I don't get why people saved Carly
I never got the reason why people saved Carly over Doug, I mean for ffs Carly put the batteries in the wrong way and she didn't even know how to work a radio.
She was a good shooter but Doug was smarter than her imo.
She was a good shooter but Doug was smarter than her imo.
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
You make a joke about the battery thing at the end of episode 2.
[/Spoilers]
I picked her because, even though she knows about me, she's on my side about it, and she's trustworthy. She's loyal and, especially after this episode, she's a good friend.
I intended to save Carly, but I moused over her and got no option, I did with Doug, so I saved him.. It wasnt till later I realized I needed to click her purse.
But, with that being done, I was glad it worked out that way because she knew of Lee's past, and so did Larry, but after EP2 was over, they're both dead. I have no Idea if they both lived and knew of Lee's past if it would make much difference, but at leaste it's not a concern now!
Yes, but Doug has been able to set up a trap for zombies for me now out of pure garbage. Not wasting any ammo like Carly would this way either
I guess she didn't like him that much after all.
Right, because we're making decisions from hindsight rather than from what Lee knows and can see at the time, in the time frame given.
There were holes in the wall and she's shown to be a crackshot.
You could argue the other way around and ask why Carly didn't just pistol whip the one that grabbed her. Of course, how the hell did Doug get grabbed in the first place? What was he doing, reinforcing the 2x4s with his body?
I explored both options and still saved Carly for the exact logic I stated above. Neither choice is a "screw up."
There are holes in the wall and when I'm pretending to be Lee, making a decision, I figured Carly could make the shot.
I also figured there was a greater chance Doug could pull away (and less likely chance the 2x4s would break) than Carly having enough brains to use the butt of her gun (and a greater and more imminent danger of her getting bit on the ankle.)
I didn't "weigh" their lives based on who they were, what gender they were, what the knew or what they could contribute. They were human beings and I reasoned a decision that I thought had the best chance of saving both of them.
I agree, why not just snatch up this beautiful girl/ future leader/ savior of mankind and just go somewhere with her, that way you can 100% make sure she is always safe instead of going of to save people I could give two shits about.
Or is that just me...
He was mocking Rick in the Tank over Queen Clems Walkie Talkie
I tried to do for people based on their usefulness as a whole, take for example Duck, he is a child, and isn't really going to be much help as far as anything goes, I was willing to let him die over Shawn, and was willing to let him get thrown out when it was thought he had been bitten. I realize it probably sounds cold, but you have to put things into perspective, yes this person may be a child, or tech savvy, or whatever, but how is that going to be useful to you and the rest of the group as a whole in the future.
This. She's pretty, had my back so far, and gained my trust by accepting and keeping Lee's secret.
And Lee even teased her about the battery thing, which I thought was one of the funnier moments of that pretty grim episode.
Choice 1: I lose ammo like there's no tomorrow. [Carly]
Choice 2: I gain an early warning system. [Doug]
That's a hard choice.
I saved Doug originally because I had a feeling he'd be jury-rigging all sorts of crap, as is the wont of very technically minded sorts. So I just had a hunch that he'd turn out okay.
On the other hand, Carly just isn't very bright. She goes blabbing about Lee's past right away and at an awkward time instead of keeping her peace for a better time, she wastes ammo like there's no tomorrow whilst claiming to be a crack-shot maverick, and she can't handle putting batteries into a radio.
I mean, the intelligent woman on the team is Lilly, and I'll be sure to keep her alive and well. But Carly? Yeahno. I'll take Doug, every time.
Besides, Lilly and Kenny are both plenty good with guns. So having a third is a pointless, ammo-wasting redundancy.
Also, interesting that physical attraction factors into whom should survive, there! That might not be in your best interests at the end of the day. >_>
Carly: A person who exists to be sexually objectified and saved only for that reason! Because golly gee we're straight and we want to bang her.
So depressing.
See, this makes my decision regarding Doug even more concrete. :P