A corrupt pseudo-doctor who thinks making his own daughter ignorant of the outbreak is a good guardian? If you seriously think he's a better choice than Luke, then hang me and feed my remains to a pack of wolves.
Throwing Clementine on the floor like a bag of dirt. He was just looking out for himself. At least Carlos had a reason for putting Clementine in the shed.
A corrupt pseudo-doctor who thinks making his own daughter ignorant of the outbreak is a good guardian? If you seriously think he's a better choice than Luke, then hang me and feed my remains to a pack of wolves.
Fuck this, I'm out of here.
That and if you think about it even if it wasn't a walker bite she is still a child and she could die from a bite that severe she even says it herself "I could die if I don't get this patched up" or something along the lines and she would then turn if she died in the middle of the night and kill someone or catch them off guard and bite them if she was to be taken into the house.
Throwing Clementine on the floor like a bag of dirt. He was just looking out for himself. At least Carlos had a reason for putting Clementine in the shed.
Carlos didn't know that it was a dog bite because he is fucking idiot. I don't understand how he can be a doctor, propably all his clients died because carlos is so shitty doctor.
Carlos knew it was a dog bite and put Clementine in the shed to protect his daughter. That shows that he is willing to do anything to protect the ones he loves.
It's better than bringing her into the house. Even if it isn't a walker bite if she dies which she herself said could happen then she would still turn. It's not worth the risk.
Hell no, i mean yeah Carlos could be a good caretaker but if he had to choose between Sarah and Clem he would obviously pick his daughter, so the best caretaker Clem could have would be Luke
Wait, what? This is your argument on why Carlos should be excused for putting Clem in the shed? You just explained how if Clementine didn't get patched up then she would've died, yet Carlos still put her in the shed for his own selfish needs. You're telling me that if Clementine didn't steal the supplies then she would've turned? Please tell me, would you still be so "understanding" towards Carlos if he was the reason Clem died? Seriously, you have a bizarre way on picking who you should trust.
Trust the man who had nothing to gain by fighting for you and didn't stop until he knew you were safe in the cabin (Luke). He even fed you. Carlos put you in the shed and tells you that you can't be trusted (Determinant). It was his fault that Clementine had to go through all of that and yet you're defending him.
That and if you think about it even if it wasn't a walker bite she is still a child and she could die from a bite that severe she even says … moreit herself "I could die if I don't get this patched up" or something along the lines and she would then turn if she died in the middle of the night and kill someone or catch them off guard and bite them if she was to be taken into the house.
I'm saying that Carlos is a BETTER choice than Luke. You just pointed out why you think Carlos shouldn't take care of Clementine but you never explained why Luke is a better candidate.
I never said they shouldn't get her patched up I think she could and you cannot possible call looking after your own daughter to be selfish. I still agree with putting her in the shed regardless because even if she did get help she is a lot more likely to still die than an adult from that kind of injury. This is what I posted in this thread earlier "I'd likely do the same. She is a kid so they wouldn't have to use much supplies i'd just patch her up and leave her there until they figure out who or what she knows. I mean in a world like that this you have to really think Would you potentially sacrifice your daughter's safety or even life to save this other girl you don't even know?"
Wait, what? This is your argument on why Carlos should be excused for putting Clem in the shed? You just explained how if Clementine didn't … moreget patched up then she would've died, yet Carlos still put her in the shed for his own selfish needs. You're telling me that if Clementine didn't steal the supplies then she would've turned? Please tell me, would you still be so "understanding" towards Carlos if he was the reason Clem died? Seriously, you have a bizarre way on picking who you should trust.
Trust the man who had nothing to gain by fighting for you and didn't stop until he knew you were safe in the cabin (Luke). He even fed you. Carlos put you in the shed and tells you that you can't be trusted (Determinant). It was his fault that Clementine had to go through all of that and yet you're defending him.
Yeah you're totally right. It's not like Pete only brought three bullets with him to go to the river and it's not like Clementine needed to save him or else he would've died.
Have I been talking to a wall all this time ? How many times do I need to say no one is taking care of Clementine, Luke is her FRIEND and the reason why is because he is a young guy who like her lost his parents and loved ones and stood up for her since they met, Carlos is neither Nice or young and he obviously didn't give Clementine the benefit of the doubt not to mention he already has someone he has to watch over all the time, Is this good enough?
I'm saying that Carlos is a BETTER choice than Luke. You just pointed out why you think Carlos shouldn't take care of Clementine but you never explained why Luke is a better candidate.
Sorry to break it to you, but leaving a little girl out in the shed to die, so you can protect your daughter is selfish. Guess what? Carlos didn't patch up the wound and he just threw her in the shed. He's contemptible, ignorant, and selfish. The triple threat. Good luck trusting your Clem's life with him. I think I'm just going to stick with nice guy, trustworthy, and selfless Luke.
I never said they shouldn't get her patched up I think she could and you cannot possible call looking after your own daughter to be selfish.… more I still agree with putting her in the shed regardless because even if she did get help she is a lot more likely to still die than an adult from that kind of injury. This is what I posted in this thread earlier "I'd likely do the same. She is a kid so they wouldn't have to use much supplies i'd just patch her up and leave her there until they figure out who or what she knows. I mean in a world like that this you have to really think Would you potentially sacrifice your daughter's safety or even life to save this other girl you don't even know?"
Carlos seems to be doing fine with Sarah. Luke can't even watch Clementine when she needs his help. Who came to the rescue when Clementine was in trouble? Carlos!
Being nice and young has nothing to do with survival. Fine, Carlos can be her partner in killing walkers and maybe even teach Sarah a thing or two. Carlos doesn't have any parents either so I guess that makes him qualified. Carlos was just looking out for Sarah when he put Clementine in the shed. That can potentially be good for Clementine when he starts befriending her.
Have I been talking to a wall all this time ? How many times do I need to say no one is taking care of Clementine, Luke is her FRIEND and th… moree reason why is because he is a young guy who like her lost his parents and loved ones and stood up for her since they met, Carlos is neither Nice or young and he obviously didn't give Clementine the benefit of the doubt not to mention he already has someone he has to watch over all the time, Is this good enough?
he could be protective with Clementine too. He even saved her life!
How exactly did he save her life? If my memory serves me right, he couldn't tell the difference between a dog and zombie bite.
You don't know if he lost his family or not so toy are not talking fact and also being nice has nothing to do ? Soy yoy would associate with someone who has been a douchebag to you ? You are really special
Being nice and young has nothing to do with survival. Fine, Carlos can be her partner in killing walkers and maybe even teach Sarah a thing … moreor two. Carlos doesn't have any parents either so I guess that makes him qualified. Carlos was just looking out for Sarah when he put Clementine in the shed. That can potentially be good for Clementine when he starts befriending her.
I wouldn't actually call it saving..... It's not like Clem had no way of getting out of there. Regarding your thread, Clem doesn't really need to be protected anymore. Should Carlos watch her back? Yes,absolutely! Same with Luke, it was never he implied he was her "guardian" or anything like that.
I wouldn't actually call it saving..... It's not like Clem had no way of getting out of there. Regarding your thread, Clem doesn't really ne… moreed to be protected anymore. Should Carlos watch her back? Yes,absolutely! Same with Luke, it was never he implied he was her "guardian" or anything like that.
Comments
A corrupt pseudo-doctor who thinks making his own daughter ignorant of the outbreak is a good guardian? If you seriously think he's a better choice than Luke, then hang me and feed my remains to a pack of wolves.
Fuck this, I'm out of here.
Throwing Clementine on the floor like a bag of dirt. He was just looking out for himself. At least Carlos had a reason for putting Clementine in the shed.
Why don't you agree? What do you find flawed in my opinion? Explain.
He is better than Luke. What do you see in Luke that makes him a better guardian than Carlos?
That and if you think about it even if it wasn't a walker bite she is still a child and she could die from a bite that severe she even says it herself "I could die if I don't get this patched up" or something along the lines and she would then turn if she died in the middle of the night and kill someone or catch them off guard and bite them if she was to be taken into the house.
Just like Carlos putting Clementine in the shed to ensure Sarah's safety? Anyone could have done that.
Carlos didn't know that it was a dog bite because he is fucking idiot. I don't understand how he can be a doctor, propably all his clients died because carlos is so shitty doctor.
I already told you in my first comment and im not gonna say it again so feel free to go up and check it out again
Dude, phrasing.
I think that Pete would have been the best choice among the cabin group
Well, there was that one time where he saved her life.
It's better than bringing her into the house. Even if it isn't a walker bite if she dies which she herself said could happen then she would still turn. It's not worth the risk.
Hell no, i mean yeah Carlos could be a good caretaker but if he had to choose between Sarah and Clem he would obviously pick his daughter, so the best caretaker Clem could have would be Luke
Wait, what? This is your argument on why Carlos should be excused for putting Clem in the shed? You just explained how if Clementine didn't get patched up then she would've died, yet Carlos still put her in the shed for his own selfish needs. You're telling me that if Clementine didn't steal the supplies then she would've turned? Please tell me, would you still be so "understanding" towards Carlos if he was the reason Clem died? Seriously, you have a bizarre way on picking who you should trust.
Trust the man who had nothing to gain by fighting for you and didn't stop until he knew you were safe in the cabin (Luke). He even fed you. Carlos put you in the shed and tells you that you can't be trusted (Determinant). It was his fault that Clementine had to go through all of that and yet you're defending him.
That's gotta be the dumbest thing i've ever heard on this site...and i heard alot of dumb things on this site believe me!
Carlos saved Clementine in the trailer when she was being surrounded. Where was Luke when she needed help? Nowhere to be found.
Clem is her own caretaker
I'm saying that Carlos is a BETTER choice than Luke. You just pointed out why you think Carlos shouldn't take care of Clementine but you never explained why Luke is a better candidate.
Ofcourse she is! But i could accept Kenny as a semi caretaker of her though...
Exactly. Carlos can watch her just like he does with his daughter. Luke wasn't even there when she needed him.
I never said they shouldn't get her patched up I think she could and you cannot possible call looking after your own daughter to be selfish. I still agree with putting her in the shed regardless because even if she did get help she is a lot more likely to still die than an adult from that kind of injury. This is what I posted in this thread earlier "I'd likely do the same. She is a kid so they wouldn't have to use much supplies i'd just patch her up and leave her there until they figure out who or what she knows. I mean in a world like that this you have to really think Would you potentially sacrifice your daughter's safety or even life to save this other girl you don't even know?"
Yeah you're totally right. It's not like Pete only brought three bullets with him to go to the river and it's not like Clementine needed to save him or else he would've died.
Have I been talking to a wall all this time ? How many times do I need to say no one is taking care of Clementine, Luke is her FRIEND and the reason why is because he is a young guy who like her lost his parents and loved ones and stood up for her since they met, Carlos is neither Nice or young and he obviously didn't give Clementine the benefit of the doubt not to mention he already has someone he has to watch over all the time, Is this good enough?
Sorry to break it to you, but leaving a little girl out in the shed to die, so you can protect your daughter is selfish. Guess what? Carlos didn't patch up the wound and he just threw her in the shed. He's contemptible, ignorant, and selfish. The triple threat. Good luck trusting your Clem's life with him. I think I'm just going to stick with nice guy, trustworthy, and selfless Luke.
Carlos seems to be doing fine with Sarah. Luke can't even watch Clementine when she needs his help. Who came to the rescue when Clementine was in trouble? Carlos!
Ken+clem= deadly combo
The most powerfull beeings in the Walking Dead all wear hats! (except for stupid Nick!)
Being nice and young has nothing to do with survival. Fine, Carlos can be her partner in killing walkers and maybe even teach Sarah a thing or two. Carlos doesn't have any parents either so I guess that makes him qualified. Carlos was just looking out for Sarah when he put Clementine in the shed. That can potentially be good for Clementine when he starts befriending her.
I do I know Luke won't be helping her the whole episode? Because when she needed his help he wasn't there. Carlos just cares about his loved ones.
How exactly did he save her life? If my memory serves me right, he couldn't tell the difference between a dog and zombie bite.
I agree. That's also what Chuck said.
Peddo
In the trailer. When the walkers were surrounding Clementine, he shot them. He saved her.
You don't know if he lost his family or not so toy are not talking fact and also being nice has nothing to do ? Soy yoy would associate with someone who has been a douchebag to you ? You are really special
It was pretty obvious in the trailer that Luke wasn't around.
-Clementine's theme cues in-
I wouldn't actually call it saving..... It's not like Clem had no way of getting out of there. Regarding your thread, Clem doesn't really need to be protected anymore. Should Carlos watch her back? Yes,absolutely! Same with Luke, it was never he implied he was her "guardian" or anything like that.
Okay, but that was just the trailer. I'm pretty sure the entire episode will be longer than 90 seconds.
People keep saying that he's going to be like a "brother" to her. Meaning that they're going to be close. Personally I think that's a terrible idea.