›

SHOW VS. GAME Who's next? 1

Flame ReaderFlame Reader
edited August 2013 in The Walking Dead
Heres the first thread to discuss the next match up for Game vs. Show. Discuss your current choices, Suggest choices for next time, and discuss the last match up, here
«13

Comments

  • CornflakeDudeCornflakeDude
    edited August 2013
    Here's my opinion, don't take it as fact

    Rick, but It would be close cause Lee's tough
    Andrea, I guess cause she has more experience
    Shane, mostly cause he has police training
    The governor? Haha he's pretty ruthless
    And probably Dale cause he has guns and Chuck uses a shovel

    Unless you mean which ones are our favorites in that case it's all of those choices reversed.
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    Chuck would easily destroy TV Dale,he never killed a walker or shot a gun ever,now comic book Dale on the other hand was alot better of a character
  • Rock114Rock114
    edited August 2013
    Ben vs The Governor. I HAVE to see that.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    CornflakeDude wrote: »
    Here's my opinion, don't take it as fact

    Rick, but It would be close cause Lee's tough
    Andrea, I guess cause she has more experience
    Shane, mostly cause he has police training
    The governor? Haha he's pretty ruthless
    And probably Dale cause he has guns and Chuck uses a shovel

    Unless you mean which ones are our favorites in that case it's all of those choices reversed.

    These are ALL supposed to vote based. Its entirely your choice on what to base your vote on
  • HarpadarpaHarpadarpa
    edited August 2013
    By the way, Shane would win every time, because Kenny fights like a wuss.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    Bucket Hat v Hobro.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    I would like to see Kenny fight something and win for once in his life, not likely but a man can dream, Ben and the Governor, I feel sorry for Ben, Chuck would win because nothing beats the Hobro, I would say Lee beats Rick but I don't know.
  • Roy1306Roy1306
    edited August 2013
    would like to se Carley VS andrea..in S2 on that RV walker Andrea was just screaming there and crying when she killed the walker..carley did way tougher impression

    edit : Carley isnt afraid from walkers and is a good survivor - save doug and u see Carley puts up a very good fight against the walkers grabbing her over and over again
  • master psychicmaster psychic
    edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    would like to se Carley VS andrea..in S2 on that RV walker Andrea was just screaming there and crying when she killed the walker..carley did way tougher impression

    edit : Carley isnt afraid from walkers and is a good survivor - save doug and u see Carley puts up a very good fight against the walkers grabbing her over and over again

    You're pretty much asking for a Doug Vs Carley thread dude .
  • MerakMissile2MerakMissile2
    edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    would like to se Carley VS andrea..in S2 on that RV walker Andrea was just screaming there and crying when she killed the walker..carley did way tougher impression

    edit : Carley isnt afraid from walkers and is a good survivor - save doug and u see Carley puts up a very good fight against the walkers grabbing her over and over again

    You mean in ep.1 when Doug is saved? Er...Carley gets immediately pulled down by her hair and gets her faced ripped off... Deadeye shot she is, hand-to-hand fighter she is not.
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    We have to have Doug v Milton.
  • Roy1306Roy1306
    edited August 2013
    master psychic wrote: »
    You're pretty much asking for a Doug Vs Carley thread dude .

    nah not really xD just telling my opinion why carley can beat up andrea :P when I 1st saw carley's death in ep 1 I was kinda shocked she still got up after the walkers grab :P not tryign to make doug vs carley thread coz there are really way to much out there :s

    #Teambattery
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    nah not really xD just telling my opinion why carley can beat up andrea :P when I 1st saw carley's death in ep 1 I was kinda shocked she still got up after the walkers grab :P not tryign to make doug vs carley thread coz there are really way to much out there :s

    #Teambattery

    not to mention doug or carley would have to been in the show
  • Roy1306Roy1306
    edited August 2013
    MerakMissile2 wrote: »
    You mean in ep.1 when Doug is saved? Er...Carley gets immediately pulled down by her hair and gets her faced ripped off... Deadeye shot she is, hand-to-hand fighter she is not.

    actualy she gets grabbed twice. somehow she is getting up using the fridge then another walker pulls her down and thats the end of her..but yeah I agree with you,she didnt make such physicaly strong character to me..not compared to Molly anyways
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    actualy she gets grabbed twice. somehow she is getting up using the fridge then another walker pulls her down and thats the end of her..but yeah I agree with you,she didnt make such physicaly strong character to me..not compared to Molly anyways

    who beat Michonne :P
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    True, but it's safe to say she is stronger then Kenny at hand to hand.
  • Roy1306Roy1306
    edited August 2013
    Flame Reader wrote: »
    who beat Michonne :P

    read that few minutes ago,loved it good job !
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    read that few minutes ago,loved it good job !

    thanks lots! Im really good at coreographing stuff :D
  • master psychicmaster psychic
    edited August 2013
    MerakMissile2 wrote: »
    You mean in ep.1 when Doug is saved? Er...Carley gets immediately pulled down by her hair and gets her faced ripped off... Deadeye shot she is, hand-to-hand fighter she is not.

    Well what would you expect her to do ? Turn into Supergirl and save the day ?
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    I liked it to, it reminded me of that show on Spike, god it's been sometime I forgot it's name.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    I liked it to, it reminded me of that show on Spike, god it's been sometime I forgot it's name.

    Deadliest warrior?
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    That was it, only for Walking Dead, I always thought that would have been a good idea.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Bioshock Infinite WD wrote: »
    That was it, only for Walking Dead, I always thought that would have been a good idea.

    Well, look forward for more to come!
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    I like it.
  • That1GuyThat1Guy
    edited August 2013
    Well, the poll is very tied.
  • Roy1306Roy1306
    edited August 2013
    I guess its up to Flame then?
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    Quite tied up, not what I was expecting.
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    I guess its up to Flame then?

    Tommorow morning if its all tied up, ill use my extra vote i only use in a case like this. Sound good?
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    "I don't know much about you Dale, but I can tell you, sure as the sun gon' come up tomorrow, that you keep going on like this and that bucket hat ain't gonna make it."

    And then Dale tries to hide Chuck's shovel and lecture him (of all people) re retaining one's humanity. Chuck then sends him back to On Golden Pond.


    It's beautiful *wipes tears*
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    If one person here votes dale vs. chuck im gunna lose it.
  • MerakMissile2MerakMissile2
    edited August 2013
    TWO people voted! Hooray!
  • Flame ReaderFlame Reader
    edited August 2013
    MerakMissile2 wrote: »
    TWO people voted! Hooray!

    *repeated facedesk*
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    Sick Octopus wrote: »
    "I don't know much about you Dale, but I can tell you, sure as the sun gon' come up tomorrow, that you keep going on like this and that bucket hat ain't gonna make it."

    And then Dale tries to hide Chuck's shovel and lecture him (of all people) re retaining one's humanity. Chuck then sends him back to On Golden Pond.


    It's beautiful *wipes tears*

    Lol looking back at the series I think Dale was one of the weakest group members,they really didn't do his comic counterpart justice like at all!
  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited August 2013
    You can't even compare Carley to Andrea. It's like comparing a bag of money to a bag of rocks

    But it was the easiest one so I voted for that xD
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    Bag of money=Carley. Bag of rocks=Andrea maybe?
  • TTaing987TTaing987
    edited August 2013
    Exactly ^^
  • Sick OctopusSick Octopus
    edited August 2013
    I know, Crixus. He was supposed to be the 'moral compass' and I understand where he was coming from, but fuck if he couldn't be patronizing and completely out of touch with reality sometimes. And he did endanger the group; hiding their gun cache was the thing that sent me reeling.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    I knew it, if we are talking comic then I am not sure who I would vote for, but show Andrea SUCKS, Carley all the way there.
  • Bioshock Infinite WDBioshock Infinite WD
    edited August 2013
    Lol one of the tags is Walking Kombat, I like that.
  • CrixusCrixus
    edited August 2013
    Sick Octopus wrote: »
    I know, Crixus. He was supposed to be the 'moral compass' and I understand where he was coming from, but fuck if he couldn't be patronizing and completely out of touch with reality sometimes. And he did endanger the group; hiding their gun cache was the thing that sent me reeling.

    Yeah and even his death was so lame,A starving weakened walker was able to walk towards him push him over and have at and this was when he had a loaded rifle,he litreally never killed a walker in the TV Series. Andrea is another Comic book character whom I thought the TV Series butchered,I do like the TV Show version of Herschel though and of course the TV version of Shane was great but for every other character so far I've preferred their comic versions.
This discussion has been closed.