Is first season ending superable?

edited April 2014 in The Walking Dead

ENORMOUS SPOILER AHEAD

To this date i havent met someone who hasnt have some kind of emotional reaction to first season ending and that is mainly cause they kill the main protagonist Lee someone you have learned to love and worry about and the relation you have build with Clementine ( for whom you worry even more about) and right now the only way i can imagine of superating it is by killing Clementine wich i highly doubt but you know that everything is possible

Comments

  • Not with the current lead writer.

  • edited April 2014

    ...ouch.

    Alt text

    I don't have anything to say about this statement other than I would not like receiving it; can't disagree, though.

    Not with the current lead writer.

  • ItsGabeeItsGabee Banned
    edited April 2014

    My big brother didn't feel anything when he finished S1
    Here's the actual convo:

    Me: Did you cry on Season 1 Episode 5???

    BigBro: Nope.

    Me: Really?

    BigBro, Did you?

    Me: Yup.

    BigBro: chuckles...

  • Tell your big brother he is rude enough to enter salty´s spitoon

    ItsGabee posted: »

    My big brother didn't feel anything when he finished S1 Here's the actual convo: Me: Did you cry on Season 1 Episode 5??? BigBro: Nope. Me: Really? BigBro, Did you? Me: Yup. BigBro: chuckles...

  • Though he did write A House Divided which was okay, it's still a shame he's writing Episode 5. The guy who wrote TWAU Ep1 is writing In Harm's Way, which is good.

    Not with the current lead writer.

  • Not rude, Has a heart of freaking STEEL.

    ps3gamer095 posted: »

    Tell your big brother he is rude enough to enter salty´s spitoon

  • I didn't cry. I got sad sure, but it went away after the credits. I didn't really care much about Lee, as long as Clem was okay.

  • Yup, sums up my opinion. I do think he did a fine job in various areas of A House Divided, but a frigging finale? Throw your throw all your best writers and their grandmother to make that please.

    How shall I put this? I like for the most part how he is writing the overall plot, and a few good scenes with our characters, but it is a little rough around the edges on characterization, development and consistency of the cast. Maybe that isn't just his problem; maybe the new design philosophy Telltale's been taking limits what scenes he can add to only those absolutely needed for the plot to advance, I don't know.

    An episode ends up being the combined imput of director, writers, designers, etc. It's hard to discern who did what. So far, I get the impression that he's doing an ok job, just not something mind-blowing.

    JakeSt123 posted: »

    Though he did write A House Divided which was okay, it's still a shame he's writing Episode 5. The guy who wrote TWAU Ep1 is writing In Harm's Way, which is good.

  • Your brother is a good liar.

    ItsGabee posted: »

    My big brother didn't feel anything when he finished S1 Here's the actual convo: Me: Did you cry on Season 1 Episode 5??? BigBro: Nope. Me: Really? BigBro, Did you? Me: Yup. BigBro: chuckles...

  • I wish they'd got Mark Darin to write an episode. Starved For Help had possibly the best Character Interaction/Puzzle/Plot Development ratio and a great climax, and that's probably why it's almost the most universally liked episode.

    Yup, sums up my opinion. I do think he did a fine job in various areas of A House Divided, but a frigging finale? Throw your throw all your

  • i never said cry i said emotional reaction

    I didn't cry. I got sad sure, but it went away after the credits. I didn't really care much about Lee, as long as Clem was okay.

  • i also thought the same

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    Your brother is a good liar.

  • I didn't cry at the end, and didn't know of anyone doing so until I joined this forum. It was emotional and sad, but I didn't cry.

    ItsGabee posted: »

    My big brother didn't feel anything when he finished S1 Here's the actual convo: Me: Did you cry on Season 1 Episode 5??? BigBro: Nope. Me: Really? BigBro, Did you? Me: Yup. BigBro: chuckles...

  • Because you're a hardened manly man. No one can compete with your stout and brawny man essence. You are a manly god amongst wimpy men.

    I didn't cry at the end, and didn't know of anyone doing so until I joined this forum. It was emotional and sad, but I didn't cry.

  • The only thing missing from him is a Kenny-stache.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    Because you're a hardened manly man. No one can compete with your stout and brawny man essence. You are a manly god amongst wimpy men.

  • Killing Clementine wouldn't make me cry, it would make me RAGE. Still an emotional reaction, sure, but far from the right one.

    Unless TTG actually does it in hopes of enraging gamers everywhere. Which would actually be kind of hilarious.

  • Good of you to notice. Really though, lol, I just didn't cry. I wasn't trying to judge anyone who did. I was just making it known that not everyone cried at the end. I do consider it one of, if not the most heart wrenching scenes in any game I've ever played, however.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    Because you're a hardened manly man. No one can compete with your stout and brawny man essence. You are a manly god amongst wimpy men.

  • edited April 2014

    Just in case that does happen, I want everyone to sharpen their pitchforks and gather their torches. We'll be ready to fuck shit up.
    And don't forget to put on those Clem hats ;)

    Killing Clementine wouldn't make me cry, it would make me RAGE. Still an emotional reaction, sure, but far from the right one. Unless TTG actually does it in hopes of enraging gamers everywhere. Which would actually be kind of hilarious.

  • I know. I was just giving you a hard time, friend. Sorry!

    Good of you to notice. Really though, lol, I just didn't cry. I wasn't trying to judge anyone who did. I was just making it known that not e

  • He has redeemed himself, fellow gamers!

    Good of you to notice. Really though, lol, I just didn't cry. I wasn't trying to judge anyone who did. I was just making it known that not e

  • For all you know I have a Kenny Stache, being the Godlike essence of masculinity I've been proclaimed to be. No Godlike essence of masculinity comes complete without a Kenny Stache.

    The only thing missing from him is a Kenny-stache.

  • I know, lol.

    Viva-La-Lee posted: »

    I know. I was just giving you a hard time, friend. Sorry!

  • Damn straight :)

    For all you know I have a Kenny Stache, being the Godlike essence of masculinity I've been proclaimed to be. No Godlike essence of masculinity comes complete without a Kenny Stache.

  • You have my keyboard.

    Alt text

    Just in case that does happen, I want everyone to sharpen their pitchforks and gather their torches. We'll be ready to fuck shit up. And don't forget to put on those Clem hats

Sign in to comment in this discussion.