In episode 4, when searching the walkers, you can say "we should look for the others", Jane replies "Would anyone else do this for you?". The only person you can say by name is "Luke would."
Luke sucks,
You think i care if someone calls me a bad name, LOL. I been in high school i think i can handle Kenny's tantrum. Kenny is t… morehe only reliable adult taking care of that baby. Everyone knows Luke would abandon it if it meant giving him a higher chance of coming out alive. Luke isn't trustworthy, and i think this episode proves how unreliable he is.
OK Luke fans answer me this: Would Luke risk his life for Clementine as Lee did in Season 1.
Would Kenny?
i'm a little scared he'll take the baby so then i'll have to go with him bc i dont want anything to happen to the baby. I'd rather side with neither of them
My god. Seriously?
Kenny lost his girlfriend, the only positive thing left in his life after his family died... And people get upset he's yelling at a girl?
I think he's pretty damn nice for someone that just lost his eye and again, lost everything he fought for.
I like both Luke and Kenny but for me I will go with Luke, I still care about Kenny and he is still one of my favourite characters but I actually have grown to like Luke more, I can see people talking about how Luke slept with Jane was bad so now they are going with Kenny fair enough everyone has their own opinion, if you like Kenny more that's fine with me, everyone has their own opinions but I fail to see how Luke making a mistake makes him a bad guy, he appologised what else can he do? No character in the game is perfect, even Mike who people love has a flaw (minor) that he is grumpy when he is tired, just like in reality everyone has flaws and this episode to me make Luke seem more human as we could see a flaw of his, we got to see both Luke and Kenny's flaws yet since we have known kenny for longer we have already seen his flaws and know his flaws. Flaws are what make us human, I remember when before episode 4 everyone was mad at Luke for being too 'perfect' now they are mad when he makes a mistake he can't win can he!
In episode 4, if you don't chop Sarita's arm off and you make to the safe zone with Jane and Rebecca, you go talk to Kenny and you say you're sorry, that's when he's holding Sarita who's turning and says, "Oh look honey, Clementine's sorry." in a sarcastic way.
Neither of them are very optimal choices at this point. Luke means wells, but he also has a lot of lapses in judgement, and he doesn't seem to think through. Kenny isn't exactly a supportive person, he rushes to judgement quickly, and he has a history of lashing out at people. Also, he will ditch Lee over differences in opinion in some playthroughs. Neither of them seem like leader material to me. If it came down to a choice, then I would choose Kenny because he seems to be much better at survival than Luke. I would do this with the knowledge that Kenny would turn his back on me at any moment, and that Clementine would be forced to walk on eggshells the whole time around them.
Either way, Clem isn't in a very good situation. She has to work with what she has though.
Luke so far have shown no reason at all and indirectly put the group in danger showing that an inexperienced survivor. I owe nothing to Luke not even life. Even Mike and Bonnie have done more than Luke in 2 episodes.
Kenny always had that attitude even with Lee, because Kenny would go to expect change by Clem. Also, Kenny is from Florida always'll beat the shit mouth.
A difficult decision for me is... Lilly or Kenny would have to see how Lilly would be now.
In episode 4, if you don't chop Sarita's arm off and you make to the safe zone with Jane and Rebecca, you go talk to Kenny and you say you'r… moree sorry, that's when he's holding Sarita who's turning and says, "Oh look honey, Clementine's sorry." in a sarcastic way.
I agree that Luke isn't leadership material - and to me neither is Kenny.
This isn't why I would choose Luke, but from that angle I would argue that Luke is the one who it is easier to "force" into a follower role.
Kenny will always press for his own ideas, hate everyone else's (unless they're his in disguise), and if the group decides against his idea, will simly go right ahead anyway. He has a need to be the leader, but he just can't cut the mustard.
Neither of them are very optimal choices at this point. Luke means wells, but he also has a lot of lapses in judgement, and he doesn't seem … moreto think through. Kenny isn't exactly a supportive person, he rushes to judgement quickly, and he has a history of lashing out at people. Also, he will ditch Lee over differences in opinion in some playthroughs. Neither of them seem like leader material to me. If it came down to a choice, then I would choose Kenny because he seems to be much better at survival than Luke. I would do this with the knowledge that Kenny would turn his back on me at any moment, and that Clementine would be forced to walk on eggshells the whole time around them.
Either way, Clem isn't in a very good situation. She has to work with what she has though.
There is no right answer for this. They both have pros and cons and they both have made their fair share of mistakes both in their actions and what they have said.
I'm giving them both the benefit of the doubt until the final episode, though we can all feel it building up to the possibility that we are going to have to choose one or the other.
Kenny explicitly tells a little girl, who he knows has gone through unspeakable traumas and has lost even more loved ones than he has that i… moret was all her fault that his girlfriend died and never apologizes (except in one very very specific dialogue choice).
He shoots one of Carver's soldiers even after Clem explicitly warns him against it, leading to Walter's senseless death. As Bonnie rightfully says, Carver only killed Walter because "he was protecting his people and Kenny could've killed [them] all."
He puts the entire group at risk by indulging in his murder porn torture fantasy even after everyone tells him several times to just shoot Carver so they can escape. He never acknowledges that said murder porn torture fantasy is the reason they wasted a half dozen precious minutes they could've used to escape, which led to them being caught by Troy, leading to another half dozen minutes wasted.
The group could've been long gone before… [view original content]
Can't stand the people who blindly follow Kenny .....bit still if Kenny Luke and clem could just get it together and will to as a loyal team. I think they could make it threw anything
Comments
he was just upset,hes lost everything and now he lost yet another person he cared about,and judging by how rebecca looked she was gonna die anyway.
forget that,if i want both im taking both
Wow, this picture just screams: GAMEFACE - ON.
Both are cool,I don't know which one side's I would like to go
In episode 4, when searching the walkers, you can say "we should look for the others", Jane replies "Would anyone else do this for you?". The only person you can say by name is "Luke would."
Since when?
Nah, the timer will probably run out and you'll be eaten by a Sarah walker or some shit. Idk, it's telltale.
i'm a little scared he'll take the baby so then i'll have to go with him bc i dont want anything to happen to the baby. I'd rather side with neither of them
How did Luke even manage to get into Carver's camp anyways.
"Let's not forget it was Kennys Decision to leave and find shelter which killed Rebecca"
Rebecca didnt care about leaving. So she kind of killed herself.. so
LMAO
I like Luke, but ill choose Kenny in most situations, I just think he's much more valuable
When did Kenny say "Oh look honey, Clementine's sorry" ?
My god. Seriously?
Kenny lost his girlfriend, the only positive thing left in his life after his family died... And people get upset he's yelling at a girl?
I think he's pretty damn nice for someone that just lost his eye and again, lost everything he fought for.
I like both Luke and Kenny but for me I will go with Luke, I still care about Kenny and he is still one of my favourite characters but I actually have grown to like Luke more, I can see people talking about how Luke slept with Jane was bad so now they are going with Kenny fair enough everyone has their own opinion, if you like Kenny more that's fine with me, everyone has their own opinions but I fail to see how Luke making a mistake makes him a bad guy, he appologised what else can he do? No character in the game is perfect, even Mike who people love has a flaw (minor) that he is grumpy when he is tired, just like in reality everyone has flaws and this episode to me make Luke seem more human as we could see a flaw of his, we got to see both Luke and Kenny's flaws yet since we have known kenny for longer we have already seen his flaws and know his flaws. Flaws are what make us human, I remember when before episode 4 everyone was mad at Luke for being too 'perfect' now they are mad when he makes a mistake he can't win can he!
In episode 4, if you don't chop Sarita's arm off and you make to the safe zone with Jane and Rebecca, you go talk to Kenny and you say you're sorry, that's when he's holding Sarita who's turning and says, "Oh look honey, Clementine's sorry." in a sarcastic way.
You do realize he said that out of anger. Sarita just died, what do you expect him to say?
Neither of them are very optimal choices at this point. Luke means wells, but he also has a lot of lapses in judgement, and he doesn't seem to think through. Kenny isn't exactly a supportive person, he rushes to judgement quickly, and he has a history of lashing out at people. Also, he will ditch Lee over differences in opinion in some playthroughs. Neither of them seem like leader material to me. If it came down to a choice, then I would choose Kenny because he seems to be much better at survival than Luke. I would do this with the knowledge that Kenny would turn his back on me at any moment, and that Clementine would be forced to walk on eggshells the whole time around them.
Either way, Clem isn't in a very good situation. She has to work with what she has though.
#TEAMUSTACHE
Luke so far have shown no reason at all and indirectly put the group in danger showing that an inexperienced survivor. I owe nothing to Luke not even life. Even Mike and Bonnie have done more than Luke in 2 episodes.
Kenny always had that attitude even with Lee, because Kenny would go to expect change by Clem. Also, Kenny is from Florida always'll beat the shit mouth.
A difficult decision for me is... Lilly or Kenny would have to see how Lilly would be now.
But Luke vs Kenny... Kenny Vote for sure.
#TEAMLILLY TOO
What an ass... I mean I get where he's coming from, but he didn't have to say that and all the other rude things..
I would expect him to either say nothing, to thank X for the support, or to say "I just want to be alone right now".
I agree that Luke isn't leadership material - and to me neither is Kenny.
This isn't why I would choose Luke, but from that angle I would argue that Luke is the one who it is easier to "force" into a follower role.
Kenny will always press for his own ideas, hate everyone else's (unless they're his in disguise), and if the group decides against his idea, will simly go right ahead anyway. He has a need to be the leader, but he just can't cut the mustard.
I think Kenny will be bitten he is going crazy and I do not think he will be able to hold it together
For much longer
Kenny's not like that. He doesn't handle death well.
There is no right answer for this. They both have pros and cons and they both have made their fair share of mistakes both in their actions and what they have said.
I'm giving them both the benefit of the doubt until the final episode, though we can all feel it building up to the possibility that we are going to have to choose one or the other.
Some may choose Kenny. Some may choose Luke.
Which is yet another reason why Kenny is a serious liability to any group
Oh yeah guys. Fight a little more...
I love Kenny, I really do. But he would not be safe for Clementine. He's just.. Kenny!
Can't stand the people who blindly follow Kenny .....bit still if Kenny Luke and clem could just get it together and will to as a loyal team. I think they could make it threw anything