Rate EP3 out of 10 (NO SPOILERS PLEASE)

edited May 2014 in The Walking Dead
Just rate it out of 10 and please don't give any spoilers I play on ps3 EU so yeah no spoilers pls
«134

Comments

  • 10, best episode of Season 2 so far.
  • 10/10 Can't wait for episode 4!
    [HYPE INTENSIFIES]
  • BenPaulBenPaul Banned
    10/10
  • Better than season 1?
    LarenZzai posted: »

    10, best episode of Season 2 so far.

  • No, not better, but at least as good as some episodes of s1.
    ayylmao posted: »

    Better than season 1?

  • I hate how i need to wait another day, this is gonna be tough
  • 9/10 Sarah kinda got on my nerves otherwise it was a fantastic episode. :]
  • No spoilers but don't expect much cuz the epsiode is shorter than Vince story -.- waited 2 months to play in less than 1 hour
    ayylmao posted: »

    I hate how i need to wait another day, this is gonna be tough

  • I can't imagine having to wait another day for the release... O___O You are a brave soul. I don't get it until this afternoon, and I probably won't have time to play it because I have to study for an AP exam tomorrow - but I'll still have it in case I do get the chance... Good luck avoiding spoilers, haha. (I personally have already been spoiled for a TON of stuff posted without spoiler tags... maybe I should stay off the forums.)
    ayylmao posted: »

    I hate how i need to wait another day, this is gonna be tough

  • Really? I was told that it was 1 hour and 20 mins
    Jodie posted: »

    No spoilers but don't expect much cuz the epsiode is shorter than Vince story -.- waited 2 months to play in less than 1 hour

  • Wish me luck :(
    sardines posted: »

    I can't imagine having to wait another day for the release... O___O You are a brave soul. I don't get it until this afternoon, and I probabl

  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator
    It took me 1 hour 30 mins
    ayylmao posted: »

    Really? I was told that it was 1 hour and 20 mins

  • It's like roughly a 90-100 minute episode. It's not shorter than Vince's story...
    Jodie posted: »

    No spoilers but don't expect much cuz the epsiode is shorter than Vince story -.- waited 2 months to play in less than 1 hour

  • 9.5/10

    A few flaws here and there but I ignored them.
  • 10/10, after the episode was finished, i just sat shaking behind my pc
  • edited May 2014
    Whatever it is still short! Why it taking them too much time to make 1 episode no body give a f*** about the other games why don't they stop completing the other series and work on the walking dead after they finish it they can do whatever they want--I know I not their director or anything but seriously we are fans we deserve better
    OzzyUK posted: »

    It took me 1 hour 30 mins

  • 10/10 Excellent episode
  • 9/10..

    Short..short...and short. 1 hour and 40 minutes isnt that long. But it was worth the months wait :D
  • Lets forgot about the 400 days this the shortest episode right?
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    It's like roughly a 90-100 minute episode. It's not shorter than Vince's story...

  • edited May 2014
    9/10

    why?

    cause i expected someone from season 1 ..idk like Molly ! or Lily , and Glenn , ...
  • OzzyUKOzzyUK Moderator
    The length was my main disappointment about the episode, i think the episodes should be longer (2 hours plus would be great) but Telltale seem to think that people don't want a game longer than 90 minuets as they want to finish a episode in one sitting.

    Here is a quite from a staff member "It was decided a few years back that about 90 minutes was our goal for game play length - mostly because we feel like our games are best experienced when played in one sitting."
    Jodie posted: »

    Whatever it is still short! Why it taking them too much time to make 1 episode no body give a f*** about the other games why don't they stop

  • 5, one of the worst episodes I've ever played. By twd standards, that is. In terms of video game standards, still a 10. xD

    It, to me, was short and boring.
  • 11/10, wouldn't wait again
  • 10 out of 10, I cried while playing
  • Then why it still taking them 2 months?
    OzzyUK posted: »

    The length was my main disappointment about the episode, i think the episodes should be longer (2 hours plus would be great) but Telltale se

  • edited May 2014
    10/10
    best episode for me so far
    I expected Carlos didn't die like that ...
  • Hey, it's a non-spoiler thread XD
  • JenniferJennifer Moderator
    Telltale really does code the releases as they go, rather than developing them first and then releasing them, so they can incorporate feedback into the releases. The reason this takes longer to develop than Telltale's games without choices is because of all the branches. All of the branching storylines require code to hook them together. Then you add in the story choices that require different characters to show up based on choice, and you have to hook them together too. It's a very complicated code system that requires more time than something that's not choice based. Coming from the perspective of having written code myself,considering all of the branches in these games (including the story branches), two months is actually a pretty impressive feat.
    Jodie posted: »

    Then why it still taking them 2 months?

  • Ops I Really Forgot... xD
    Crips posted: »

    Hey, it's a non-spoiler thread XD

  • I'm glad no one else came back from season one. That'd just make it cheesy and it'd downgrade the value of having Kenny back.

    9/10 why? cause i expected someone from season 1 ..idk like Molly ! or Lily , and Glenn , ...

  • 9.7/10

    It was amazing, but this one felt really rushed to me :/
  • Best episode for me 9.5/10(I didn't give it a 10 because Reggie died too fast
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I'm glad no one else came back from season one. That'd just make it cheesy and it'd downgrade the value of having Kenny back.

  • 10.000.000.000.000.000.000.000/10 :D
  • Glenn's dead

    9/10 why? cause i expected someone from season 1 ..idk like Molly ! or Lily , and Glenn , ...

  • I knew Reggie was going to die quickly... because it's clearly him in the achievements. Although, I just didn't like Reggie's voice much. I feel like it might be telltale's fault for not giving some direction on what he should sound like... the voice didn't match the character.
  • I felt like Reggie was very under utilized. The only things i remember about him are his story about starbucks and the fact that he died. His voice wasn't bad but it felt a little... out of place. Like in the first Left 4 Dead the survivors didnt sound like real people. They sounded more like voice actors trying to be dramatic or funny. I kinda got that vibe with Reggie.
    _Juice_Box_ posted: »

    I knew Reggie was going to die quickly... because it's clearly him in the achievements. Although, I just didn't like Reggie's voice much. I

  • 7.5/10 I feel like TellTale could have done so much more with this episode, but yeah it's still enjoyable.
  • Definitely 10/10 :) I really enjoyed while playing episode 3. For me season 2 is still at least as good as season 1. For now of course :)
  • 7/10
    Short, Feels rushed. But if you ask me story was perfect and it blows you away. I hope it will get better in the last 2 episodes but it is a well done episode.
  • edited May 2014
    I have a hard time rating this episode, but...

    9/10

    I say I have a hard time because while I enjoyed myself a lot and was engrossed by what was going on, I think so much more could have been done with Carver and his community.

    I also want to lodge a continuing and relentless protest against Telltale's ongoing decision to have no hubs and little freedom. I almost get the feeling Telltale is now embarrassed to admit they ever made anything resembling old-school adventure games. I guess this is just the way its going to be, but whoever decided it should be like this is short-sighted in the extreme.

    If you don't have hubs, at least give us more chances to interact with characters OFF THE RAILS. We care more about characters we know things about, and we get more chances to know more things about characters if we are taken OFF THE RAILS.

    (Gosh, that doesn't read like a 9/10 rating, but I really did like the episode otherwise...)
Sign in to comment in this discussion.