VERY hard decision, what would YOU do?

so its about the end of episode 3.

you are playing as clementine(as usual) and you are about to break out of carvers camp, when you walk in a hallway with one door on the left and one door on the right. the doors have little square windows on them so you can see whats inside. the door on the left has the cabin group tied up with carlos,sarah,kenny and so on.(if Alvin and/or nick lived in your EP.2 playthrough they will be in there also.

the door on the right has Christa in there. this whole time you didn't know she was there, you just found out she was there. carver had tied her up in there.

Now you have to choose who to save because you here carvers men coming catching up to you.
(The Cabin Group) or (Christa)

which ever one you choose you will escape with, the other will be left behind because you don't have enough time to save both. which ever one you choose to save (lets say you save christa)

once you save her, you and her run off in the distance. once your a good distance ahead you look back to see the cabin group taken out of that room, all of them ar put up against a wall, and then there all taken out one by one, with a bullet to the brain.

if you choose to save the cabin group, the same will be done, but christa will die.

WHO WOULD YOU CHOOSE???!????

Comments

  • I would choose the cabin group. I mean, thinking of what's best for survival, in my opinion, more is better.

  • edited March 2014

    Nick or Christa Nick or Christa Nick or Christa... Fuck. This is tough.

    Nick. Gonna have to say Nick.

    Wait, is Nick dead if Walter saved him at this point?

    If so, Christa. Definitely Christa.

  • Hard....... Cabin group. I initially said Christa and wrote 15 lines on it but changed my mind. Now I don't want to write a whole bunch but basically because I promised Pete I would protect Nick.

  • edited March 2014

    Christa obviously! But wait...Kenny is with the cabin group now, hard decision.

    Clementine was together with Christa for almost 2years, she is like family to her. She only knows the cabin group for how long now? One week and the first thing they did was forcing her to sleep in a dirty old shed when she was having heavy pain. But on the other hand...Kenny is with the cabin group now, goddamnit i can't decide!

  • edited March 2014

    Well, if I went into this blind without knowing beforehand that whoever I leave behind would be immediately executed, I'd just automatically save Christa on instinct. She's the closest thing Clem has to family at this point.

    If I did know what was going to happen, I'd have to go with the Cabin Group and Kenny because I'm sure that's what Christa would want me to do. I'd hate to have Clem lose yet another person close to her, but it's the right thing to do.

    If whoever I left behind didn't have to die, though, I'd go with Christa 100%.

  • Kenny being with the Cabin group made it easy for me.

  • safety in numbers.....I'd go for the cabin group.

  • The cabin group of course! I like Christa and all but, come on! I can't let Sarah, Nick, Rebecca and all the others die in favor of one person!

  • edited March 2014

    I would love a save X or Christa decision this season. I want to say Christa but I don't want to condemn that many people all of which I like to death. It might be a little easier if Nick and Alvin were dead in my playthrough but since they're not I would probably save them and pray that Christa can forgive me.

  • First I would eat some Clementines. They help to think in such situations. :)

    Alt text

  • So you're saying 1 (Christa) vs the entire cabin group plus Kenny's group? Safety in numbers. And Christa's likely injured making her chances even worse. Not that much time has passed for Christa to heal from being stabbed or shot. Also remember, Christa blames Clem or at least harbors some ill will toward her for Omid's death. Seems Clem just might want to find Christa to make up for Omid's death and not to really find her because they're friends. Christa didn't seem to care much for her anymore judging from how cold she was toward Clem.

    Makes more sense to have the Cabin group vs Christa and Kenny's group. Depending on who died in Episode 2, the numbers would be closer. But given they're playing the Kenny vs Luke thing now, I doubt they'll play a Christa vs someone else because it's basically the same thing with a different set of characters. It's repetitive. It gets old if they keep pulling the same stunt over and over. Even if they did do it, Christa vs Lily makes more sense.

  • Easy choice for me, save the cabin group. Christa's life isn't worth the lives of the entire cabin group, not by a long shot. Even if I didn't know whoever I left behind would be killed, I'd still save the cabin group. It would still suck to leave Christa behind, but one person is just not worth an entire group of people no matter what fate awaits them.

  • As much as I want to say Christa, there are more people in the Cabin group and Christa just seems like shes okay with dying now after everything thats happened. I'd rather a lot of people survive than just one, as hard as that is to say.

  • Geesh. Maybe the cabin group, idk

  • nice. i didnt like peaches :DDDD

    WalkerHH93 posted: »

    First I would eat some Clementines. They help to think in such situations.

  • Can't tell if human meat or actual clementines

    WalkerHH93 posted: »

    First I would eat some Clementines. They help to think in such situations.

  • Only the St.Johns can tell you the answer for this question. ;)

    Can't tell if human meat or actual clementines

  • Easy, Cabin Group. I mean, I really like Christa, and maybe if there were more people with her... But I'd want to save more people as opposed to just Christa.

  • Cabin group. You get The Boatmaster and Luke, Christa is 1 person and was acting pretty emo in your last moments with her.

  • I would choose the cabin group. Damn, we can't change Kenny, Carlos and Luke for Christa. I'll miss her though :(

  • edited March 2014

    Christa didn't seem to care much for her anymore judging from how cold she was toward Clem.

    Christa's demeanor towards Clem was cold, yeah, but to say that she didn't care about her anymore? Bullshit.

    She was surrounded by 3 guys with weapons who held her at gunpoint and asked if she was with anyone and what did she do? She lied and said that she was by herself in order to protect Clem. And if Clem tries to sneak away and Christa gets stabbed in the leg by Winston, what was the first thing out of her mouth? "Clementine, RUN!"

    Christa might have harbored some resentment towards Clem over what happened with Omid, but if it really comes down to it, she'd do anything for that girl.

    So you're saying 1 (Christa) vs the entire cabin group plus Kenny's group? Safety in numbers. And Christa's likely injured making her chan

  • edited March 2014

    I'm going to sound terrible for saying this, but I would probably choose the cabin group. I've warmed up to almost all of them since "A House Divided", and I'd want to save as many lives as possible. Not to mention the fact that Kenny, my old pal, and Rebecca, who is pregnant, would be among those who would die if I chose Christa.

    To quote Spock again, "The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.".

  • I'd have to go with the cabin group

Sign in to comment in this discussion.