Clem the apple
Duck the cheese n crackers
Larry the cheese n crackers
Lily the jerky
Tried to feed Carly over Lily but she said she was fine what about me and turned it down. Don't see how you people got her to eat.
You have to give Carly apples in order to get her to eat. Same thing with Doug. I know some people have offered Doug the jerky, but I couldn't get him to accept it for some reason. Seems everyone loves the apples
I did not feed the citrus child
I fed Doug, Mark, Lilly, and the Duck-ster.
And i feel good about my decisions.
Viva la Revolution
How can you not like Clementine but like Duck?
Hell throw in Carl for that matter? Both Duck and Carl (in the show, not very far in the comic) have indirectly caused the deaths for two seemingly nice and helpful men, and overall are just basically stupid. Clementine at least shows thoughts and questions her surroundings. The former two are sort of just stupid and annoying.
Anyways I gave Clementine the crackers, then tried to feed Carley the crackers as well, but she refused. So I decided to try and feed Kenny, but said he'd only eat if I fed Duck. So I decided to feed Duck. Afterwords I tried feeding Lilly but she refused, and while I could have persisted, I decided not to. I then went over and fed Larry the jerky, and had one piece of food left over. I can't exactly remember who I fed, but I know it wasn't Katjaa, Lilly, Carley, Mark, Ben, or myself (Lee) so it must of been Kenny, with the apple.
Hell throw in Carl for that matter? Both Duck and Carl (in the show, not very far in the comic) have indirectly caused the deaths for two seemingly nice and helpful men, and overall are just basically stupid. Clementine at least shows thoughts and questions her surroundings. The former two are sort of just stupid and annoying.
Anyways I gave Clementine the crackers, then tried to feed Carley the crackers as well, but she refused. So I decided to try and feed Kenny, but said he'd only eat if I fed Duck. So I decided to feed Duck. Afterwords I tried feeding Lilly but she refused, and while I could have persisted, I decided not to. I then went over and fed Larry the jerky, and had one piece of food left over. I can't exactly remember who I fed, but I know it wasn't Katjaa, Lilly, Carley, Mark, Ben, or myself (Lee) so it must of been Kenny, with the apple.
Carl has one thing going for him, he has a hot mum
Apple to Clementine - pretty obvious choice for me - after everything Lee and Clem have been through, he's not going to let her down.
Crackers to Duck - I'm still a softie agreeing with Kenny's prioritisation of the kids - also, kids first is an easier sell politically than Clem first, as it looks less like blatant favouritism and the group really doesn't need a three-way split with every "family" for itself.
Crackers to Mark - he's hunting and doing physical labour, and seems to be coping worse with the hunger than the other adults.
I wanted to give Katja some food for the wounded man on the basis that he'd need his strength to recover, but the game wouldn't let me. Would have been a cool "softness bites you" moment if it did, then everyone yelled at you for wasting the food when he dies - in retrospect I could have got the same effect by feeding Ben.
Jerky to Larry - I agonised over this for a while. He's a big guy, and seems to be handling the hunger better than most, but he's the most likely to cause trouble if things don't go his way - plus Carley was dropping pretty heavy hints that Lilly wanted him fed. In the end I decided the cost of pissing Larry off was more than the cost of denying someone else a strip of jerky. If I hadn't given the food to Larry, Kenny or Lee would have been my next choice, as the other hunters and the best chance of getting more, and that would have really deepened the Lilly/Kenny rift.
Clem the apple, because she's my daughter, and matters more then any of them, then jerky to duck because well he's a kid -_-* an annoying kid.... next I tried to give Carly the crackers but she was like nah, and so i asked her about who i should give the rest of the rations too, so I gave Larry the crackers because he's grumpy and his heart condition and it would make nice with Lilly, he's just looking out for his daughter which i can empathize because of Clem, so then I gave Lilly the last crackers because she's a tough woman with some military experience meaning survival & firearms training, and one of the (pseudo leaders) of the group. I didn't give Kenny anything because he's being a prick and not trustworthy to watch your back which you got a taste of back at the greene's farm "R.I.P Shawn" and I didn't give Katja anything because she's fat so she can last longer without food.
I actually gave food first to Mark, being that at the time I had no idea who he was, whether I could trust him, and that he mentioned he was hungry plenty more times than the others, so I was worried he could get too hungry and go partially insane hurting the group. I over thought that lots. Next I gave food to Carly. I wanted to make sure she stays alive since she is good with a gun, (Which is the whole reason why I saved her over Doug) but she refused. After I tried sharing with Kenny to ease some tension, but he told me to feed his boy. So I went to feeding Duck and Clem after a long decision. Finally leading me to offering food to Lily even though I don't totally like her either, (I figured if she rationed food, she must have been starving herself), she took it and still showed no sympathy towards me, but I'm glad I did for I side with her now, Kenny's selfish.
I gave the first piece of food to Clemetine, which I think was obvious. When you started talking to her, she told you that she is very hungry. The second piece was given to Duck and since Carley didn't want to take it, I gave the last two pieces to Larry and Lilly. I thought Larry might change his behaviour towards Lee.
I gave Clem the first ration. Gave the next to Duck because Kenny refused to eat first...Third to Kenny. Last was to Ben, I think. I specifically avoided Larry out of sheer dislike and Lilly because she pissed me off by leaving me with this job.
I should note that afterward, Doug gave me a look. I facepalmed immediately. "OH SHIT, I FORGOT YOU WERE HERE!"
XD My bad, Doug.
Clem got an apple. Cheese and crackers for Duck and Ben. Kenny got the jerky.
I gave an apple to Clementine, cheese and crackers to Duck, Bacon to Kenny and then I tried to give Carley the second cheese and crackers, but she told to hold on it in case me or Clem get hungry. I wanted to do that, but I had already chosen to give it to someone else cause I didn't want to seem selfish to others. So, I decided to give it to Mark since he seemed like a guy I can trust.
Wow, old thread from July but I'll play along. I fed Clem (apple) and Duck first. Then I offered Carley some, but she insisted I hold on to it for Clem or myself. So I gave the remaining to Lilly (to not piss her off) and Mark (who was working on the fence). I don't like Larry, and felt feeding her daughter was good enough. And I suspected, like Mark, that Larry was getting enough food somehow. Kenny and Katjaa seemed to be doing nothing at the moment, so no food for them.
Tried to give Katjaa an apple, figured our team doc needed to keep her strength up, also she might give it to Duck. Was too busy with the soon to be dead guy to accept it.
Gave Mark the apple. Between missing his shot and saying he's having trouble holding a board straight, figured the poor guy really needed something and seeing as he's one of the people hunting for food it's a good idea to keep him feed.
Skipped Larry. As my dad use to say "If you're well enough to complain you're well enough." and Larry seemed plenty well to me. Opted to give Lilly the jerky though, in case she wanted to feed her dad. Told me she didn't need it, I told her take it anyways.
Then gave the crackers and cheese to Clem and Duck. If we can't afford to feed two children then we're probably not going to be "survivors" for much longer.
Skipped Kenny because I figured he'd be satisfied if Duck ate (he was), skipped Carley because I figured she knew me not picking her was in no way a slight against her (she did), and skipped Ben because I wasn't sure if he'd be staying or not at the time. Larry still complained though, but that's nothing new.
Is there any reason the apple is so popular? Both Clem and Duck have different dialogue if you give it to them and Doug and Carley will accept nothing else. I figured the jerky would have been more in demand.
- Clementine(Apple). She takes priority and gets the best food always(maybe i was playing favorites).
- Duck(Crackers&Cheese). Mostly to become better friends with Kenny.
- Kenny(Jerky). See above.
- Larry(Crackers&Cheese). Just trying to make peace with the old man.
Tried to feed Carley but she only accepts the apple, and i already gave it to Clementine. I refused to feed Mark because at the time i was extremely angry that he was placed in the group without an introduction and wanted nothing to do with him.
Clem- Crackers and Cheese.
Duck- Jerky
Because kids always eat first.
Kenny- Crackers and Cheese
He was a real bro, and never yelled at me like Larry and Lilly did.
Ben- Apple
I agonized over the final piece of food for a good while. I finally decided that since we didn't know Ben, and everyone else wouldn't accept food (I tried to feed Carley, but didn't pick the apple, so I gave up on her. Also, Mark telling Larry what I thought of him really didn't help his case) or hated me, I decided to extend an olive branch to the new arrival.
Wow, looking back on it, I managed to feed all three people who can survive until Episode 5.
I fed the kids because I have a soft spot for them.
I gave clementine the crackers and duck the jerky.
I think I then gave one to kenny and one to mark, I didn't like larry so I gave him none.
Gave Mark the apple because he mentioned that he was feeling weak already.
Gave Lilly the jerky because she needed it to be alert on watch.
Gave crackers and cheese to Larry so he could get the fuck off my back.
Gave crackers and cheese to Ben as a sort of welcome into the group.
In first time:
Gave to Clementine - of course she's meaning of Lee's life. ( crackers)
Gave to Duck - He's child ( jerk)
Gave to Ben - really don't know why ( apple)
Left food to myself - because I thought that it matter. ( crackers)
P.S. I think that giving half-apple to Clem - it's wrong deside. It doesn't matter that she love apples. Half-apple is really little, apples are low-calorie. Apples may not satisfy hunger.
I fed Clem, Duck, Kenny, and Lilly on my first playthrough. I tried feeding Carley but I didn't know she only accepted the slice of apple (which I gave to Clem).
On my most recent playthrough I fed Clem, Duck, Carley, and Kenny. Lilly accused me of choosing favorites and I about blew up in a rage of fit, LOL.
In all of my other playthroughs, I gave food to Mark, Clementine, Duck and Ben.
But in my most recent one;
Apple : I gave the apple to Clementine, because with how I played Lee, he would never let the kids starve -- they would be his first priority. Adults are stronger and more developed, and would be able to last longer without food than children.
Cheese & Crackers : I gave the first Cheese & Crackers to Duck, for the same reason as above and also because Kenny wouldn't eat if I didn't give food to Duck first.
Cheese & Crackers : I gave the second Cheese & Crackers to Lily, who had to be alert on watch. And the way I saw it, she was one of the "leading adults", so she had to keep her strength up.
Jerky : I gave the Jerky to Kenny, because like Lily, I saw him as one of the "leading adults" and someone who had to keep his strength up to help out.
I felt horrible about not feeding Mark, Ben and Larry, though. It was a difficult choice. And no, I didn't like Larry that much, but Mark was complaining that he was grumpy (I think this was only if you told Mark that 'he's just looking out for his daughter' when he asked what Larry's problem with Lee was) and once he told Larry that, Larry sighed and said, "Ah, I just need something to eat. Going days without food would make anyone cranky" and then turns and offers to help Mark with the wall. That was the first glimpse I got of Larry's "human" side, and I thought it was really sweet of him (considering what he's normally like).
Comments
Duck the cheese n crackers
Larry the cheese n crackers
Lily the jerky
Tried to feed Carly over Lily but she said she was fine what about me and turned it down. Don't see how you people got her to eat.
OfferApple>pharmSurvivor=Accept
How can you not like Clementine but like Duck?
Hell throw in Carl for that matter? Both Duck and Carl (in the show, not very far in the comic) have indirectly caused the deaths for two seemingly nice and helpful men, and overall are just basically stupid. Clementine at least shows thoughts and questions her surroundings. The former two are sort of just stupid and annoying.
Anyways I gave Clementine the crackers, then tried to feed Carley the crackers as well, but she refused. So I decided to try and feed Kenny, but said he'd only eat if I fed Duck. So I decided to feed Duck. Afterwords I tried feeding Lilly but she refused, and while I could have persisted, I decided not to. I then went over and fed Larry the jerky, and had one piece of food left over. I can't exactly remember who I fed, but I know it wasn't Katjaa, Lilly, Carley, Mark, Ben, or myself (Lee) so it must of been Kenny, with the apple.
Carl has one thing going for him, he has a hot mum
Apple to Clementine - pretty obvious choice for me - after everything Lee and Clem have been through, he's not going to let her down.
Crackers to Duck - I'm still a softie agreeing with Kenny's prioritisation of the kids - also, kids first is an easier sell politically than Clem first, as it looks less like blatant favouritism and the group really doesn't need a three-way split with every "family" for itself.
Crackers to Mark - he's hunting and doing physical labour, and seems to be coping worse with the hunger than the other adults.
I wanted to give Katja some food for the wounded man on the basis that he'd need his strength to recover, but the game wouldn't let me. Would have been a cool "softness bites you" moment if it did, then everyone yelled at you for wasting the food when he dies - in retrospect I could have got the same effect by feeding Ben.
Jerky to Larry - I agonised over this for a while. He's a big guy, and seems to be handling the hunger better than most, but he's the most likely to cause trouble if things don't go his way - plus Carley was dropping pretty heavy hints that Lilly wanted him fed. In the end I decided the cost of pissing Larry off was more than the cost of denying someone else a strip of jerky. If I hadn't given the food to Larry, Kenny or Lee would have been my next choice, as the other hunters and the best chance of getting more, and that would have really deepened the Lilly/Kenny rift.
Or chewy food for the talker to keep his mouth busy.
Gave Carley an apple, she seems like someone I want on my side.
Gave the other C&C to Duck and the jerky to the jerk (Larry) in an attempt to keep the peace between Kenny and Lilly.
Duck Cheese and crackers
Mark Jerky i think
and Larry cheese and crackers
i just can't do it to her...
I should note that afterward, Doug gave me a look. I facepalmed immediately. "OH SHIT, I FORGOT YOU WERE HERE!"
XD My bad, Doug.
Clem got an apple. Cheese and crackers for Duck and Ben. Kenny got the jerky.
Kenny because then he'd give us a ride on his van.
I tried giving food to Carley but she insisted others needed more.
Clem and Duck - because kids ALWAYS come first.
Then Carley - because... well... Carley.
Then Lilly... just to spite Larry and because I felt sorry for her at the time.
Gave Mark the apple. Between missing his shot and saying he's having trouble holding a board straight, figured the poor guy really needed something and seeing as he's one of the people hunting for food it's a good idea to keep him feed.
Skipped Larry. As my dad use to say "If you're well enough to complain you're well enough." and Larry seemed plenty well to me. Opted to give Lilly the jerky though, in case she wanted to feed her dad. Told me she didn't need it, I told her take it anyways.
Then gave the crackers and cheese to Clem and Duck. If we can't afford to feed two children then we're probably not going to be "survivors" for much longer.
Skipped Kenny because I figured he'd be satisfied if Duck ate (he was), skipped Carley because I figured she knew me not picking her was in no way a slight against her (she did), and skipped Ben because I wasn't sure if he'd be staying or not at the time. Larry still complained though, but that's nothing new.
Is there any reason the apple is so popular? Both Clem and Duck have different dialogue if you give it to them and Doug and Carley will accept nothing else. I figured the jerky would have been more in demand.
One of the cheese and crackers went to Duck.
One of the cheese and crackers was offered to Carley, but she refused.
The jerky was given to Mark.
And the cheese and crackers that Carley refused went to Larry.
Clementine
Duck
Kenny
Ben
Clem- Apple
Kenny- jerky (attempted)
Doug- Jerky (attempted)
Duck- Crackers & Cheese
Kenny- Jerky (success)
Katjaa- Crackers & Cheese (attempted)
Larry- Crackers & Cheese
Almost gave the last food to Mark, but I wanted to try to befriend Larry and thought Mark would understand.
- Duck(Crackers&Cheese). Mostly to become better friends with Kenny.
- Kenny(Jerky). See above.
- Larry(Crackers&Cheese). Just trying to make peace with the old man.
Tried to feed Carley but she only accepts the apple, and i already gave it to Clementine. I refused to feed Mark because at the time i was extremely angry that he was placed in the group without an introduction and wanted nothing to do with him.
Duck- Jerky
Because kids always eat first.
Kenny- Crackers and Cheese
He was a real bro, and never yelled at me like Larry and Lilly did.
Ben- Apple
I agonized over the final piece of food for a good while. I finally decided that since we didn't know Ben, and everyone else wouldn't accept food (I tried to feed Carley, but didn't pick the apple, so I gave up on her. Also, Mark telling Larry what I thought of him really didn't help his case) or hated me, I decided to extend an olive branch to the new arrival.
Wow, looking back on it, I managed to feed all three people who can survive until Episode 5.
Clementine: An Apple
Duck: Cheese and Crackers
Kenny: Jerky
Lilly: My last piece of food.
I gave clementine the crackers and duck the jerky.
I think I then gave one to kenny and one to mark, I didn't like larry so I gave him none.
Tried to feed Doug but he declined..
Gave Lilly the jerky because she needed it to be alert on watch.
Gave crackers and cheese to Larry so he could get the fuck off my back.
Gave crackers and cheese to Ben as a sort of welcome into the group.
Yeah... sorry, Clemmy.
Gave to Clementine - of course she's meaning of Lee's life. ( crackers)
Gave to Duck - He's child ( jerk)
Gave to Ben - really don't know why ( apple)
Left food to myself - because I thought that it matter. ( crackers)
P.S. I think that giving half-apple to Clem - it's wrong deside. It doesn't matter that she love apples. Half-apple is really little, apples are low-calorie. Apples may not satisfy hunger.
On my most recent playthrough I fed Clem, Duck, Carley, and Kenny. Lilly accused me of choosing favorites and I about blew up in a rage of fit, LOL.
In all of my other playthroughs, I gave food to Mark, Clementine, Duck and Ben.
But in my most recent one;
Apple : I gave the apple to Clementine, because with how I played Lee, he would never let the kids starve -- they would be his first priority. Adults are stronger and more developed, and would be able to last longer without food than children.
Cheese & Crackers : I gave the first Cheese & Crackers to Duck, for the same reason as above and also because Kenny wouldn't eat if I didn't give food to Duck first.
Cheese & Crackers : I gave the second Cheese & Crackers to Lily, who had to be alert on watch. And the way I saw it, she was one of the "leading adults", so she had to keep her strength up.
Jerky : I gave the Jerky to Kenny, because like Lily, I saw him as one of the "leading adults" and someone who had to keep his strength up to help out.
I felt horrible about not feeding Mark, Ben and Larry, though. It was a difficult choice. And no, I didn't like Larry that much, but Mark was complaining that he was grumpy (I think this was only if you told Mark that 'he's just looking out for his daughter' when he asked what Larry's problem with Lee was) and once he told Larry that, Larry sighed and said, "Ah, I just need something to eat. Going days without food would make anyone cranky" and then turns and offers to help Mark with the wall. That was the first glimpse I got of Larry's "human" side, and I thought it was really sweet of him (considering what he's normally like).
Clementine - apple,
Duck - crackers and cheese,
Mark - crackers and cheese,
Myself (wanted to share it with Clem later) - jerky
OR
Clem - apple,
Duck - crackers and cheese,
Larry - jerky,
Lilly - crackers and cheese
Don't know which food i gave but i gave Duck and Clem then Mark and then Ben.