Lilly in Season 2?

1235

Comments

  • edited August 2013
    Who said you have to join Lilly?

    I was making a Star Wars reference .
  • edited August 2013
    Okay, I am just going to vent this insanity by typing on my Fan Fic, okay this is a bit out of hand and in no way shape or form do I ever want to be banned, I am not giving up, I am just ramping down.
  • edited August 2013
    btw, is anyone else actually enjoying this?
  • edited August 2013
    Enjoying this, can I ask how can you enjoy this at all?
  • edited August 2013
    btw, is anyone else actually enjoying this?

    Yes, a nice way to pass time. And surprisingly entertaining :).
  • edited August 2013
    I'm new on this forum,so I don't ehkay's past, but I don't think he is that bad. He just has a really... strange opinion.
  • edited August 2013
    btw, is anyone else actually enjoying this?

    It is pretty funny. I'm just not phased.
  • edited August 2013
    How about we all just SHUT UP and enjoy our own opinions? This is getting ridiculous.

    I would enjoy Ehkay's opinion if he din't start a Doug and Carley vs Lilly war after he said that they deserved to get shot .
  • edited August 2013
    Can I ask did he every once post a comment that did not create a post war?
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    Yes, a nice way to pass time. And surprisingly entertaining :).

    So you wanna go out for beer sometime then?
  • edited August 2013
    Yeah I know, it's imaginary beer.
  • edited August 2013
    I'll pay for the beer, I need one most likely right now, and if it makes anyone better the next chapter on my Fan Fic is about to be uploaded, and it has Nate.
  • edited August 2013
    Yeah that makes me feel better.
  • edited August 2013
    I always have a beer handy.
  • edited August 2013
    Except when I'm driving. of course
  • edited August 2013
    Hahaha lol
  • edited August 2013
    I can forgive Cany and Kenny for being okay with Ehkay, I can never forgive Ehkay for driving me insane from one thread.

    Why do I get the feeling that half the reason you hate Lilly is because of Ehkay?
    btw, is anyone else actually enjoying this?

    Yes, I love arguing. Not intense, angry arguing, but more of a discussion, with two sides.
  • edited August 2013
    Harpadarpa wrote: »
    Why do I get the feeling that half the reason you hate Lilly is because of Ehkay?



    Yes, I love arguing. Not intense, angry arguing, but more of a discussion, with two sides.

    In all honesty the hatred of Lilly came LONG before Ehkay, he is just a very small reason to hate Lilly.
  • edited August 2013
    I dunno about that... The death of one character is hardly enough to get your panties in a bunch :)
  • edited August 2013
    Trust me, just look at my post history, the hate goes all the way back to May, believe me I am a honest man, I hate Lilly because she killed Carley yes that is a major reason, I have said before that I agree with what Hershel said, family is important, and to me close friends are considered family to me, so Lilly murdered family, that and she was my forth favorite character behind Lee Clem and Kenny.
  • edited August 2013
    Hey I hate Kenny because of the death of one character and that one character was a character I didn't even like...
  • edited August 2013
    And that character would be...Ben perhaps, I feel so dumb for not knowing what you are talking about.
  • edited August 2013
    Larry of course...
  • edited August 2013
    I actualy really want Lilly in S2..I REALLY liked her character and understood where she was coming from in ep 3 even tho i didnt think it was right.
    for Kenny you need to side with him on EVERY SINGLE ARGUMENT/SITUATION if you want him as your "bro"..but all you need to for Lilly is to save Larry and she is on your side.

    Kenny suddenly forgot I fed his kid twice & saved him at the farm + saving his wife drom walker David/Travis,he left me for dead twice !
    Larry is Lilly's only family in the apocolypse and people couldnt take the last thing she had away from her - thats why most of us tried to revive Larry.

    I said this before on different thread/here (can't remmeber) Lilly's character was the most well written character and the most interesting 1 if you try to understand her I know it wont happen but I want to play as her in S2 ^^ see how she is dealing with things after killing Doug/Carley

    EDIT : Lilly made the impression for me that no matter how much she hates a charatcter she will protect him (siding with Kenny in ep2 argument about the new ppl will lead her to say somehting like that) so if Kenny was christa and Lilly was Kenny (if you dropped ben in ep 4) she would have save him - she was ready to forgivie him as she says in ep 3
  • edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    I actualy really want Lilly in S2..I REALLY liked her character and understood where she was coming from in ep 3 even tho i didnt think it was right.
    for Kenny you need to side with him on EVERY SINGLE ARGUMENT/SITUATION if you want him as your "bro"..but all you need to for Lilly is to save Larry and she is on your side.

    Kenny suddenly forgot I fed his kid twice & saved him at the farm + saving his wife drom walker David/Travis,he left me for dead twice !
    Larry is Lilly's only family in the apocolypse and people couldnt take the last thing she had away from her - thats why most of us tried to revive Larry.

    I said this before on different thread/here (can't remmeber) Lilly's character was the most well written character and the most interesting 1 if you try to understand her I know it wont happen but I want to play as her in S2 ^^ see how she is dealing with things after killing Doug/Carley

    I don't think many Doug/Carley fans would be happy to play as their murderer .
  • edited August 2013
    Kenny murdered Larry so whats the difference?
  • edited August 2013
    I don't think many Doug/Carley fans would be happy to play as their murderer .

    thats very true,thats why I said I dont think it will happend :) I liked carley myself but the "try to help somebody for once" right after she saved your ass from the bandits kinda got under my skin :( as much as I liked her
  • edited August 2013
    Roy1306 wrote: »
    thats very true,thats why I said I dont think it will happend :) I liked carley myself but the "try to help somebody for once" right after she saved your ass from the bandits kinda got under my skin :( as much as I liked her

    Well Lilly was a bit rude aswell , if you choose " Why her " she says that Carley's family could be bandits thus pissing her off . I would be too if someone said that my family are a bunch of terrorists .
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    Kenny murdered Larry so whats the difference?

    Difference is, that we don't even know if he was alive. He might've just turn into a walker and kill everyone in the room. Kenny didn't want to take the risk.
  • edited August 2013
    And Ben, Carley, or Doug were killing the group by taking supplies.
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    And Ben, Carley, or Doug were killing the group by taking supplies.

    Carley and Doug never took the supplies and never did anything to the group so your argument is invalid .
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    And Ben, Carley, or Doug were killing the group by taking supplies.
    She never accused Doug...
    To be fair Doug was probably the only person she actually trusted...
  • edited August 2013
    Well Lilly was a bit rude aswell , if you choose " Why her " she says that Carley's family could be bandits thus pissing her off . I would be too if someone said that my family are a bunch of terrorists .

    Lilly was very pissed because right after she came back to save the group that hated her (she could run away from her window but she chose to shoot and save them) and her suspisions for someone taking supplies are now revealed as true - she was right and not the group that considered her as a crazy,paranoid person.
    the group just lost all of their medications and food,where could they get more on the road? I understood where she was coming from even tho I didnt agree with killing Carley..
  • edited August 2013
    Hudomonkey wrote: »
    She never accused Doug...
    To be fair Doug was probably the only person she actually trusted...

    Well she did tell Doug to shut up something like " I heard enough of you , Ok Doug ? "
  • edited August 2013
    But at that time we did not know who did it but we knew that it was one of them.
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    But at that time we did not know who did it but we knew that it was one of them.

    And what if it wasn't them ? Are you just going to shoot random people for nothing ?
  • edited August 2013
    Difference is, that we don't even know if he was alive. He might've just turn into a walker and kill everyone in the room. Kenny didn't want to take the risk.

    I disagree,Kenny never made the impression of being protective towards anyone else but his family,if he couldnt take any risks why didnt he toss duck out to? there was a chance of duck coming back as a walker aswell and we didnt know if he was bitten or not..for me killing Larry was more of a revange for the man that wanted to kill his son
  • edited August 2013
    Who else could it be? Ben and Carley/Doug were alone at the house in season 2 which points to them as suspects. And if I had to then yes.
  • edited August 2013
    Ehkay wrote: »
    Who else could it be? Ben and Carley/Doug were alone at the house in season 2 which points to them as suspects. And if I had to then yes.

    At that time , the bandits were attacking the diary and they wanted food from the St Johns and as Jolene said , if the St Johns still lived the bandits would get food from the diary not from Motor Inn .
    Whose to say that Ben and Carley/Doug were the likely suspects ? It could of been Kenny or Katjaa , Lee , Duck or Clem for all we know .
  • edited August 2013
    Carley did make herself quite suspicious...
    I mean she did keep Lee's secret from the rest of the group and she was always on her own neither siding with Lilly or Kenny...
    Ben and Carley would have been the people I would have suspected...
This discussion has been closed.