine that you'd be probably the only one who would want to help him. It's easy to think that Larry would have killed him on the spot just, but what would Lilly do?

    I know what I would do...help Kenny. It was not until after he left me to die the second time that I said to myself "this guy....is not my kind of guy". So I would try CPR. I think Lilly would help too with the CPR.

    Larry on the other hand...he's a loose cannon. I think he would have done something really bad....
  • DomingezDomingez
    edited May 2013
    Kiel555 wrote: »
    I know what I would do...help Kenny. It was not until after he left me to die the second time that I said to myself "this guy....is not my kind of guy". So I would try CPR. I think Lilly would help too with the CPR.

    Larry on the other hand...he's a loose cannon. I think he would have done something really bad....

    I would've done the same thing help Kenny, but then with Lee performing CPR and Lilly doing nothing/talking down Larry. Larry would have killed Kenny with the salt lick...and then I would kill him :D
  • Supporter of LillySupporter of Lilly
    edited May 2013
    I helped Lilly with her dad but yeah I think I would've helped Kenny even though I desise him very much.
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited May 2013
    I decided to kill Larry, but it was a really hard choice, even though I didn't like the man. Honestly, since Kenny isn't as big as him, I just might have chosen to save him instead of killing him. I'd probably always regret it though, because in a situation like that survival should take top priority.
  • CarScarCarScar
    edited May 2013
    I know people think Lilly is a heartless monster but I honestly don't see her having the guts to kill someone outright like that. Larry would go for the kill. Lilly would try to calm her dad down while Lee attempts to save him. If Lee sides with Larry, I don't think Lilly would act. She'd need Lee's support to stand up to Larry.
  • MikejamesMikejames
    edited May 2013
    CarScar wrote: »
    I know people think Lilly is a heartless monster but I honestly don't see her having the guts to kill someone outright like that.

    When she was still mentally stable that is..
  • Salt LickSalt Lick
    edited May 2013
    I image surely both Lilly and her father understand more than anyone how it's like when somebody has a heart attack seeing as how Larry had suffered from one himself so I don't think they would want to kill him outright unless he showed signs that he'll turn into one of them.
  • The FallenThe Fallen
    edited May 2013
    CarScar wrote: »
    I know people think Lilly is a heartless monster but I honestly don't see her having the guts to kill someone outright like that. Larry would go for the kill. Lilly would try to calm her dad down while Lee attempts to save him. If Lee sides with Larry, I don't think Lilly would act. She'd need Lee's support to stand up to Larry.

    Would be totally out of character for Lilly to kill a group member... ;)

    Although i do think you're right that she wouldn't have campaigned to kill Kenny, but nor do i think she's put up that much resistance to her dad (see Duck in pharmacy). I can see her being fairly uncertain.

    As for what i would do, well pragmatically killing Kenny would be the right thing to do in that scenario, as it was with Larry. However the critical difference being that Kenny (at least at the time) was my friend and i'd be far more prepared to do something stupid and risk my life for him than Larry, so i'd probably go against my better judgement and try to help him (before Larry probably drops a saltlick on his head)
  • Mark$manMark$man
    edited May 2013
    The Fallen wrote: »
    Would be totally out of character for Lilly to kill a group member... ;)

    Although i do think you're right that she wouldn't have campaigned to kill Kenny, but nor do i think she's put up that much resistance to her dad (see Duck in pharmacy). I can see her being fairly uncertain.

    As for what i would do, well pragmatically killing Kenny would be the right thing to do in that scenario, as it was with Larry. However the critical difference being that Kenny (at least at the time) was my friend and i'd be far more prepared to do something stupid and risk my life for him than Larry, so i'd probably go against my better judgement and try to help him (before Larry probably drops a saltlick on his head)

    Sounds about right! That... and the fact you'd probably have to kill Larry since he'd feel you put his family at risk and so you'd have a fight and you'd have to eventually kill him. Even if you sided with Larry, I'm sure he'd complain. "You smashed his head in wrong you son of a bitch!" *Slam* Or...
    "You murdered him!" He is such a hypoctrite I swear :S

    I think the fact here is Kenny wouldn't have a heart attack, so... we didn't have to choose :D I'd still use the salt lick on Larry, like "Oh no... I thought he had the heart attack... False alarm! Eh... he's still breathing. *Drop* Oooooops... I have butter fingers..."
  • HudomonkeyHudomonkey
    edited May 2013
    If Kenny had not killed Larry I would have still liked him...
    I probably would help and Larry honestly wouldn't just kill him I think he would be ready but wouldn't just kill him...

    Kenny was desperate to save his family and would have even killed Clem if she threatened their safety
    Larry is protective of Lilly but I don't think he would outright kill him without giving him a chance...
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited May 2013
    The fact that the first thing Larry does upon us meeting him is try to kill a 10-year-old child on the suspicion of him being bitten without giving him a chance. So I'd have to disagree and say that it would be the drug store all over again, but this time we couldn't stop Larry.
  • thestalkingheadthestalkinghead
    edited May 2013
    larry would have killed kenny, and he would have killed himself (if he could have) to protect his daughter
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited May 2013
    I would have tried to save Kenny, if Larry does anything about it he dies, simple.
This discussion has been closed.