Alvin or Nick
After episode 2 both have determinant status, what if Carver makes Clementine choose who survives and who doesn't. Who would you choose ?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.
After episode 2 both have determinant status, what if Carver makes Clementine choose who survives and who doesn't. Who would you choose ?
Comments
Goddamn it, Domingez!
Umm... Fuck it, Alvin! The baby needs its father.
I'm stuck.
Alvin because he is the father(maybe) of the kid, but Nick because Pete told me to protect Nick....
UHHHHH
God damn it. In the heat of the moment I'd choose Nick but in my super cereal save I'd save Alvin.
I like Alvin But I like Nick more, And I promised Uncle Pete I would watch over him.
He forces you to make the decision in front of both of them and then kills the one you choose to survive.
Oh......no.......If I save Nick, he and Luke will be happy but Rebecca won't have Alvin and if I save Alvin, he and Rebecca will be happy but Luke won't have Nick! hmmmmmmmmmm......I'd probably have to go with Alvin but it'd be a tough decision. If this were to happen though, I'd base my pick off of the situation at the time.
Carver won't let him lol.
Anyway it's a very tough decision. I have been thinking about it a while....
Consequences of picking Alvin: Luke will be disappointed or even hate Clem for letting Nick die.
Consequences of picking Nick: Rebecca will be devastated.
In the heat of the moment, I would've save Nick.
Nick. I don't trust Alvin. Plus Carver seems to have a legitimate reason to be pissed at him.
Or he's testing Clem and gives her an empty gun. Carver the troll lol
My Clem would be too haunted by Christa and Omid's tragedy to do anything other than save Alvin. Sorry Nick. Only way he might get saved is if it turns out that Alvin is not quite the loving husband he seems to be.
Nick. I promised Pete and I will NEVER break that promise. Even if it was between him and Kenny. Damn you Pete... You had to troll me by making me promise.
" Nick. I don't trust Alvin. "
So you think the guy that nearly shot you the first time you met, didn't want to help Clem and Pete at the river, mouthed of at you a couple of times and accidentilly shot a nice innocent man is more trustworthy? I am seriously asking myself where all this Nick love is coming from...we haven't seen anything good coming from him so far.
If Nick keeps fucking things up then he will be just like Ben 2.0, I think he will come around and be more useful after the whole Matthew incident. Alvin is hiding something we only know he killed a guy named George, maybe Alvin also messed up big time before.
A promise is forever.
omg. lol that would suck id b like, What The??
Thank God I didn't pinky swear with Sarah!
Nick because I promised Pete (On one of my save files), and Nick distracted the walkers so that Clem could get away at the start of episode 2. Plus I just like Nick more.
Neither. I'd just let the timer run out. But if I was forced to choose I guess I'd go with Nick. He's far more interesting than Alvin. Besides Rebecca's baby has Carver she doesn't need Alvin.
" Maybe Alvin also messed up big time before. "
Yes maybe he did, but we don't even know that yet. What we do know is that Nick screwed up a couple of times already! And yes maybe Nick won't screw up as much anymore in the future, or maybe he will even become " usefull ". But the facts are, so far he wasn't, so far he just ruined things.
A test of loyalty and how far she can go maybe.
I would save Nick. I'm more interested in his development, and of course the infamous promise to Uncle Pete.
Nick is honest and loyal. Alvin is sneaky and a coward.
C'mon, stop with this "Nick is Ben 2.0". He's not. He can tell the truth and apologize for something what he did. Ben couldn't do this, remember? He lied to us when Lily indicted him and earlier he was quiet about that what happened with supplies- Nick wanted to talk with group about that what he did. Second thing: Savannah. Zombies around, Clem in danger - Ben left her and escaped. Nick stayed to sacrifice for her.
And Nick is not THAT stupid to take the weapon which you blocked the doors...
Damn, poor Alvin... I also promised Pete and Luke to watch over Nick.
I'd save Nick, I really like him and I'd be devastated if he died. Alvin is an alright guy but like others have said, he's suspicious and has apparently killed someone in cold blood. Wouldn't be surprised if he turns out to be not as nice of a guy as we initially thought.
Rebecca would be heartbroken and would most likely hate Clem for it, but I have a feeling Carver would kill Alvin sooner or later anyways. He seems to have a grudge on him and could possibly see him as a competitor since they're both romantically interested in Rebecca.
" C'mon, stop with this "Nick is Ben 2.0". "
Could you please explain me, why you saying this to me? I never said he is. Domingez said that.
What i said is that Nick screwed up alot of things and due to this fact, he isn't trutworthy.
Wow, that would be hard decision... I honestly have no idea. I genuinely like both of those characters, but Nick is a bit of a screw up, at worst, a liability. Plus, Alvin is nice to Clem. Still Nick is Luke's best friend, and I did promise Pete that I'd protect Nick.
It's one of those decisions that I don't think I'd have any idea until I get to the decision. I honestly have no clue.
Definitely Nick.
I really hope he survives the next episode.
Good points. Ben was the screw up of S1 and Nick at the moment is the only one that is screwing up in S2 just saying. Difference between them is that Nick is an adult who seems to cope better than a kid like Ben. Nick was truly sorry and apologetic for his actions I agree. However Ben was a scared shitless kid but he did say sorry to Lee on the train for getting Carley killed and in ep.5 he also tells Kenny that he is sorry for what he did.
I'd choose to have Nick survive.
If he did kill Nick after that, like Dome says, he'd be at the top of my list of people to fuck up. I made a promise, damnit...
Alot of people like Nick, But i have to go with Alvin for the story's sake. The Screen for Episode 3 has Clem helping Rebecca give birth so i wanna see Alvin and Rebecca talk about what happened with her and Carver.