Geez too many people argumenting here :P still,thanks for the support.
If TTG dosen't like the videos i will take them down.
I will never have the time to make whole episodes, so it won't in anyway spoil the gaming experience.
I'm just about done adding annotations to the Lee vs Keny scene and that single scene is over 20min with all the outcome.
So if you don't like the idea/videos just... Don't watch them
And Cyreen, when I was saying you had no credibility because you're a Canadian and not a lawyer...
By in passing, I meant non-specific. Did I say I was a lawyer? For all you know, I'm packing a gun. The legal profession offers of wide selection of careers, but then you're good a making assumptions and running off at the mouth, aren't you? I don't require credibility to make that judgment.
My lack of intelligence makes it hard for me to understand
Obviously, you mental midget. Fortuitously means "by accident", while "in passing" means in the course of doing something else. Maybe you should go look up "vicariously" again while you're at it.
Obviously, you mental midget. Fortuitously means "by accident", while "in passing" means in the in the course of doing something else. Maybe you should go look up "vicariously" again while you're at it.
Not worth contemplating, I don't do ugly and he is so eager to censor everyone else, yet he's the one that got banned.
Cyreen, how you flirt with me so publicly is making me embarrassed
it's funny since i've not been here as much, (amazing i know !) red panda takes it upon himself to take over the forums and effectivley become a mini mod which is ironic cos he complained a fair bit about me doing it before ep3 came out..
and you till haven't learned how to edit posts to avoid double posting, you see it is such a simple thing to do you copy the second post and you paste it in the previous post you then delete the second.....(irony)
so to say you are giving your opinion, but when people make it moot you start with borderline insults ?
He's a chef, not a marketer hired by TTG. It's not an advertisement.
None of you are lawyers and some of you aren't even Americans. How do you know the law? Simple: you don't. You probably aren't even familiar with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.
Yet, you still have an opinion. Guess what? It's worthless. It means nothing, especially in a court of law.
The only way he doesn't get in trouble is if TTG lets it go. It's probably not worth suing over b/c he is probably broke but they might have it taken down. I can see that.
Anyway, keep giving your worthless non-legal opinion. If he listens then it's his own fault for listening to people no smarter than he when it comes to copyright law and deserves what he gets.
But he got the PERMISSION from telltale, so what the heck is your problem??
And where I live this would go under fair usage and thus is not illegal by law. The EULA does not legally mean shit in most countries with exception of USA.
I think telltale is smart enough to see it more as free advertisment than piracy. If it was not for let's plays, i would never have discovered telltale and their games.
Also there is absolutely no way he can implement the actual gameplay mechanics over youtube.
hmmm if he doesn't gain money from the clips TTG wont bother with any legal action. lawyers cost a lot and if there is no money to be gained they wont even bother. it could be considered violation of copy right laws and a jury would determine if it was indeed a crime. that's asumeing there isn't already a case law on this subject already. i haven't bothered to find out if there is a case law about it yet but i can if i ever get time. most likely however it probably is illegal but its probably one of those one people ignore like jay walking and what not. if its not an issue it will be ignored.
They don't have to hire lawyers. They just have to contact Youtube and say he's infringing on their copyright. They take the video down and it's on him to make the argument that he's not.
Google has been sued so much over copyright material that they always play it safe. A lawyer is going to go after the biggest pay day, which is Google. Why sue some broke user? They sue Google for hosting the material b/c Google is worth billions of dollars. That's a nice payday.
So Google, not likeing being sued, takes things down quick and it's not easy to make the case that it's no infringment. They tons of money if they're wrong so they don't play around when it comes to claims of copyright infringement.
Stop the hostility, the off topic and the legal discussion, we've had enough of it. Seriously, we've had ENOUGH.
Telltale has never ever objected to Let's Plays. Mark (Darin) and Jake (Rodkin) have repeatedly encouraged and fostered Let's Plays and fan art of any kind. There is of course a legal vulnerability in what Warning_3 does - as with all recording of game material - but Telltale has always deeply understood how the fans' efforts in creating this helps support their franchises. warning_3 just brings half an inch of the (comparatively vast) interactivity of TWD into his videos. I bet my fucking modship that he will never ever get into trouble for this. That's easy for me to say because I (a) know that it's the case and (b) should Telltale ever change this central policy of theirs, I probably just would not want to spend my free time on this forum to help any more.
p.s. I might kill off some of the off topic posts here. They just serve to ruin the original thread, and I find that communicative strategy disgusting. I might also choose to merge this thread into the already existing "Let's play" sticky though, but we'll see.
We are not opposed to you making fan videos, as long as you are not making them for profit. However, we do ask that you impose reasonable limits on the level of interactivity in your videos and the overall amount of content used. If the videos too closely resemble actual gameplay, that would violate our Terms of Use.
Actually, a good one to do with be all the way back in the first episode when you have the choice to leave Clem's house in daylight or at night. I doubt most people have played it both ways.
Maybe the dinner scene with the St. John's? It's one of the few scenes where shit happens to fast to really think about what to say. I always enjoy the "It's.... people!" line, cracks me up every time lol.
Comments
It's funny because he's a chef... Oh wat, that's the joke.
Thank you. You're far too kind.
If TTG dosen't like the videos i will take them down.
I will never have the time to make whole episodes, so it won't in anyway spoil the gaming experience.
I'm just about done adding annotations to the Lee vs Keny scene and that single scene is over 20min with all the outcome.
So if you don't like the idea/videos just... Don't watch them
Thanks
By in passing, I meant non-specific. Did I say I was a lawyer? For all you know, I'm packing a gun. The legal profession offers of wide selection of careers, but then you're good a making assumptions and running off at the mouth, aren't you? I don't require credibility to make that judgment.
Obviously, you mental midget. Fortuitously means "by accident", while "in passing" means in the course of doing something else. Maybe you should go look up "vicariously" again while you're at it.
Not worth contemplating, I don't do ugly and he is so eager to censor everyone else, yet he's the one that got banned.
Cyreen, how you flirt with me so publicly is making me embarrassed
Youtube link
Any suggestions of future interactive videos?
PS. could a mod edit the title of the topic to 'Interactive Walking dead scenes [new video up]'?
it's funny since i've not been here as much, (amazing i know !) red panda takes it upon himself to take over the forums and effectivley become a mini mod which is ironic cos he complained a fair bit about me doing it before ep3 came out..
and you till haven't learned how to edit posts to avoid double posting, you see it is such a simple thing to do you copy the second post and you paste it in the previous post you then delete the second.....(irony)
so to say you are giving your opinion, but when people make it moot you start with borderline insults ?
'slow hand clap'
You must have been drinking... too much as well.
Don't let this be you. Knock it off.
And where I live this would go under fair usage and thus is not illegal by law. The EULA does not legally mean shit in most countries with exception of USA.
I think telltale is smart enough to see it more as free advertisment than piracy. If it was not for let's plays, i would never have discovered telltale and their games.
Also there is absolutely no way he can implement the actual gameplay mechanics over youtube.
I imagine it must've taken a long time for the editing...thanks for this, Warning!
Still don't care
Telltale has never ever objected to Let's Plays. Mark (Darin) and Jake (Rodkin) have repeatedly encouraged and fostered Let's Plays and fan art of any kind. There is of course a legal vulnerability in what Warning_3 does - as with all recording of game material - but Telltale has always deeply understood how the fans' efforts in creating this helps support their franchises. warning_3 just brings half an inch of the (comparatively vast) interactivity of TWD into his videos. I bet my fucking modship that he will never ever get into trouble for this. That's easy for me to say because I (a) know that it's the case and (b) should Telltale ever change this central policy of theirs, I probably just would not want to spend my free time on this forum to help any more.
@all: Here's a SDCC 2012 panel about fan art/ legal implications. I think it's quite interesting - and applicable here.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKBsTUjd910
p.s. I might kill off some of the off topic posts here. They just serve to ruin the original thread, and I find that communicative strategy disgusting. I might also choose to merge this thread into the already existing "Let's play" sticky though, but we'll see.
- The st. john dinner table
- Talking to people in the drug store or the barricade
- The meat locker
Those are the ones that stand out most to me
I've been thinking about the dinner table to
This has been covered by the devs and mods....Please move on.
I don't feel like playing for however long to see 2 seconds of speech. There is no skip feature that I'm aware of in the game so....
Click here to watch it!