I think I'm ready to leave the forum

1356

Comments

  • Saying everyone has a few problems and then they hate it is kind downplaying the issue. There are actually a lot of problems with Season Two as a whole (objectively more than Season One), and people are desperate to point out these flaws because it’s a shame how many more flaws there are in this season.

    There is a huge difference with Carley’s death and Nick/Sarah’s death in that the former was well written and served a purpose, while the latter happened just because and were riddled with gaping plotholes. There’s a reason people didn’t boycott after Carley’s death, but are doing so after Nick/Sarah. Not that I agree with such a reaction, but Carley’s situation was nothing like Nick/Sarah’s.

    Season One had potential and did something with it. Season Two had just as much potential, but so far hasn’t been as good as it could have been.

    Anyways, a DLC of the 400 Days character would be pretty awesome :P

    TJ3046 posted: »

    I'm attached to the series as well. I was depressed for weeks after Lee died in season one and Omid's death pissed me off something awful. I

  • I wouldn't say that the majority isn't giving criticism. You'll find that it's mostly the same people who're repeatedly "whining" rather than criticising. In other words, a vocal minority(?)

    Deceptio posted: »

    Well, I haven't been on that much during these past couple of days. All I've really noticed were thread titles and the threads themselves, a

  • Yeah sometimes I think people don't understand the difference between criticism and complaining. Criticism is actually valid and helps a lot (in the case of constructive criticism anyway), whereas complaining achieves nothing. But I guess you all knew that, right? :P

    Deceptio posted: »

    Well, I haven't been on that much during these past couple of days. All I've really noticed were thread titles and the threads themselves, a

  • Oh yeah. Red Dead changed me as a person if that says anything. That's the most personal video game story I've ever experienced besides The Walking Dead S1.

    Speaking of the GTA series, you should definitely also check out Red Dead Redemption. This game is a masterpiece and in my opinion, it's eve

  • This is why its sometimes better to not be on a forum altogether.. You dont get spoiled before release.. And you can enjoy the game without coming on here and listening to overreactions and pointless ranting about an episode.

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    I don't know why people are trying to "boycott" telltale. Nothing will happen, what's done is done sadly. Just don't buy their future stuff, like me. Personally, I hate how they destroyed the series because of them rushing things for future projects but that's them and they could do what they want. But, they wont be getting my $5 dollars and future money on their planned games because of this. Episode 4 is a horrible way to end MY TWD story, but I don't want to worsen it by playing episode 5 since they just want a cheap tear. And plus, there is no time left and no going back to change the plot for episode 5 so it's really useless and already going to be disappointing. Also I noticed puzzlebox replying to this thread only, that's honestly really sad.

  • edited July 2014

    You seem to misunderstand the complaints about Sarah. People complain about her death(her second one) because it was riddled with plot holes, not because it was impossible to save her. There was literally no reason for her to be out on the deck rather than inside with Rebecca. Inconsistent characterization. There was also no reason no one besides Jane went down to help Sarah, or why no one thought to shoot Sarah so she wouldn't have to suffer.

    Just try to ignore all this hate threads about the previous episode. The episode definitely wasn't flawless and there were some major proble

  • edited July 2014

    Hehe would be nice but don't delete the likes because some people have work hard to gain those xD

    puzzlebox posted: »

    A few hours ago I was going to make a thread like this but I was arias of getting dislikes. This is something that concerns me... it

  • puzzlebox?

    It's ok if you don't like it, that's not the point.

    The point is ranting about some flaws (even though there are flaws, I will admit, it can't ruin the entire episode) and trying to start up boycotts.

    And yes it is crazy that outside of the forums everyone likes it, and this is suppose to be the fan base?

    Ellias posted: »

    I don't know why people are trying to "boycott" telltale. Nothing will happen, what's done is done sadly. Just don't buy their future stuff,

  • Episode 4 is everyone jumping on the IGN 6 rating bandwagon...

  • Eh, I've seen tons of different people just complaining, on the forum at least. I don't know about twitter and all of that other stuff,

    I wouldn't say that the majority isn't giving criticism. You'll find that it's mostly the same people who're repeatedly "whining" rather than criticising. In other words, a vocal minority(?)

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    because this forum is basically the people who actually wait the whole 2 months and care every day literally, so I guess they expect a perfect episode, or um a decent one lol? And just because it's the fan base doesn't mean they'll like everything wtf? Are you and everybody actually surprised people are going far and making a scene because the episode wasn't decent to them? That's what fans do, they over react and care about every little thing.

    And most of the people who say it was a good episode is most likely one of those lp viewers, which is sad.

    longlivelee posted: »

    puzzlebox? It's ok if you don't like it, that's not the point. The point is ranting about some flaws (even though there are flaws, I w

  • Yea I know what you mean, it's like people buy the game just to find them

    People will always look for flaws in everything. That's why we can't have nice things.

  • perfect
    Everything has flaws.

    they'll like everything
    I never said they had to like everything, I just said they didn't have to hate everything. Fans are fans of a specific hobby or whatever, not haters of it.

    lp viewers
    This is so wrong how you concluded to this is beyond me ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

    Ellias posted: »

    because this forum is basically the people who actually wait the whole 2 months and care every day literally, so I guess they expect a perfe

  • Episodes 4 didn't destroy MY TWD ending.

    Ellias posted: »

    I don't know why people are trying to "boycott" telltale. Nothing will happen, what's done is done sadly. Just don't buy their future stuff,

  • Yea right, because IGN ratings are obviously very legit...COD 10/10 every year-.-

    Alt text

    Legendary12 posted: »

    Episode 4 is everyone jumping on the IGN 6 rating bandwagon...

  • Mine either :)

    iHeartTWD posted: »

    Episodes 4 didn't destroy MY TWD ending.

  • The episode4 ending was a perfect setup for the season finale...i can't wait to see what's happening next! (And who is gonna survive the shotout)

    TJ3046 posted: »

    Mine either

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    Perfect Of course everything has flaws, tell me something I don't know.

    They'll like everything I assumed you were implying that since you ended it off by saying "And yes it is crazy that outside of the forums everyone likes it, and this is suppose to be the fan base?" only safe assumption really. But now you know.

    lp viewers It isn't wrong since the people who consider it a great episode are people who watch it on youtube. Which honestly I have no idea why telltale allows this, they lose a ton of money by that and gain little, but again that's none of my business and a whole different topic I am NOT getting into.

    longlivelee posted: »

    perfect Everything has flaws. they'll like everything I never said they had to like everything, I just said they didn't have to hate ev

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    I can maybe understand that, but you go gurl.

    iHeartTWD posted: »

    Episodes 4 didn't destroy MY TWD ending.

  • edited July 2014

    Here a quarter seems to hate it, every little aspect. Everything I can name has been hated on here. Outside of the forums I rarely see this.

    I consider it a great episode, and I actually have bought the game. That's like me saying all of the haters don't buy twd and just see it somewhere, don't generalize. So in a way that is incorrect.

    I'm not saying you have to "love it" I'm just asking for some to quit talking about ONLY the flaws, nothing else. It'd be great to see actually a real discussion taking place, instead of some boycott about giving up a game just because you didn't like an episode or a flaw.

    Ellias posted: »

    Perfect Of course everything has flaws, tell me something I don't know. They'll like everything I assumed you were implying that since yo

  • edited July 2014

    People on the Telltale forums are upset over an episode of Walking Dead?
    Alt text

    Seriously, this isn't anything new. Many gamers tend to be unforgiving at times. Sometime it's understandable.

  • ElliasEllias Banned
    edited July 2014

    There are REAL discussions taking place, stop over reacting. Same with the "quarter" thing since I'm seeing more people who find it decent and or good on this forum. Stop being in the hate threads then.

    If you cannot take negative critisim then stop going on this site and rather go on the sites that actually like it, like you said. If you want to leave like OP, then go ahead nobody is stopping you.

    And i'm not generalizing. The people I know IRL, sadly watch it on youtube and consider it DECENT. My assumption to why there's more NEGATIVE in this forum is because these people go on this site daily waiting for the news. they actually wait and pay attention to time and the little news telltale gives out like what? once a month or two? That's why the majority is negative, because they expect highly of it. And don't go on arguing about "oh blah blah they shouldn't blah" because it's going to be useless since I think that too. Also once the episode is released alot of people are already pissed off because of the poor pr and the long wait.

    longlivelee posted: »

    Here a quarter seems to hate it, every little aspect. Everything I can name has been hated on here. Outside of the forums I rarely see this.

  • edited July 2014

    Nobody is expecting GOTY, everyone is expecting good character development and no forced or lazy writing, if there are some issues with episode 5 for folks, then they will give their honest thoughts, those people are not forcing you to read their threads that is YOUR CHOICE, if the forum is getting too negative, then maybe there is an issue, either way, you can't silence opinions and you can't simply write off some people's well thought out complaints as whining, that is childish.

    #TeamSarah posted: »

    I'm NOT coming to these forums after episode 5. because if it isn't GOTY then there will be a lot of complaning.

  • I never over reacted (ô‿ô)

    And I cannot avoid those threads, they are everywhere, and the threads that have nothing to do with those threads have people hating on them.

    Yeah the people you may know are not the same people, that's no excuse.

    I never said I wanted to leave, we were just giving out some things on our mind, and we didn't need people saying this stuff to try to shut the minority up.

    So please don't go on saying "leave" because that's not what I'm trying to say. No need to make the minority opinion feel worthless.

    Ellias posted: »

    There are REAL discussions taking place, stop over reacting. Same with the "quarter" thing since I'm seeing more people who find it decent a

  • One episode (ô‿ô)

    "this episode made me hate twd. boycotting. not buying. etc..."

    MatthewPaul posted: »

    People on the Telltale forums are upset over an episode of Walking Dead? Seriously, this isn't anything new. Many gamers tend to be unforgiving at times. Sometime it's understandable.

  • Well I personally don't hate it. It could've been better and I wish what happened on the slide happened in the actual episode (among other things) but I enjoyed. Certainly not the best episode. I'm just happy I played it.

    longlivelee posted: »

    One episode (ô‿ô) "this episode made me hate twd. boycotting. not buying. etc..."

  • How is it childish when not everyone wants to talk about Nick's bad death 24/7 its childish to just point out little flaws and honestly, bitch about them for 5 hours. I'm not saying there can't be complaints, but there shouldn't be so many threads about the same thing. And some of you are expecting GOTY, no matter how good the episode is there is lots of complaints. Even after A House Divided there was TONS of threads saying how terrible it was. The forum is always negative these days, issue or not.

    J-Master posted: »

    Nobody is expecting GOTY, everyone is expecting good character development and no forced or lazy writing, if there are some issues with epis

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    If you say so.

    Then if you are really bothered by those threads, then it's probably best to leave the forums or try to avoid the threads and not click on them? Also there is an option to hide comments so you can hide negative reviews and rants

    they are the same people?... LOL?

    And I never told you to leave. said if you wanted to then go ahead nobody is stopping anybody.

    Again, I didn't tell you to "leave!!!". I advised it since you seem really bothered by negative reviews and rants and they're "everywhere". I only assumed too.

    Also what are you talking about? I'm not dissing anybody at all who say twd episode 4 is perfect. I don't care if people consider it good, I never argued with any. It's actually vise verse. People will tart at the people who have something negative to say, or flood them with downrates. Not that downrates affect me in any way, i'm just saying so. So honestly, that doesn't make sense.

    longlivelee posted: »

    I never over reacted (ô‿ô) And I cannot avoid those threads, they are everywhere, and the threads that have nothing to do with those thre

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    Everybody but luke and kenny since they will force the icecream and pizza. typical telltale.

    The episode4 ending was a perfect setup for the season finale...i can't wait to see what's happening next! (And who is gonna survive the shotout)

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    Why do people hate on COD so much? I mean I understand that it's repetitive but I don't see the same hate on Mario games and Zelda games. Also, the zombie story in COD world at war-black ops 2 is brilliant.

    Yea right, because IGN ratings are obviously very legit...COD 10/10 every year-.-

  • ElliasEllias Banned
    edited July 2014

    "One episode" You fail to realize the majority of are points. Alot of us have been starting to dislike TWD series since episode 2. Poor interaction (we hardly got to talk to any characters) Lack of hubs, although the one in episode 2 is somewhat okay. Actions are limited as well as conversation. And choices do not matter.

    longlivelee posted: »

    One episode (ô‿ô) "this episode made me hate twd. boycotting. not buying. etc..."

  • It's not the opposite, believe me. I have pages of proof. I'll give you some since you need it ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

    And the downvotes represent how many people disagree with you, so in a way it's almost like a status.

    It's not the same people, you said "PEOPLE I KNOW". I'm not someone you know...LOL?

    Ellias posted: »

    If you say so. Then if you are really bothered by those threads, then it's probably best to leave the forums or try to avoid the threads

  • y are you disliking my every post m8 (ô‿ô)

    Ellias posted: »

    "One episode" You fail to realize the majority of are points. Alot of us have been starting to dislike TWD series since episode 2. Poor inte

  • Dislikes and insults. I know how that feels....

    puzzlebox posted: »

    A few hours ago I was going to make a thread like this but I was arias of getting dislikes. This is something that concerns me... it

  • "I think I'm ready to leave the forum."

    I don't mean to sound rude, but I've never seen you before...

  • He's been around since last year, just hasn't commented very often.

    "I think I'm ready to leave the forum." I don't mean to sound rude, but I've never seen you before...

  • ElliasEllias Banned

    I do not dislike any post, I haven't disliked any in months. You shouldn't let dislikes get to you, also what is the reason for that face? Is it supposed to be funny? I do not get it.

    longlivelee posted: »

    y are you disliking my every post m8 (ô‿ô)

  • I've.. I've seen one Sarah post, most are about Luke from what I've seen. Though the few Sarah and Luke comments on those posts are quite overwhelming with negativity.

  • Oh I see...

    It's a dislike troll nvm.

    ignore my last post

    Ellias posted: »

    I do not dislike any post, I haven't disliked any in months. You shouldn't let dislikes get to you, also what is the reason for that face? Is it supposed to be funny? I do not get it.

Sign in to comment in this discussion.