Clementine or Ellie

2

Comments

  • OlgaSedovaOlgaSedova Banned
    edited July 2013
    What's Ellie?

    Clem > Everyone Else
  • edited July 2013
    The equivalent of Clementine in the Last Of Us, Naughty Dogs latest game.
  • edited July 2013
    I like them both but Ellie can take care of herself (and others, if you played the game) while Clem is very much in need of a protector. Clem is at least 5 years younger than Ellie which is a big difference when the ages are 8-9 and 14. Ellie is more well adapted since she was born into the apocalypse, as opposed to Clem who has memories of grade school and old friends. So if I could only take one it is Clem.
  • edited July 2013
    Clementine or Ellie?

    i1msud.jpg
  • edited July 2013
    Because that's not how Telltale rolls. You choose one. Or don't and they both die, you get a game over screen, and you still have to choose one.

    That being said, I trust Ellie to have my back more but in a Sophie's Choice kind of thing, I'd pick Clementine every time.
  • edited July 2013
    Clementine or Ellie?

    i1msud.jpg

    *Mexican celebration music*
  • edited August 2013
    Ellie hands down. She is one of the best characters i've ever seen in a video game. She is like the girl from the hungar games, very capable and far more useful in a fight than Shiva was in Resi 5. Ellie saved my ass countless times by alerting me to people that were attacking me from the left,right and rear. She is actually a sweet girl as well. She wasn't living like a bandit in the wastelands so she does still hold some childlike innocense. She grew up in the safe zone so she has never seen an adult magazine before she left the safe zone. She likes to read comics, etc. She has the inquisiteness of a normal child, always asking questions. Her character at times reminded me of the kid in the road movie when he kept asking his dad questions. I particularly liked when she would sing and try to whistle.

    I thought Ellie was adorable, partly because she was so life like and she looks a bit like Elen Paige who I also think is very cute. When she lets her guard down around peolple she knows and trusts she is very cute but she can also be very badass and wisely untrusting where strangers are concerned.
  • edited August 2013
    Ellie 100% she can survive on her own she can scout, scavenge, hunt, she even has the perfect attitude for the situation.
  • edited August 2013
    I like both... but...
    Ellie should be dead. I don't think I can let that slide. The whole world is going to die because she's alive... But I guess we can blame Joel for that.

    In short, Clementine.
  • edited August 2013
    I know, that did always bug me a little bit, I mean I understand what he did but it still bugs me.
  • edited August 2013
    I know, that did always bug me a little bit, I mean I understand what he did but it still bugs me.

    Well after Sarah died , Ellie was like a second daughter to Joel so I guess he doesn't want to lose her like Sarah .
  • edited August 2013
    I understand what they did, but not why.

    Let's keep it at that outside of

    Dude, psychic, some people haven't played last of us.
  • edited August 2013
    I know, just saying I know why he did that, hell I would have done the same, but it is selfish.
  • edited August 2013
    I wouldn't.

    Psychic, put it in spoilers!
  • edited August 2013
    I can't believe people actually like Ellie. She's a bratty bitch and she's the complete opposite of clementine. And please tell me Crixus is fucking joking.
    I'm surprised you don't like her. I can't see why anyone that has played the last of us wouldn't like Ellie. I know she was the difference many times between me getting the game over screen and me progressing through the story. She saved my ass countless times and looked after me/joel the way Carl looked after Rick when they left the prison in the comics. She is very realistically rendered and she is adorable, she sings, hums, tries to whistle and she is at times hilarious. Like all kids that are forced to grow up, she regresses from time to time showing her age and innocense e.g when she sees her first adult magazine and the fact that she didn't realise that the guy that kidnapped her wanted to "groom" her for sex as she never saw herself as a woman and didn't have those kind of thoughts.
  • edited August 2013
    I found Ellie to be a bit like Becca...
    So Clem...
  • edited August 2013
    I liked her don't get me wrong, I just like Clem and Elizabeth more because I do not have enough room under my heart, does that make me a asshole?
  • edited August 2013
    Example of Ellie and Becca = survivalist
    Example of Clementine = Sophia
  • edited August 2013
    Example of Ehkay = Male Lilly
  • edited August 2013
    Example of Lilly = a Bitch.
  • edited August 2013
    Example of Ehkay = Male Lilly
    That is a bit unfair on Lilly she is a bit crazy but she isn't completely psychotic and she actually liked Clementine and even gave her things to help her sleep...

    She didn't wish death on everyone only people she thought were traitors and slowly killing them...
  • edited August 2013
    I know, that did always bug me a little bit, I mean I understand what he did but it still bugs me.
    To be honest it would have bugged me far more if he hadn't done what he did, given what we went through when playing the game. He did what I wanted him to do. If there was a choice option like in TWD I would have still done what Joel did, that reaction is realistic. The same way Kenny would have done anything to save Duck and Lee would have done anything to save Clem, Joel would do anything to save Ellie. As the player I grew as attached to Ellie as Joel the character did and I would have put Joel through anything to get her to safety. Such was the quality of the games writing and character development.
  • edited August 2013
    Hudomonkey wrote: »
    I found Ellie to be a bit like Becca...
    So Clem...
    No way. Ellie is far more caring. I take it you don't remember the part where she wanted to help the man that was pretending to be injured?

    Ellie was willing to undergo tests for the salvation of man kind and would have willingly died to save the world if she had to. It was Joel that was selfish and amoral.
  • edited August 2013
    I liked her don't get me wrong, I just like Clem and Elizabeth more because I do not have enough room under my heart, does that make me a asshole?
    No not at all. We can't all like the same things. I haven'y played Bio shock infinite myself so I can't comment on the AI controlled girl in the game but generally I don't feel as connected to characters in fps games as I do with those in 3rd person games since there are less animations and facial expressions in conversations on account of us not seeing their faces, accept for cut scenes of cause.
  • edited August 2013
    Clementine vs Ellie 1v1 Ellie would win with ease and Clementine would be crying while getting shot at and Ellie would go Rambo.
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    Clementine vs Ellie 1v1 Ellie would win with ease and Clementine would be crying while getting shot at and Ellie would go Rambo.

    Ellie would not be the type to kill a child dude .
  • edited August 2013
    We will never know. You'd be suprised what people do to survive.
  • edited August 2013
    Are we seriously reviving this thread?
  • edited August 2013
    I don't know why ether.
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    Clementine vs Ellie 1v1 Ellie would win with ease and Clementine would be crying while getting shot at and Ellie would go Rambo.
    full-of-shit-e1306565942806.jpg
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    Clementine vs Ellie 1v1 Ellie would win with ease and Clementine would be crying while getting shot at and Ellie would go Rambo.

    Ellie wouldn't kill a kid unless the kid was supposed to murder her. All the horrible things Ellie has done was because of self defense. She's not like Joel.
  • edited August 2013
    Lets Imagine Clem & Ellie are on thier own,a walker grabs clem,a clicker grabs Ellie,who will be able to take care of herself and live? Ellie.
    If Clem could show even a little of the fighting skill the ellie showed it will be different + Ellie can kill clickers without help (telling joel she killed some clickers by herself after the got seperated with those brothers) I like Clem a LOT tho
  • edited August 2013
    Oh no this thread is back! :( sorry I just don't like comparing some of my favorite games
  • edited August 2013
    Me nether, hence why I have never made a whats better Bioshock of Walking Dead thread.
  • edited August 2013
    360 owner here :(
    Last Of Us is the only title that made me sad to not have a PS, but i watched Pewdie play most of it so i feel better at least getting to experience some of it.

    Ellie if i wanted to survive i suppose cause she can help, Clem just because i would feel the need to help her.
  • edited August 2013
    Ellie
  • edited August 2013
    zev_zev wrote: »
    Ellie

    ZEV ZEV ! Long time no see !
  • edited August 2013
    ZEV ZEV ! Long time no see !

    Angry russian return mhahahah
  • edited August 2013
    Nothing stops angry Russian, good to have you back.
  • edited August 2013
    As much as I like Ellie, she's still Garbage :D
This discussion has been closed.