I once tried a nothing but Lilly playthrough, felt like shit for siding with the she devil. Anyway I walked away hating her even more, as she still stabbed me in the back with the your a murderer and then stole the RV, but she never once treated me like a friend, more like a servant or a loyal soldier, unlike Kenny where he treats you like his brother and sticks with you to the end.
I like both characters way more if I side with them both a bit during the story; siding with Kenny in ep 1 and Lilly in ep 2 lets you see both sides of either character.
I actually really liked Lilly at the end of ep 2.
She seems much more tragic in ep 3 if you tried to save Larry and more likeable. The moment on the side of the road makes it appear much more like she snaps in the doug version.
Not that I forgive her for doing what she did though... I mean I don't want to kill her but completely forgiving would be kind of weird.
I don't quite know why everyone who tried to save Larry is randomly forgiving Kenny and wanting him to have survived. I still haven't forgiven him for leaving me to die numerous times while sane... forgetting that I had saved his kid and sided with him tons just because I didn't smash someone s head in. :mad:
I like both characters way more if I side with them both a bit during the story; siding with Kenny in ep 1 and Lilly in ep 2 lets you see both sides of either character.
I actually really liked Lilly at the end of ep 2.
She seems much more tragic in ep 3 if you tried to save Larry and more likeable. The moment on the side of the road makes it appear much more like she snaps in the doug version.
Not that I forgive her for doing what she did though... I mean I don't want to kill her but completely forgiving would be kind of weird.
I don't quite know why everyone who tried to save Larry is randomly forgiving Kenny and wanting him to have survived. I still haven't forgiven him for leaving me to die numerous times while sane... forgetting that I had saved his kid and sided with him tons just because I didn't smash someone s head in. :mad:
Well you could say the same thing about Lilly because some people forgive and want her to survive even if she did kill Doug/Carley oh and lets not forget that she takes the Rv and leaves you no matter what .
I like both characters way more if I side with them both a bit during the story; siding with Kenny in ep 1 and Lilly in ep 2 lets you see both sides of either character.
I actually really liked Lilly at the end of ep 2.
She seems much more tragic in ep 3 if you tried to save Larry and more likeable. The moment on the side of the road makes it appear much more like she snaps in the doug version.
Not that I forgive her for doing what she did though... I mean I don't want to kill her but completely forgiving would be kind of weird.
I don't quite know why everyone who tried to save Larry is randomly forgiving Kenny and wanting him to have survived. I still haven't forgiven him for leaving me to die numerous times while sane... forgetting that I had saved his kid and sided with him tons just because I didn't smash someone s head in. :mad:
Lilly was a great character. I tried to save Larry in episode 2, and was completely pro-Lilly from that point on until Carley's death. It's interesting to see how much she vouches for you if you're on her side. She's a lot more easier to please then Kenny, who has a general consensus of "you disagreed with me? Fuck you."
Oh, and as soon as Duck and Katjaa died, I tried to be on Kenny's side as much as I could. I noticed he left me for dead even if I was completely pro-Kenny before the meat locker, but he still came with me at the end of episode four. He's my third favorite character after Lee and Clem.
For the record, I don't want either of them to return in season 2. To me, Kenny died a heroic death, which is what his character deserved. I feel Lilly's character arc ended in the comics.
I'd prefer that she doesn't appear in season 2 unless she gets some sort of redemption for her past actions. Lee redeems himself for murdering someone, and Kenny "redeems" himself for being a complete asshat the entire game. Seeing as Lee, Kenny, and Lilly were the main trio of sorts for the first 3 episodes, it's only fair that Lilly gets the same closure. Otherwise, just leave her fate a mystery.
Carley/Ben/Kenny is the reason why she snapped so I blame them for all the hell that they went through.
Blaming Ben and Kenny is one thing but Carley never did anything wrong and Lilly pretty much started the argument by accusing her as a traitor without proof .
Blaming Ben and Kenny is one thing but Carley never did anything wrong and Lilly pretty much started the argument by accusing her as a traitor without proof .
Carley went off on Lilly causing her death. Paranoia + argument=R.I.P And the proof is lack of supplies.
And killing random people with no proof isn't helping anybody .
Lack of supplies is proof and isn't it a coincidence all goes to shit once Ben shows up I wanted to leave all three of them in the woods but I had to take them.
HOW MANY TIMES MUST I SAY THIS, saying if Carley said nothing would still have gotten her killed, if Ben did almost nothing and almost got shot, then Carley would have died ether way, GET IT IN YOUR HEAD!!!
HOW MANY TIMES MUST I SAY THIS, saying if Carley said nothing would still have gotten her killed, if Ben did almost nothing and almost got shot, then Carley would have died ether way, GET IT IN YOUR HEAD!!!
That's the thing we will never know. We can only assume.
I know for a fact that what would have happened, and if she did not kill Carley then someone else was going to die, someone was not going to be walking away from it.
Comments
I actually really liked Lilly at the end of ep 2.
She seems much more tragic in ep 3 if you tried to save Larry and more likeable. The moment on the side of the road makes it appear much more like she snaps in the doug version.
Not that I forgive her for doing what she did though... I mean I don't want to kill her but completely forgiving would be kind of weird.
I don't quite know why everyone who tried to save Larry is randomly forgiving Kenny and wanting him to have survived. I still haven't forgiven him for leaving me to die numerous times while sane... forgetting that I had saved his kid and sided with him tons just because I didn't smash someone s head in. :mad:
Well you could say the same thing about Lilly because some people forgive and want her to survive even if she did kill Doug/Carley oh and lets not forget that she takes the Rv and leaves you no matter what .
Lilly was a great character. I tried to save Larry in episode 2, and was completely pro-Lilly from that point on until Carley's death. It's interesting to see how much she vouches for you if you're on her side. She's a lot more easier to please then Kenny, who has a general consensus of "you disagreed with me? Fuck you."
Oh, and as soon as Duck and Katjaa died, I tried to be on Kenny's side as much as I could. I noticed he left me for dead even if I was completely pro-Kenny before the meat locker, but he still came with me at the end of episode four. He's my third favorite character after Lee and Clem.
For the record, I don't want either of them to return in season 2. To me, Kenny died a heroic death, which is what his character deserved. I feel Lilly's character arc ended in the comics.
of Course, her Snapping wasn't helping things out. And after the events in the meat locker she's probaly not anywhere near as (decent) that she was.
Blaming Ben and Kenny is one thing but Carley never did anything wrong and Lilly pretty much started the argument by accusing her as a traitor without proof .
Carley went off on Lilly causing her death. Paranoia + argument=R.I.P And the proof is lack of supplies.
Wait, I'm Defending Lily?
Lilly wasn't going to calm down and she wasn't going to listen to Lee nor Carley .
Because like she said "taking supplies is like sneaking into your room and cutting your throat."
-Lilly
Yup. Remember Doug? I certainly do.
And killing random people with no proof isn't helping anybody .
Lack of supplies is proof and isn't it a coincidence all goes to shit once Ben shows up I wanted to leave all three of them in the woods but I had to take them.
That's the thing we will never know. We can only assume.
If you save Doug , Ben doesn't insult Lilly like Carley and after Kenny kills the walkers , she aims at Ben but Doug saves him .
Did they kill Larry ? NO . They were innocent and they deserved better than to be shot by a crazy woman .
Wasn't Doug's fault for sure. If anyone in Doug's death, it was Ben's.
By they I mean Doug and Carley .
Ehkay , you're about to start a Doug and Carley Vs Lilly war thread and it won't be a pretty one .
Doug Pulled Ben away from the Gun. Which Followed Ben and fired at the wrong time.
Okay how about this
Tip: Do not argue with a pissed off paranoid girl with a loaded gun.
GAARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR ! IT'S LIKE I AM TALKING TO A BRICK WALL ! :mad::mad::mad::mad::mad::mad::mad:
I didn't but it was a necessary sacrifice.
You wouldn't be pissed if someone was accusing you of stealing supplies?
Master psychic, calm down bro, don't let him get the better of you man.
it was necessary to kill ... Doug ... Carley ... Gaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa !