Rank The cabin group

BeastwolfBeastwolf Banned
edited March 2014 in The Walking Dead

Rank all the cabin group members including Pete from least favorite to favorite and why they are on that position

«1

Comments

    1. Nick
    2. Luke
    3. Pete
    4. Carlos
    5. Sarah
    6. Alvin
    7. Rebecca

    There's a pretty small gap between the first 5 and a huge gap between 5 , 6 and 7

  • Pete is my favorite because he was nicest
    Luke my second favorite, same reason
    Nick, even though he is an idiot, he makes honest mistakes
    Alvin, because he's kinda funny
    Carlos, well he at least helped clem
    Rebecca, she scares me, didnt want to help clem
    Sarah last cause i found her a little bit annoying

  • edited March 2014
    1. Carlos (I know.... What am I thinking...? Well, he grew on me a lot in ep 2)

    2.Pete

    3.Luke

    4.Nick

    5.Alvin

    6.Sarah

    7.Rebecca

  • edited March 2014
    1. Luke
    2. Pete
    3. Nick
    4. Carlos (my Latino brother)
    5. Rebecca (she grew on me)
    6. Alvin (juice box)
    7. Sarah

    This was actually hard to make because the entire cabin group became more like able in episode 2. It'll be tough seeing them all inevitably die. :p

  • Must be the hot accent. ^_^

    * Carlos (I know.... What am I thinking...? Well, he grew on me a lot in ep 2) 2.Pete 3.Luke 4.Nick 5.Alvin 6.Sarah 7.Rebecca

  • edited March 2014
    1. Pete
    2. Al
    3. Carlos
    4. Luke
    5. Rebecca
    6. Sarah
    7. Nick
  • edited March 2014
    1. Luke
    2. pete
    3. Carlos
    4. Sarah
    5. Alvin
    6. Rebecca
    7. Nick

    I honestly cant stand Nick he just comes across as a whiner, I saved him but that was only because i told Pete i would look out for him :)

  • Wow people really don't like Sarah.

    I wasn't going to post my favorites list but someone has to show the sheltered girl some love

    1. Sarah
  • edited March 2014
    1. Pete. I really liked his character especially at the beginning when he trusted me.

    2. Luke. Really nice and sometimes funny. Likable personality and is pretty cool

    3. Nick. Unique character that can sometimes be an idiot but his intentions are in the right place. Also "Luke he is becoming a danger to the group"

    4. Rebecca. Her actions in S2 E1 were justified in the next episode. She seemed pretty nice later on and is going through a lot knowing that the baby could be Carver's.

    5. Carlos. Not the best doctor but still a nice guy. He was more respectful in S2 E2 and saved Clem's life. However not knowing the difference between a dog and zombie bite, and letting a little girl turn off a wind turbine is why he is number 5.

    6. Alvin. I like his character but I simply like the others better. He seems to be a nice guy but seems cowardly. It looks as if the group pushes him around and he does whatever they say. Hopefully his character improves in S2 E3 if he lived in your play through.

    7. Sarah. I don't really like her. Probably because of the fact that she is sheltered too much from the apocalypse and therefore is not really phased by anything.

  • edited March 2014
    1. Luke. Although this may change after the future episodes. So far he's a good guy, and has been the most accepting of Clem. Not initially of course, but eventually. It'd be nice for her to have a older brother figure. I hope he lives for this reason.

    2. Nick. I can really relate to this dude. I've had similar stuff happen to me family wise, and I know I screwed up back then. Besides being hot headed, it's clear to me that he's a good guy deep down. Also, like Kenny, I always know where I stand with him.

    3. Carlos. Besides being a doctor, he reminds me of Lee before he ran into Chuck with his wise words of advice. There are bound to be parents who will be slightly illogical due to their worry of the well being of their child. It's understandable, and I admire his will power.

    4. Sarah. She's innocent, and reminds me of Clem before we taught her how to survive and shoot a gun. And although slightly naive, I can see her going in for the long haul as long as we are there to help her out.

    5. Pete. This is a no brainer as to why. He was the first to believe us. His good nature and love for his nephew Nick was one of his highlights. Even though he had such a short amount of screen time, he made a lasting impression. Poor guy.

    6. Rebecca. Back in Episode 1, I always knew there was something else causing her harsh attitude, and I never blackmailed her due to this. She's not my favourite, but she's definitely growing on me. Carver better leave her alone.

    7. Alvin. He's a nice guy and all, but so far, he's too under developed for me to appreciate his character. Besides the fact that he's an okay individual. Since he's alive in my playthrough, I'm crossing my fingers in hopes that I can learn more about him to change this.

  • 1 - Pete
    2 - Alvin
    3- Luke
    4 - Nick
    5- Sarah
    6 - Rebecca
    7 - Carlos

    Anyway Pete's dead and Alvin and Nick are going to die in two episodes tops, so I'll have to reconsider the list

  • edited March 2014
    1. Luke: He saved Clem, and he seems to be a nice guy. Acts like a "big brother" type figure I suppose.

    2. Pete: Same reasons as Luke, but it seems that Luke has more importance to the story so... yeah.

    3. Sarah: She may be overly friendly and not that bright, but clem does need a friend.

    4. Carlos: I don't know, I just like him. Aside from the fact that he may be the dumbest doctor I've ever seen...
      .

    5. Nick: He's impulsive and quick to temper, not to mention not all that bright, but he's kind of likeable, and at least he apologized each time he fucked up.

    6. Alvin: Again, nice guy, helped Clem get medical supplies, etc.

    7. Rebecca: I actually like Rebecca too... just less than everyone else because she was a bitch in Episode 1.

  • edited March 2014
    1. FUCKIN' UNCLE PETE
    2. Nick, due to being related to the aforementioned Uncle Pete
    3. Luke, due to having known Nick, and therefore Pete, before the apocalypse
    4. Pete's dead body
    5. Pete's unnamed dead sister, having been related to Pete
    6. Nick's watch, having belonged to Pete at some point
    7. Carlos - dat accent
    8. All of those other people

    No, I don't sense any patterns here... get off my back...

    1. Pete, that guy was the bäst ever, i like guys who know how to play poker

    2. Alvin, awesome teddy bear who has nicely fed tummy

    3. Nick, adorable fuck-up

    4. Carlos, he's number four, cause that stupid answer he gave Clem when asked abou why they leave Carvers camp, 'because we had to = / '

    5. Luke, nice i guess but i don't like him as a new partner for Clem, plus he dropped Clementine and that's no good

    6. Sarah, i don't care about her, and she poined a gun at me so fuck it!

    7. Evil Witch!!!! Alvin deserves better

    I know, worst answers evah : (

  • Go Pete!

    Rock114 posted: »

    * FUCKIN' UNCLE PETE * Nick, due to being related to the aforementioned Uncle Pete * Luke, due to having known Nick, and therefore Pete, b

  • Damn, I forgot the ninth member, who would actually take 5 instead of Carlos: Nick's watch, having belonged to Pete prior to the apocalypse.

    Go Pete!

  • edited March 2014
    1. Luke = Good brother-sister relationship scenes with Clementine, and a decent persona all around.

    2. Pete = Good hearted man who wants to do what's best for everyone. Had he lived longer he would have been placed first.

    3. Sarah = Was suspicious of her at first, but she grew on me. Liked her interaction with Clementine.

    4. Nick = Didn't like him at first, but he grew on me when he owed up to his mistakes and tried to make amends.

    5. Alvin = Likable, but a little boring. Not much character done to him, though that may change in Episode 3.

    6. Carlos = Didn't like him in Episode 1, and not sure what to make of him in Episode 2. He comes across as more incompetent than competent at times.

    7. Rebecca = Didn't like her in Episode 1, and found her suddenly shift of personality too sudden in Episode 2 to be realistic for me.

    1. Luke
    2. Pete
    3. Nick
    4. Carlos
    5. Rebecca
    6. Alvin
    7. Sarah
  • edited March 2014

    And tenth member would be Petes sister, she was only mentioned and she died while ago but... Go Pete!

    Rock114 posted: »

    Damn, I forgot the ninth member, who would actually take 5 instead of Carlos: Nick's watch, having belonged to Pete prior to the apocalypse.

  • edited March 2014

    Editing post now... I forgot about her as well...

    EDIT: Aaaaaaaaand fixed.

    And tenth member would be Petes sister, she was only mentioned and she died while ago but... Go Pete!

  • Good call to get rid off all those other non-Pete related characters! Go Pete "We burnin' goddamn daylight" Randall!

    Rock114 posted: »

    Editing post now... I forgot about her as well... EDIT: Aaaaaaaaand fixed.

  • To be fair, Carlos had dat accent and is funny to have around. Everyone else though...

    Good call to get rid off all those other non-Pete related characters! Go Pete "We burnin' goddamn daylight" Randall!

    1. Luke
    2. Pete
    3. Nick
    4. Alvin
    5. Rebecca
    6. Carlos
    7. Sarah
  • And that shirt is pretty style too.

    Rock114 posted: »

    To be fair, Carlos had dat accent and is funny to have around. Everyone else though...

  • edited March 2014
    1. Nick- Fleshed out, and realistically flawed. With the way he's dealt with his mistakes and losses in the group I think we've had the most time to really delve into his character.

    2. Sarah- First solid example of developed interactions between two kids trying to grow up in this situation. Sarah's a good lighthearted and/or tragic foil to Clem, showing less independence and maturity overall, but still willing to help and learn from her.

    3. Pete- The trustworthy and genuinely likable uncle. Like Chuck, I guess the guy was too cool to last for very long.

    4. Luke- Seems like a level headed guy with a sort of brotherly relationship towards Clem and Nick, but I'd still like to learn more about what makes him tick, and where he's been before all this happened.

    5. Carlos- I like his relationship with Sarah, and he seems like a decent guy despite the shed debacle, but I'd like more time for him to converse with Clem or see him interact with the others. He's been off-screen a lot, discussing group matters.

    6. Alvin- I like the idea of the goodhearted but weak-willed guy, but outside of the juice box bit and his loyalty to Rebecca he hasn't gotten much time to shine.

    7. Rebecca- Never hated her as much as some people, and I'm sure she'll be a decent character from here on out, but I found the quick shift in her attitude towards Clem a little off putting. Otherwise, I like the concept of her acting out on the frustrations of not wanting to feel too dependent on others.

  • 1-pete the rest come after lol

    1. Pete
    2. Luke
    3. Carlos
    4. Nick
    5. Sarah
    6. Alvin
    7. Rebecca
    1. Luke
    2. Pete
    3. Rebecca
    4. Alvin
    5. Carlos
    6. Nick
    7. Sarah
    1. Luke
    2. Alvin
    3. Pete
    4. Nick
    5. Sarah
    6. Rebecca
    7. Carlos
    1. Carlos
    2. Luke
    3. Pete
    4. Nick
    5. Alvin
    6. Sarah
    7. Rebecca (Keep in mind I still like her)
    1. Pete - he was a hero and strongest person in that group. My favorite.
    2. Alvin - he is a good guy. He probably knows the baby isn't his but he's still doing his best to protect it from Carver. BTW i was surprised he didn't just sit on carver's head after Kenny shot him.
    3. Rebecca - she might probably be the most interesting character of all this season.
    4. Sarah - I like her. She is just a girl, probably a little sick, and I really understand Carlos. He doesn't want to lose her. Her relationship with Clem may become much more interesting in the future.
    5. Carlos - I think he is a good leader. I also understand why he put Clem in a shed. It was a little girl after all. Something really unexpected and he couldn't be sure she wasn't infected.
    6. Luke - I think he still is a little boring. He is no hero, husband or father - just a guy. I didn't like when he said he likes killing walkers. I hope TTG will make this character really interesting, like Lily who was also a little boring at the begginning of story.
    7. Nick - I don't dislike him. He is just the most irritating. I can't believe Pete (perhaps the most clever person in TWD so far) was his uncle.
  • edited March 2014
    1. Luke - He is the nicest (living) character in S2 so far, caring, brave and seems trustworthy. What's not to like?
    2. Pete - He was pretty awesome. Kind, brave and wise. Shame he had to die.
    3. Nick - He's pretty flawed - clumsy, impulsive, aggressive - but at least he's honest and not a coward (I'm looking at you Ben). He's going though a lot and I feel bad for him.
    4. Sarah - I really like her innocence. It's the same thing I liked about Clem in S1 which she has now somewhat lost.
    5. Rebecca - I didn't like her in E1 but she's redeemed herself for the most part. She's also going through a lot of stuff so I decided to forgive her bitchy attitude.
    6. Carlos - He's not a bad guy, just kinda dumb. Really dumb actually.
    7. Alvin - I don't know what to think of him. He helped Clem, so he's probably nice, but then again he seems to be hiding some dark secrets.
  • edited March 2014
    1. Uncle Pete ( He was such a badass! Probaply my most favourite character of the whole game, excluding Lee, Clem and Kenny ofcourse. That goes without saying.)

    2. Luke ( I'm not a big Luke fan to be honest, but he's nice and loyal. )

    3. Sarah ( She's my BFF! I gave her the unbreakable pinky swear!)

    4. Carlos ( I didn't like him in Episode1, but i liked his character development in Episode2.)

    5. Alvin ( Well...he's okay i gues.)

    6. Rebbeca (She was a bitch in episode1, so i don't quite like her that much. She became a bit nicer in episode2 though.)

    7. Nick ( I know alot of people seem to like Nick alot, but he just isn't sympathetic to me. I know he lost alot of people recently and i know that his intentions are good, but that's no excuse for all the bad and idiotic things he has done so far. )

  • edited March 2014
    1. Pete
    2. Luke
    3. Alvin (He's a good guy..)
    4. Nick
    5. Carlos
    6. Rebecca
    7. Sarah
    1. Uncle Pete - These dipshits probably would have killed me without Uncle Pete and now he's dead so I feel like I have to put him here in memorium. RIP best uncle you will be missed.
    2. Nick - Nick is struggling a lot emotionally and I sympathize and identify with that. He makes mistakes and has his flaws but at the end of the day he's honest and was willing to risk his life at the distillery shed so Clem could get away safe. He's grown to become one of my favorite characters in the game, if not my absolute favorite.
    3. Sarah - Sarah is sweet and strange. I love moments with her--I loved hearing about her weird sci fi books, I loved how fascinated she was by the gross dog bite, I love that she snaps photos and gets excited about the Christmas tree. She's a hope spot in a very dark story. I doubt it will last but I'm savoring it the best I can.
    4. Rebecca - Like Nick, Rebecca is also very flawed and because of her experiences has grown very guarded, but I can tell she and Clementine are going to grow a close bond. I'm not fond of how she treated Clem in ep 1, but ep 2 redeemed her full circle to me. The moment where Clem listened to her baby kick was very endearing to me.
    5. Carlos - Hot dad 10/10 would bang, but almost unrealistically incompetent at times. I appreciate his dedication to Sarah and his close bond with her but I feel like some of his stifling is unnecessary and dangerous, and the naivety he's fostered in her may come back to bite him in the ass.
    6. Alvin - I liked him a lot in ep 1 because he and Uncle Pete were the only ones who didn't want to feed me to the wolves, but between him making Clem go into the building to look for food by herself, Rebecca being genuinely terrified of how he'll react if the baby isn't his, and then Carver mentioning he killed a guy, I'm... not sure how I feel about Alvin. I can't gauge him
    7. Luke - Luke is flighty, indecisive, and secretive. Like Alvin, I have difficulty gauging what kind of person he is and what his motives are. Him insisting that we lie to Matthew was the moment I stopped trusting him and I feel like he's got some morally ambiguous skeletons in his closet. Also I don't like the way he patronizes Nick. But 10/10 would bang.
    1. Nick. His intentions are good, but I always believed he could rise against his fear. Ironically, I got him killed.
    2. Carlos. Unlike most others, I liked him from Episode 1. He's just a guy trying to protect his daughter. Even if he's sometimes a complete idiot.
    3. Luke. The archetypal big brother, at least I thought. But I still trust him.
    4. Sarah. At first I didn't know what to think of her. She was odd quite often. But she opened up a lot in Episode 2.
    5. Rebecca. Again, like Carlos, I know she's going through a lot of stuff, so I don't lash out at her.
    6. Pete. Oh Pete. I didn't save you. Sorry.
    7. Alvin. He's not a bad guy at all, it's just that I don't really know him all that well.
    1. Nick
    2. Luke
    3. Sarah
    4. Alvin
    5. Pete
    6. Carlos
    7. Rebecca
  • DeceptioDeceptio Banned
    edited March 2014

    Here's my list. I don't really have a hatred against anyone so far, so I just ordered them in order on how much I like them.

    1. Nick: Most people hate him, and think he's the new Ben. I can't compare him to Ben, as Nick lives up to his mistakes and is overall a good guy as my Clementine said in Episode 2. Sure he fucked up a couple times, but he has some sense of leadership and can handle himself and shoot a gun, all traits that Ben didn't have. (Not hating on Ben) He's just really likable to me, I don't completely know why yet.

    2. Luke: His brother-sister relationship with Clementine is mainly why he's such a likeable character, and that he's the one who cares for Clementine the most.

    3. Carlos: I think he's a badass. He's been nicer to Clementine since Episode 1 and he's one of the most useful members of the group in my opinion.

    4. Pete: Just a nice man. He treated Clementine really well and defended her whenever the others accused her of being bit. Too bad he had to die.

    5. Alvin: Not too much character development from him yet, but the few times we've seen him he's been nice for the most part. Although I don't think he's TOO helpful to the group, as all he's been doing is sitting around and being lazy. But he's pretty nice so far to cover in that negative.

    6. Rebecca: Yeah she's nice now, but the reason why she's so low in the list is because of the way she treated Clementine in Episode 1. She was a total bitch. She's nice now, but she's going to have to redeem herself a bit more if she wants to top the others.

    7. Sarah: I don't hate Sarah, but I don't love her either. She's a pretty funny character, but she's pretty annoying at some times. She's just one of those girly girls to me, even though that's not the main reason why she's annoying. I can't really explain why she annoys me a bit, it's weird.

    1. Luke
    2. Nick
    3. Pete
    4. Alvin
    5. Carlos
    6. Rebecca
    7. Sarah
    1. Luke
    2. Nick
    3. Pete
    4. Carlos
    5. Alvin
    6. Sarah
    7. Rebecca
Sign in to comment in this discussion.