Would you enjoy a Lily Redemption Subplot in Season 2?
I am a big fan of Carley, and when replaying The Walking Dead and really do miss her. Gins of a well written character. Although Lily pisses me off during the story, I actually don't think she is a bad person, she is just someone who could pushed over the edge and did something nuts, something she would not normally do. I mean it is a zombie apocalypse, I KNOW I would do some things that I right now would normally do.
Personally I would love a redemption arc for Lily in Season 2, to cleanse her of her crime of killing Carley/Doug, where she will probably have to sacrifice herself.
Personally I would love a redemption arc for Lily in Season 2, to cleanse her of her crime of killing Carley/Doug, where she will probably have to sacrifice herself.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
Granted, most players would rather see Lilly die in the most undignified way possible instead after the Carley/Doug/RV incident...
Let's leave her story alone.
I count myself among those people. I don't know, can't say that I don't enjoy a good redemption story, but Lilly sealed her status in my eyes because of that completely unnecessary murder. I doubt that even if she saved a bunch of season 2 characters, it wouldn't make up for the shit she caused back in season 1. A good act does not wash out the bad, nor bad the good. But perhaps I'd dislike her a little less after that. Though I would ultimately rather she, like Kenny, didn't appear in season 2 at all.
Kenny's an asshole depending on the choices you make but Lilly's a bitch no matter what and will pull the same stunts with you even if you have her back. I said this before and I'll say it again, Kenny's a saint compared to her.
She was the leader when no one else was willing and was hated and fought against at all point just because she was the one who did the rationing, she was the one who had to think about letting new people in the group...
And then a member of the group killed her father right in front of her and she was forced to remain leader with no one left to trust...
No wonder she snapped...
She saved everyone when the bandits attacked and she was right about Ben...
If Kenny had not broken the group...
Lilly wouldn't have became what she became...
Kenny forgot the countless times I saved him and his family because I am not a murderer and after that left me for dead at every turn and tried his best to get me out of the equation...
Kenny still drops you, he still becomes a drunk and he still would have ripped Ben apart...
Lilly may betray you no matter what but she appreciates it when you help her and she may steal the RV but with Kenny in charge...
She had no choice...
I hate Kenny and I dislike Lilly but if Kenny is given a chance for redemption after everything he did...
I'd be willing to give Lilly the same chance
Forced? How?
I'm sure she had he option of giving up the leadership position since she can't handle it.
She wanted to remain in charge after that poor leadership skills she displayed in Episode 1. Who hated her? This is one thing I don't get where people think she was hated. I'm sure rationing wasn't as hard as hunting for food besides, didn't Mark suspect she was giving her dad extra.
One member killed her father and suddenly the whole group can't be trusted?
And again, she wasn't forced to remain as leader, she had the option to give it up but didn't.
She snapped because she's a weak-minded coward.
That could've been avoided if she hadn't arrogantly stayed at the motel. She was right about Ben but only due to guessing, she wasn't right about Carley.
She broke up the group by making bad decisions, killing a valuable member and leaving the group vulnerable by abandoning them for dead.
All Kenny did was possibly kill her dad(whether he was alive or not is debatable), Everything that happened after that was Lilly's doing.
And Lilly forgot the times you helped her. At least with Kenny, he will help you if you've been good to him, can't say the same with Lilly and even with the stunts he pulls with you, he sticks by you till the end, where was Lilly?
Drop you?
What reasons are there he shouldn't rip Ben apart? Ben caused his family's death, at least Kenny forgives him later on.
Lilly will still kill an innocent person, she'll still expose your past, she'll still leave you for dead no matter what decisions you make with her.
What?
She'll kill someone you care for, she'll ungratefully reveal your secret and she'll abandon you and even Clementine for dead, how are those signs of appreciation?
There are always choices. She had the choice not to pull the trigger but does anyway.
Kenny never killed an innocent person and left people for dead like Lilly has. He sticks by you till the end whereas Lilly abandons you.
A slow and painful death for Carley? o_O Must've missed something in your posts
Who was left in the group to trust? By the end of episode 2 there was only Kenny and his family and Doug/Carley left she did trust Doug to a point and Carley was lying to the group about Lee and I could understand why someone might not trust her (I didn't)
She knew she was a mess but having the responsibility of keeping a group half of which is directly linked to the man who killed your father...
They survived 3 months at the Motel and died within days of leaving it...
The Motel was the only thing keeping the group alive...
The group was broken when Kenny fragmented it... Lilly just finished it off...
She saved everyone from the bandits and they had just lost all their supplies and their base... She wanted vengeance and was broken she didn't know what to do and her Paranoia had consumed her...
Kenny would have Killed Lilly if she hadn't stolen the RV she had no choice...
Kenny killed Larry and left me for dead so many times whilst when Kenny would have let me die she saved me...
Kenny was never there for me even when I did what he wanted just because of one disagreement...
Whoops, I met Lilly, I would never say I want Carley dead at all.
If that happenes , than Lilly would be beyond redemption and deserve to be shot by Becca or Shel .
Also , stop trolling . It's not healthy for you
Well you don't like Clem that's ok , but in the " Do You Think Season 2 Will Be As Good/Darker Than Season 1? " you say this "Someone throws a grenade or something, and it blows off Clementines legs, with her screaming at the top of her lungs. Then you put her out of her misery or leave her to bleed " Now that's just cruel .
Damn you're twisted.
Agreed.
I know,I just mean having her legs blown off,I bet Kirkman couldn't even do that,maybe you should write all the horrible things that happen in the comic,even though I would be scared if you did.
I doubt it,but I think most people like Clementine,though may I ask why you hate her?
No your not the only one , there is also a member called Ehkay who hates children like you .
I think they wouldn't become attached to characters,they would just want every character murdered as horribly as possible.
I see,in what way is she annoying?Also why do you hate her because she is little?
That is the way the comic already is, they take someone you like and murder them in the worst ways.
Yeah,but it would be way worse if Cany wrote it,I presume you would humiliate them before hand Cany and then torture them for so long until you finally give them a slow,painful,brutal death.
I don't think many people could.
I think Nate would be the one to read his comics .
If he was in charge , everybody in season 1 would be dead , and every character would be different . Lee would be a abusive drunk who hits Clementine and treats her like dirt , Kenny would be a true monster , Lilly would be the Governor and Larry would be like Negan , Carley would be a demonic bitch and treat everybody like dirt and Ben would get people killed ON PURPOSE .
Hell no, I don't want a Lilly redemption arc. She's irredeemable in my eyes, and is definitely my favorite candidate for tripping over a grenade randomly.
To truly redeem herself she'd have to pull off a freakin' miracle. Cure the zombie virus, bring Carley back, and then sacrifice herself to save Clementine.
Also, the guy who wants Clem tortured has no soul. He's Lilly!
Thanks Jesus and The Lord that you are not the creator of The Walking Dead Comics and the Game .
Only 17 times? Dude, I thought you were trying to be dark.
DUDE don't help him please .
Screw you ! :mad:
I second this.