How Should Lilly be reintroduced?
Hi, guys! This is my first post!
Most likely Lilly will be reintroduced next episode(Episode 3: In Harms Way). Originally, Lilly was supposed to be the same Lilly that killed Lori Grimes and Judith Grimes while in command of The Governor(Issue #48). However, after Kirkman released the novel "The Road to Woodbury" it contained a different backstory for the character. So, Robert Kirkman confirmed through "Letter Hacks" that the Lilly from TellTales The Walking Dead and the Lilly from the Novels/Comics are two separate people. So, now TellTale can bring Lilly back! I have some ideas:
Carver locks up Clementine in a dark room. Clementine is about to sit down when she hears a rustle from the back of the dark room. She goes to investigate when Lilly jumps out of the shadows. Clementine can either hug Lilly, say- "Your still alive", remain silent or the option I would choose, Clementine smacks Lilly across the face and replies "That was for Carley/Doug."
Lilly is Carvers "right hand girl". She is a high ranking member of the community and is very loyal to Carver. It will be up to players to decide her ultimate fate.
So, what do you guys think?
Comments
well im gonna thumbs up this because I know that you mentioned lilly your gonna get a barrage of down votes lol.
I like both those options I hope we see her again
I want to smack Lilly for killing my favorite character(Carley). But I can't do that if she's not around! Thanks for thumb-upping it!
I don't even want too many characters to appear in the same place or else the story wouldn't be random enough anymore.
I would like it if she were one of Carver's soldiers, but not his second in command or anything. She's just some random grunt in his militia patrolling the community edge when Carver shows up with everyone captive. As they slowly file past her... "What the fuck? Kenny, is that you?" For the rest of the Episode she uses her position in Carver's community to make Kenny's life hell because of what he did to Larry, all while he is powerless and can't fight back because he's a captive.
as much as I love Kenny I would like to see that would make the story even more cooler and since she had a soft spot for clem maybe clem can convince her to stop
Welcome to the forums!
Exactly. Before, both of them were pretty much on even ground, but now Lilly would have all the power. I think Kenny's reaction to that situation would be really interesting, and the player could encourage her actions, or try to get her to stop.
can I just ask why does everyone think Lily is coming back? it would be interesting if she did but there are alot of people who think she is 100% coming back the only reason most of us knew Kenny was coming back was because Telltale said his fate would be explored and his game files were found anyway if she comes back I think she should be apart of Carvers group and like someone said above she should give Kenny a harder time than the others in the group for what he did to Larry
This may not be a popular choice, but I think Lilly should be reintroduced by storming into Carver's camp(in the RV if you let her drive off with it) dressed like Rambo with a machine gun and grenades shooting and blowing up everything she sees. And after the smoke clears and Carver's men are dead, she screams, "I'm no scared little girl!". Then everyone goes back to her psycho camp where Clementine starts becoming crazy and rubs blood on her face(Episode 4 title card), thinking she's a brave warrior like Lilly.
I'm not saying she is and to be honest I don't think she will but I hope she does she was an interesting character and it would be cool to see how she reacts to seeing clem and Kenny again especially since she doesn't know Kenny's family is dead maybe she will sympathize with that
Haha why is Lilly 'jumping out of the shadows' in the first scenario? I would probably think she was a walker and try to bust her head open.
I like the second one.
yea fair enough I just ment that there are a lot of people who are deadset on her coming back and I just don't understand why but I do agree it would be cool to see how she reacts to seeing Clem and Kenny but I just don't see it happening
Thanks
The reason she is "jumping out of the shadows" is that she is sick of being constantly abused by Carvers men.
Ohh, alright. In that case I would stay silent. It would be amusing to see how she would break the ice.
I would go for number two cause it's seems that would mostly likely happen if she does return also welcome to the hood!
Lilly: So....how bout that weather?!
Thanks!
If you left Lilly on the road she will be more hostile towards Kenny. If you took her, Lilly will forgive Kenny. Lilly can survive the season if you make peace between Kenny and Lilly and convince Lilly to rebel against Carver.
I don't think 100% that we'll ever see her again, I just throw out scenarios I'd like to see if she did make her return. Given that Kenny is back in the mix, Lilly returning as well could really make for an interesting dynamic given the group's current situation.
This is a fantastic idea. As Clementine you could try to manipulate her to help you escape and earn her trust or if you really don't like her you could also berate her. Not the smartest move but the option would be nice for people who aren't exactly fans of her.
One of Carver's lieutenants. As I've said before, this would make for an interesting story, because perhaps her loyalties would be divided, and also, she'd be in a position of power over Kenny, and would be able to enact her revenge... If she wanted to of course.
I would like if she came to save the group. It would go something like this.
The group is trapped in Carver's base. After a hard victory of fighting the horde of walkers Lilly and people who came with Tavia in 400 day's (except Bonnie as she is a spy in this scenario) come to kill Carver and free the people he was "protecting." Bonnie has told Clem about this plan and gives you the choice to tell your group or not. Once Lilly and Co come they fight with Carver's group with the help of the cabin and ski lodge group. Lilly sees Clem and looks shocked saying "Clementine?... Is that you?" she begins to cry "I'm sorry I left. I'm sorry I killed Carley(or Doug). Carver comes in and him and Lilly start brawling. Carver has beaten Lilly and she is on the ground and Carver is pointing a gun at her head. Kenny was fighting with with Carver's right hand (Troy I guess) is holding Kenny's head toward a walker that is on the other side of a fence. Clem has a gun but knows she can't save them both.
This brings the decision that people mention. Most people would save Kenny. But after Lilly had apologized you may feel the need to give her a second chance and you can also kill Carver. If you save Kenny, Troy dies but Carver escapes killing Lilly. Telltale knows Lilly is hated and most players would save Kenny so they use that so Carver can escape. If you save Lilly however then Kenny dies but Carvers man lives. No matter what in one of the episodes you have to face Carver, or Troy (who I hope actually talks next episode) later on or even next season.
That would be the hardest decision of all time!
While I would love Lily's reappearance (I thought she was well written and could lead to very interesting scenarios, as mentioned in this thread), I get the feeling that bringing her back may make it a feel a bit too scripted, since Kenny has already appeared. Although, meeting Kenny was already more unlikely (story-wise, not Telltale-wise), being in a worse position, so it's pretty possible. No word on whether it's probable, however. I hope they do, but I don't know whether TTG is willing to bring her back.
Lilly was found no where in the game files for episode 3 nor 4
Only if they give Lilly a perfect explanation for how she made it this far and decided to travel the same was as everyone else, but out of the others from season one, she is probably the most likely to come back.
That's actually a pretty good theory, I can see that happening.
I would think so
. Thanks for reading it 
. Its not really possible but it would be pretty cool if something like that happened.
Like everyone is saying this season "heading up north" or to "Wellington". Maybe Lilly also was heading there, but Carver found her and decided to stay idk.
Earth will crack and she will arise from hell!
I absolutely agree! Her fate was WAY to open ended for my liking.
I'd like Lilly to be introduced as a rotting corpse.
She might make the same mistake Kenny did and ask about Lee.
I think if they reintroduce one of the most hated characters, they're going to have to do something like this:
Clem and Co. is heading north towards Wellington, when they're jumped by bandits. Lilly is among them, but when she notices Clem, she orders her boys to stand down.When they refuse to do so, she attacks them, and allows Clem and Co. to continue unharmed.
She wandered around... How did Kenny get to the exact place where Clem ended up? We have no explanation for this, yet it is, and nobody cares.
Who knows? Maybe she was kept under extreme wraps, and is nowhere to be found solely because they include all her data in episode 3's download, and they don't want a repeat of Kenny.
I hope christa returns too so her and Lilly will have a rivalry or something
Seconds before being front-kicked into a wheat thresher.
Lilly is roaming the forest when...BLAM Lilly falls to the ground with a bullet hole to chest
Clem: That was for Carley/Doug!