That post was linked in Espurr's post, and I do agree with the overall comment that he's the deconstructed hero. He keeps trying to do good but doesn't have the overall strength to do good. I don't agree with the Luke using Clem thing, although I agree with the WRITERS using Luke and Clem to grow and develop off each other.
Yesssssssssss the voice. THAT voice. It's perfect. If anything, they should use him for the credits
I actually saw another long post about someone's theory and perception about what Luke's character is all about:
http://skooth.tumblr.com… more/post/86285352707/michael-7123-skooth-i-really-disliked-luke-a
I don't know how much I agree with it (I definitely don't agree with Luke wanting to utilize Clem). I think Luke could just be a genuinely good guy who wants to protect as many people as he can. The whole wanting to be a hero thing could make sense, though.
Have you ever heard Scott Porter sing? Ughhh. He has such a nice voice. They should do something with it.
They actually already made a thread about that on here, I linked to it on my post since it is a very great theory/character analysis, althou… moregh like you I didn't agree about the Luke utilizing Clem part too, but for the most part it's a solid theory. Although I don't think it comes from Luke consciously wanting to be a hero, it's just that the world he lives in doesn't allow for heroes, and he happens to be the character that fits the ideal hero role.
And hm, I don't know about the Luke singing part. I keep seeing people suggesting that, but I don't think it'd work in-game unless they can set it up really well and it suits the mood right.
Haha, well personally I would've liked permission first so I would've known to come here sooner, but I posted it to share with the internet so obviously people sharing it wouldn't bother me, and you gave credit so no hard feelings. And yeah I noticed Luke gets bashed a lot, not only here but all over the internet it seems, so I had to get it out of my system. I'm glad my post stuck out to you though, I was scared I was the only one that felt that way, so good to know I'm not alone. And hi fives back.
And gah, I'm sorry you had to deal with that troll earlier, that seems to be another thing going on, people dismiss people with flower crown Luke avatars as stupid fangirls that can't hold up a good argument just because of a picture.
OMG, WOW. THANK HEAVENS you don't have it out for me, I felt like I should have taken your permission first, but you're cool with it, at lea… morest!! Firstly, I loved your post. Really. If you've been around here much, you'll realise Luke gets bashed a lot here too, saw your post and it really struck with me. I'm huge into symbolism and hidden meanings and it felt RIGHT and if you look at the comments here a lot of people agree!
Maaaan, forget the nuances. You had a great post. You keep overanalysing. because to me, it felt exactly right!
YOU GO GIRL!
By the way, I found out what happens if you don't make Clem resist against Luke when he returns! Apparently she'll break free, yell "stop". He'll then be like hey, hey, it's just me.
That post was linked in Espurr's post, and I do agree with the overall comment that he's the deconstructed hero. He keeps trying to do good … morebut doesn't have the overall strength to do good. I don't agree with the Luke using Clem thing, although I agree with the WRITERS using Luke and Clem to grow and develop off each other.
Yesssssssssss the voice. THAT voice. It's perfect. If anything, they should use him for the credits
Yeah, had it been mine, I'd have liked to know too, I'm still getting used to tumblr, I learned there's ask boxes things now, would have been nice to know when I posted this hahaha XD I'll credit your username in the orginal post, now that you're here That's just proof of Telltales good writing, that we all have crazy, varying opinions about a single character!
Ah, don't worry about the troll. I was asking for it with such a pro-luke post. I was expecting a few. Yeah, our adorable avatars have got a bad rep, but fangirl or not, we can defend anyone with legitimate reasons!
Haha, well personally I would've liked permission first so I would've known to come here sooner, but I posted it to share with the internet … moreso obviously people sharing it wouldn't bother me, and you gave credit so no hard feelings. And yeah I noticed Luke gets bashed a lot, not only here but all over the internet it seems, so I had to get it out of my system. I'm glad my post stuck out to you though, I was scared I was the only one that felt that way, so good to know I'm not alone. And hi fives back.
And gah, I'm sorry you had to deal with that troll earlier, that seems to be another thing going on, people dismiss people with flower crown Luke avatars as stupid fangirls that can't hold up a good argument just because of a picture.
By the way, I found out what happens if you don't make Clem resist against Luke when he returns! Apparently she'll break free, yell "stop". He'll then be like hey, hey, it's just me.
Ah, I see so you were new to tumblr, their messaging system isn't always the best though, but it works well enough. And yeah everyone has different characters they can identify with or not, and that's what makes them realistic.
I would've expected more, but looks like people have been pretty civil about it, which is nice. I like your avatars, and find it stupid people can judge someone's intelligence by them, so keep on rockin' your avatar. ;D
Yeah, had it been mine, I'd have liked to know too, I'm still getting used to tumblr, I learned there's ask boxes things now, would have bee… moren nice to know when I posted this hahaha XD I'll credit your username in the orginal post, now that you're here That's just proof of Telltales good writing, that we all have crazy, varying opinions about a single character!
Ah, don't worry about the troll. I was asking for it with such a pro-luke post. I was expecting a few. Yeah, our adorable avatars have got a bad rep, but fangirl or not, we can defend anyone with legitimate reasons!
FInally hopped on to the bandwagon, but hell, it's just great cause this fandom's quite small. These characters are gold, the fact season one's finale made me and EVERYONE cry, that, is the true power of the writing!
People here are afraid of the good ol' mods, that's why. They do their job pretty efficently!! Hey, thanks, I'm no photoshop whiz, but YouTube fixed that! I'll keep it to have people underestimate me evil laugh
Ah, I see so you were new to tumblr, their messaging system isn't always the best though, but it works well enough. And yeah everyone has di… morefferent characters they can identify with or not, and that's what makes them realistic.
I would've expected more, but looks like people have been pretty civil about it, which is nice. I like your avatars, and find it stupid people can judge someone's intelligence by them, so keep on rockin' your avatar. ;D
Comments
That post was linked in Espurr's post, and I do agree with the overall comment that he's the deconstructed hero. He keeps trying to do good but doesn't have the overall strength to do good. I don't agree with the Luke using Clem thing, although I agree with the WRITERS using Luke and Clem to grow and develop off each other.
Yesssssssssss the voice. THAT voice. It's perfect. If anything, they should use him for the credits
Yeah, agreed. If the ZA world can take Lee, there's literally no boundaries.
It'd be such a nice touch to the game to have Luke sing, but you're right, unless it sets the mood it may do nothing. Credits song it is then!
Haha, well personally I would've liked permission first so I would've known to come here sooner, but I posted it to share with the internet so obviously people sharing it wouldn't bother me, and you gave credit so no hard feelings. And yeah I noticed Luke gets bashed a lot, not only here but all over the internet it seems, so I had to get it out of my system. I'm glad my post stuck out to you though, I was scared I was the only one that felt that way, so good to know I'm not alone. And hi fives back.
And gah, I'm sorry you had to deal with that troll earlier, that seems to be another thing going on, people dismiss people with flower crown Luke avatars as stupid fangirls that can't hold up a good argument just because of a picture.
By the way, I found out what happens if you don't make Clem resist against Luke when he returns! Apparently she'll break free, yell "stop". He'll then be like hey, hey, it's just me.
Yeah, had it been mine, I'd have liked to know too, I'm still getting used to tumblr, I learned there's ask boxes things now, would have been nice to know when I posted this hahaha XD I'll credit your username in the orginal post, now that you're here
That's just proof of Telltales good writing, that we all have crazy, varying opinions about a single character!
Ah, don't worry about the troll. I was asking for it with such a pro-luke post. I was expecting a few. Yeah, our adorable avatars have got a bad rep, but fangirl or not, we can defend anyone with legitimate reasons!
Ah, cool! It's still Luke hecking up in his trying to talk to Clem attempts but freaking her out beforehand XD He'll never learn sigh
Ah, I see so you were new to tumblr, their messaging system isn't always the best though, but it works well enough. And yeah everyone has different characters they can identify with or not, and that's what makes them realistic.
I would've expected more, but looks like people have been pretty civil about it, which is nice. I like your avatars, and find it stupid people can judge someone's intelligence by them, so keep on rockin' your avatar. ;D
FInally hopped on to the bandwagon, but hell, it's just great cause this fandom's quite small. These characters are gold, the fact season one's finale made me and EVERYONE cry, that, is the true power of the writing!
People here are afraid of the good ol' mods, that's why. They do their job pretty efficently!! Hey, thanks, I'm no photoshop whiz, but YouTube fixed that! I'll keep it to have people underestimate me evil laugh
For those who might not know the reference you can watch at 5:50