Why do you think that? How is the idea of Carlos being like a "father" to her better? In my opinion, Carlos is a ticking time bomb. I don't even want to imagine what's gonna happen to him if something happens to Sarah.
You don't know if he lost his family or not so toy are not talking fact and also being nice has nothing to do ? Soy yoy would associate with someone who has been a douchebag to you ? You are really special
Didn't you see the comment when I say " i don't agree with it but its your opinion" its pretty dumb to say what you just said when you don't read all the comments, Im just defending my position and he is defending his so you getting involved is completely uncalled for
True you are defending your opinion you just don't have call another person "special" to do so. Plus I did read all the comments I just later saw you bashing him for his opinion, that why I got involved.
Didn't you see the comment when I say " i don't agree with it but its your opinion" its pretty dumb to say what you just said when you don't… more read all the comments, Im just defending my position and he is defending his so you getting involved is completely uncalled for
Bashing ? That is BS from top to bottom, We are having an argument like normal people, We haven't gotten into a fight and we are not disrespecting each other we just don' agree and are giving each other reasons why so once again your point is invalid and completely irrelevant
True you are defending your opinion you just don't have call another person "special" to do so. Plus I did read all the comments I just later saw you bashing him for his opinion, that why I got involved.
Bashing ? That is BS from top to bottom, We are having an argument like normal people, We haven't gotten into a fight and we are not disresp… moreecting each other we just don' agree and are giving each other reasons why so once again your point is invalid and completely irrelevant
Hold on a damn minute, Are you thinking I called him special as calling him a retard ? What I meant by that was unique because not many people think that way so maybe you should ask first next time you wanna throw someone under the bus like that
If I could mistake it that way others could too. To me at least it came off that way, at least wording wise. I would say something along the lines "Oh well that's a different perspective" instead of "you are special". Anyways sorry for mistaking your comment.
Hold on a damn minute, Are you thinking I called him special as calling him a retard ? What I meant by that was unique because not many people think that way so maybe you should ask first next time you wanna throw someone under the bus like that
If I could mistake it that way others could too. To me at least it came off that way, at least wording wise. I would say something along the… more lines "Oh well that's a different perspective" instead of "you are special". Anyways sorry for mistaking your comment.
Carlos doesen't care about clementine, he don't Trust her and wants keep her away from his daughter. Luke cares about clementine, that's why he is better choise for a caretaker
Carlos tries his best to protect his daughter, I agree, but that's all. Trusting Clementine with Carlos, despite him seeming like an irrational idiot, would be a bad idea because he wants to protect his daughter, he clearly doesn't care about or trust Clementine. If you think he would protect her, you're wrong, as it was clearly shown in the first episode of season 2 that he doesn't have any interest in protecting her. He left her to die in a shed. If he isn't an idiot, he should have known she could easily have died without medical treatment and he refused it to her anyways.
While Luke tried to convince the group to let Clementine stay, sympathized with her and even gave her food.
I never said they shouldn't get her patched up I think she could and you cannot possible call looking after your own daughter to be selfish.… more I still agree with putting her in the shed regardless because even if she did get help she is a lot more likely to still die than an adult from that kind of injury. This is what I posted in this thread earlier "I'd likely do the same. She is a kid so they wouldn't have to use much supplies i'd just patch her up and leave her there until they figure out who or what she knows. I mean in a world like that this you have to really think Would you potentially sacrifice your daughter's safety or even life to save this other girl you don't even know?"
Well said, I don't know how anyone can think he should "Take care of her" after the way he treated Clementine the first Episode and the incompetence he showed in some of those situations, But fuck it thats what opinions are for
Carlos tries his best to protect his daughter, I agree, but that's all. Trusting Clementine with Carlos, despite him seeming like an irrati… moreonal idiot, would be a bad idea because he wants to protect his daughter, he clearly doesn't care about or trust Clementine. If you think he would protect her, you're wrong, as it was clearly shown in the first episode of season 2 that he doesn't have any interest in protecting her. He left her to die in a shed. If he isn't an idiot, he should have known she could easily have died without medical treatment and he refused it to her anyways.
While Luke tried to convince the group to let Clementine stay, sympathized with her and even gave her food.
I choose Luke.
Eh, I'm not saying he's unfit to be a caretaker, but I don't think he's fit to be Clementine's caretaker. He clearly doesn't want to and may have even tried to let her die. The role of the caretaker would actually be to stop Carlos from locking Clementine in the shed, to take care of her, which Luke did. d:
Well said, I don't know how anyone can think he should "Take care of her" after the way he treated Clementine the first Episode and the incompetence he showed in some of those situations, But fuck it thats what opinions are for
Nope I'm team Luke. Everyone in the group has someone. Carlos & Sarah. Alvin & Rebecca. Nick & Pete. Who does Luke have? No one. Him and Pete saved Clem from a walker. They didn't know her, they didn't have to do that but they did and they stuck up for her in the group discussion too. Luke even took the effort to get to know her at the dinner table.
Comments
If he died then you just proved my point on why Carlos should watch out for Clementine.
TeamMachete
Why do you think that? How is the idea of Carlos being like a "father" to her better? In my opinion, Carlos is a ticking time bomb. I don't even want to imagine what's gonna happen to him if something happens to Sarah.
When Carlos dies, your arguments will be invalid
@Saltlick right now your kind of being a douchebag, its his a opinion no need to diss him on it and no need for the attitude.
Didn't you see the comment when I say " i don't agree with it but its your opinion" its pretty dumb to say what you just said when you don't read all the comments, Im just defending my position and he is defending his so you getting involved is completely uncalled for
True you are defending your opinion you just don't have call another person "special" to do so. Plus I did read all the comments I just later saw you bashing him for his opinion, that why I got involved.
Bashing ? That is BS from top to bottom, We are having an argument like normal people, We haven't gotten into a fight and we are not disrespecting each other we just don' agree and are giving each other reasons why so once again your point is invalid and completely irrelevant
Calling someone "special" is not disrespect?
Hold on a damn minute, Are you thinking I called him special as calling him a retard ? What I meant by that was unique because not many people think that way so maybe you should ask first next time you wanna throw someone under the bus like that
I wish Lee would return and see his grown Clem :c
If I could mistake it that way others could too. To me at least it came off that way, at least wording wise. I would say something along the lines "Oh well that's a different perspective" instead of "you are special". Anyways sorry for mistaking your comment.
I wouldn't just call someone a retard just because I don't agree with them,Don't worry This was all a misunderstanding
Carlos doesn't want Clementine anywhere near Sarah, and he probably doesn't want her in the group either. So no.
Carlos doesen't care about clementine, he don't Trust her and wants keep her away from his daughter. Luke cares about clementine, that's why he is better choise for a caretaker
Carlos tries his best to protect his daughter, I agree, but that's all. Trusting Clementine with Carlos, despite him seeming like an irrational idiot, would be a bad idea because he wants to protect his daughter, he clearly doesn't care about or trust Clementine. If you think he would protect her, you're wrong, as it was clearly shown in the first episode of season 2 that he doesn't have any interest in protecting her. He left her to die in a shed. If he isn't an idiot, he should have known she could easily have died without medical treatment and he refused it to her anyways.
While Luke tried to convince the group to let Clementine stay, sympathized with her and even gave her food.
I choose Luke.
Well said, I don't know how anyone can think he should "Take care of her" after the way he treated Clementine the first Episode and the incompetence he showed in some of those situations, But fuck it thats what opinions are for
Eh, I'm not saying he's unfit to be a caretaker, but I don't think he's fit to be Clementine's caretaker. He clearly doesn't want to and may have even tried to let her die. The role of the caretaker would actually be to stop Carlos from locking Clementine in the shed, to take care of her, which Luke did. d:
Nope I'm team Luke. Everyone in the group has someone. Carlos & Sarah. Alvin & Rebecca. Nick & Pete. Who does Luke have? No one. Him and Pete saved Clem from a walker. They didn't know her, they didn't have to do that but they did and they stuck up for her in the group discussion too. Luke even took the effort to get to know her at the dinner table.