I do agree, I think Hershel was better in the show, but they just destroyed Andrea, I guess they could have not Dale better but I still liked his character, unlike Andrea which was pretty much unlikable at the end.
I mean, come on, she:
SPOILERS (how do I add spoiler tags?)
-Slept with two antagonists;
-Almost killed herself and after she gave up, she didn't even try to convince that one woman and the doctor to not give up;
-Almost killed Daryl;
-Got sick and had to have Michonne take care of her
-Died in the stupidest way possible.
I can't account for her behaviour in S1/S2 but it's apparent that while she was at Woodbury, she carried her commonsense around in that stupid bag she always had over her shoulder.
Okay, first off, none of these battles should involve firearms. Otherwise, the winner is pretty much whoever shoots first. If we're talking melee-style, one-on-one combat with a few choice weapons, then it'll go:
Lee > Rick
Andrea > Carley
Shane > Kenny
Governor > Ben
Chuck > Dale
Of these, which would I like to see more? Ask not for whom the bell tolls...
About Andrea accidentally shooting Daryl, I still remember the hate and death threats the ACRTESS got. I mean, seriously? She had nothing to do with Andrea's actions.
I remember that bullshit, I mean it was really dumb on the characters part, but really you go that far to go after the actress, I mean I just because I hate Lilly does not mean I want to kill Nicky Rapp, that is most likely why people hate Daryl fans.
I know, every time someone named Ben shows up in the Walking Dead or anything zombie, assume he is a complete screw up and will get someone killed until shown otherwise, remember if you check the word 'screw up' or anything like it in the dictionary there is no description, just a picture of Ben Paul.
I remember that bullshit, I mean it was really dumb on the characters part, but really you go that far to go after the actress, I mean I just because I hate Lilly does not mean I want to kill Nicky Rapp, that is most likely why people hate Daryl fans.
yeah, the actors have nothing to do with the characters they play, even doug who is based off a real person is not the real person, he is a character in a piece of fiction.
anyway, Ben would accidentally save the governors life while getting himself killed
in a fist fight Lee would beat Rick , but in a gunfight Rick has a quicker draw and good aim so he would beat Lee
shane would beat Kenny, he looks pretty strong and he is trained, plus he would cheat somehow
carley would win in a gunfight, but it would be close in a fist fight but i would actually give andrea the edge because even though her final fight wasn't so great she did fight off a few zombies by hand
Yeah, I'm going to have tentatively side with Andrea if it comes down to a good old fashioned brawl, just based on the few walkers she tousled with, and her physique.
The problem with show Andrea is that at times she's grossly overconfident and smarmy and, if anyone's seen one of the deleted S2 scenes, Daryl absolutely owns her re: being observant. She really isn't.
Yeah, I'm going to have tentatively side with Andrea if it comes down to a good old fashioned brawl, just based on the few walkers she tousled with, and her physique.
The problem with show Andrea is that at times she's grossly overconfident and smarmy and, if anyone's seen one of the deleted S2 scenes, Daryl absolutely owns her re: being observant. She really isn't.
Yeah that was hilarious,she thinks she is so smart but she spent most of season 3 being completely stupid and blind to whats happening around her.
You know, seeing as how these battles are super likely to end up being an extremely one-sided popularity contest if a likable character from the game is participating, how about having some of the more hated game characters join in? I want to see the TV characters duke it out with Andy St. John, the Stranger, and Larry.
You know,seeing as how these battles are super likely to end up being an extremely one-sided popularity contest if a likable character from the game is participating, how about having some of the more hated game characters join in? I want to see the TV characters duke it out with Andy St. John, the Stranger, and Larry.
It's true.
Although I'm trying not to be biased, hence my support for the loathed Andrea in a hand to hand match, and really my brouche, Ken, hasn't got a chance against Shane.
You know, seeing as how these battles are super likely to end up being an extremely one-sided popularity contest if a likable character from the game is participating, how about having some of the more hated game characters join in? I want to see the TV characters duke it out with Andy St. John, the Stranger, and Larry.
*facedesk* i completely forgot campman and the st. johns > _ <
Although I'm trying not to be biased, hence my support for the loathed Andrea in a hand to hand match, and really my brouche, Ken, hasn't got a chance against Shane.
However, I like your suggestion.
it should be the battle of the moustaches between Axel and Kenny, seems like that match is more fair
Comments
Or Shane vs Lily?
SPOILERS (how do I add spoiler tags?)
-Slept with two antagonists;
-Almost killed herself and after she gave up, she didn't even try to convince that one woman and the doctor to not give up;
-Almost killed Daryl;
-Got sick and had to have Michonne take care of her
-Died in the stupidest way possible.
Andrea
Shane
Governor
Chuck
Lee > Rick
Andrea > Carley
Shane > Kenny
Governor > Ben
Chuck > Dale
Of these, which would I like to see more? Ask not for whom the bell tolls...
<Hint: it tolls for Dale>
Y'all miss me
You know...in Season 3 of the show, there is a kid named Ben who is in The Governor's group. :O
Yup and he
GODDAMMIT BEN!
Seriously.
yeah, the actors have nothing to do with the characters they play, even doug who is based off a real person is not the real person, he is a character in a piece of fiction.
anyway, Ben would accidentally save the governors life while getting himself killed
in a fist fight Lee would beat Rick , but in a gunfight Rick has a quicker draw and good aim so he would beat Lee
shane would beat Kenny, he looks pretty strong and he is trained, plus he would cheat somehow
carley would win in a gunfight, but it would be close in a fist fight but i would actually give andrea the edge because even though her final fight wasn't so great she did fight off a few zombies by hand
chuck would definitely beat Dale
The problem with show Andrea is that at times she's grossly overconfident and smarmy and, if anyone's seen one of the deleted S2 scenes, Daryl absolutely owns her re: being observant. She really isn't.
Yeah that was hilarious,she thinks she is so smart but she spent most of season 3 being completely stupid and blind to whats happening around her.
He doesn't deserve to have his name spelled right!
Yes, hopefully Milton.
It's true.
Although I'm trying not to be biased, hence my support for the loathed Andrea in a hand to hand match, and really my brouche, Ken, hasn't got a chance against Shane.
However, I like your suggestion.
*facedesk* i completely forgot campman and the st. johns > _ <
it should be the battle of the moustaches between Axel and Kenny, seems like that match is more fair
a battle like that could end the apocolypse itself!