[SPOILERS]Lilly to return? (merged threads)

edited September 2012 in The Walking Dead
Hey guys,

I want to see how many peoples besides me would like to have Lilly back in group in the next episode.

She is my favorite character alongside with Carley and Duck,but since those two are already dead i hope i will have an option to at least have her back.

What you guys think ?
«1345

Comments

  • edited August 2012
    She killed my bro and stole my ride.

    Woman don't get more kill on sight than that. :mad:
  • edited August 2012
    This is a joke, right?
  • edited August 2012
    I really liked Lily...i really did until she shot Carley like that...crazy bitch...and i did another play where i take her to the RV but she leaves me like that anyways...so NO
  • edited August 2012
    I wouldn't mind seeing her in another episode, but she's not getting back in the group. She became extremely paranoid, murdered a member of the group, stole the RV and abandoned everyone.
  • edited August 2012
    Tekor wrote: »
    Hey guys,

    I want to see how many peoples besides me would like to have Lilly back in group in the next episode.

    She is my favorite character alongside with Carley and Duck,but since those two are already dead i hope i will have an option to at least have her back.

    What you guys think ?

    Lilly killed Carly because the stress of being the alpha and the loss of her father caused her to snap. I can understand the cause of her snapping but the death isn't justified. If I were Lee I would not feel safe with Lilly around Clem or myself.
  • edited August 2012
    Sure id love to see her back. JUST SO I CAN GET JUSTICE FOR CARLY. But i would let her kill Ben first just so i wouldnt have to get my hands dirty.And where was the throw Ben over the side of the train option?
  • edited August 2012
    Lilly can't be in the next episode because she's on her way to Woodbury, which according to google maps is west of Macon whereas Savannah is east.
  • edited August 2012
    Only if she comes back naked
  • edited August 2012
    I'd like to see her come back......as a Walker so I can put a bullet in her brain!

    Attachment not found.
  • edited August 2012
    It is unlikely we will see her in Ep4. But for Ep5? I would say it is very likely, that she will come back and there will be that moment of wrath, justice and redemption (not neccesarily in this order). It would be very fitting, considering what she has done.
  • edited August 2012
    Faramis wrote: »
    It is unlikely we will see her in Ep4. But for Ep5? I would say it is very likely, that she will come back and there will be that moment of wrath, justice and redemption (not neccesarily in this order). It would be very fitting, considering what she has done.

    True...also if she tells me that she buried Carly and apologizes for what she did....that would be a big PLUS!
  • edited August 2012
    I would have shot and killed her in Episode 3 if I had the chance.
  • edited August 2012
    she can come back if she wants but she would be safer hanging with the walkers then with me.
  • edited August 2012
    She will for sure come back but not in the next episode and I want her to make a comeback, because every group need a troublemaker you can love or hate ;)
  • edited August 2012
    You like her? After she murdered your friend right in front of you, with no evidence, just because she had a hunch? And then the hunch turned out to be wrong? Cold blooded murder man, there's not much Lilly can do to come back from this.
  • edited August 2012
    Rock114 wrote: »
    You like her? After she murdered your friend right in front of you, with no evidence, just because she had a hunch? And then the hunch turned out to be wrong? Cold blooded murder man, there's not much Lilly can do to come back from this.

    to be fair she wasent aiming for carley/doug she was aiming for ben, and it was him so it was a good hunch.
  • edited August 2012
    She was on edge, her father was killed. It was in the heat of the moment, and quite honestly I shot Jolee after a very brief conversation, so I'm not one to Judge.

    But yeah, I'd quite like Lilly to catch up with the group.
  • edited August 2012
    Well, when I said Lilly, that I will go with her, before she left me in the dust, the game said that "Lilly will remember that".

    So maybe we will see her again ?
  • edited August 2012
    But then, the game told us Shawn would remember that too... he died about 10 mins later.
  • edited August 2012
    Well, when I said Lilly, that I will go with her, before she left me in the dust, the game said that "Lilly will remember that".

    So maybe we will see her again ?

    She will, but we'll not see her again in the game. If you guys want Lilly, read the coming novel and/or the comic books.

    Oh... and by the way, I hate Ben!!!
  • edited August 2012
    [Comic spoilers]

    Well Lilly is only in once scene in the comics..
  • edited August 2012
    big-augen wrote: »
    She will, but we'll not see her again in the game. If you guys want Lilly, read the coming novel and/or the comic books.

    Oh... and by the way, I hate Ben!!!

    Why ? Maybe i am missing something but in the game it's not being said where is she going and storyline doesn't actually follow comic books?
  • edited August 2012
    Lilly is the woman that shoots Lori and the baby at the prison. Kirkman has already stated that this game is canon so in order for the two to connect Lilly has to be on her way towards Woodbury so that she can run into Rick's group in the comics.
  • edited August 2012
    darham175 wrote: »
    Lilly is the woman that shoots Lori and the baby at the prison. Kirkman has already stated that this game is canon so in order for the two to connect Lilly has to be on her way towards Woodbury so that she can run into Rick's group in the comics.

    I didn't knew the game is canon to the comic books but i checked it out and yes it is BUT highlight me please because Lilly doesn't die in the comic and wikia says "In The Walking Dead Survivors' Guide, Lilly is listed as presumed living. " so there is a chance that she is coming back in later episodes i believe.
  • edited August 2012
    Lilly is a self-centered bitch and that's putting it nicely. I helped her and she betrayed my trust. She ignored me and killed my woman. Even despite (unknowingly) killing the wrong person, she tried to justify her act by throwing out own murders back at us. She didn't know the difference. She killed someone that posed no immediate threat, intentionally, based on an emotionally fuelled hunch.

    None of mine or Kennys kills managed to tick every one of those boxes. Oh but I can think of someone who DID try that before her. Larry when he punched me in the store. Oh did I mention I found some pills to save his life just moments before he did that?

    Not only did she use our own murders against us, she suggests that they all just drop that it happened, like she apparently did when Kenny killed Larry.... she didn't in the slightest. Another quote from her "but I'll die". Yes, with any luck, justice will be served.

    She is corrupt and self-centered. She doesn't have the decision-making skills to be fit for a leader, that much is certain. She diesn;t want to help anyone from outside the group, but when it comes to an abandoned full of loot it's "wrong" to take it? Whether she's right or wrong about a bunch of things, her reasoning is always off.
  • edited August 2012
    Sergiy wrote: »
    But then, the game told us Shawn would remember that too... he died about 10 mins later.

    Yeah, you've got a point.
  • edited August 2012
    What, Lilly shoots Lori? I think I found my new favourite character right here.
  • edited August 2012
    I'm actually hoping we'll see her again in a Season 2 of the game.
  • edited August 2012
    Khazmo wrote: »
    I'm actually hoping we'll see her again in a Season 2 of the game.

    I thought the game is just 5 episodes and that's it?



    Seeing Lilzzz in episode 4 might be too soon but I think she might make that episode 5 appearance.
  • edited August 2012
    I hope Season 2 is a whole different story not related to Lee or Clementine. Cameos of characters (not Lee or Clementine though) who were in the first Season and also comic characters, obviously, would be good. I like the idea of playing as a female character.

    Edit: I really, really hope Lilly doesn't return. Not because I don't like her, just I liked the way she left (only if you decide to not take her with you in the RV like I did though) and the whole shock factor around it. Having her return would completely ruin it.
  • edited August 2012
    The game is just 5 episodes, but if it makes them enough money, expect a sequel season to come out. Afterall, it will cost less to make a sequel, due to being able to reuse so many assets from season 1, whilst making more money.

    Personally, I think this season will end in one of two ways, both of which lend into a season 2:

    1) Lee dies, which means that Telltale avoid having to carry over any decisions from the first season, and can use a new character instead.
    2) All but Lee and Clem die, meaning that for season 2, they can give us a new group to go with, and the actions of the first season do not matter much.

    I can't see it ending any other way
  • edited August 2012
    No. At this point I think putting a character that would *have* to leave the group at some point because she "needed to be elsewhere" was a mistake from the start. Glen should have been the only Cameo group member and his departure was handled exceptionally well. Lily's should have been as well, not sacrificing two characters just to send her packing. Her coming back will only serve as a reminder of TellTale's blunder in this regard.
  • edited August 2012
    ruairi46 wrote: »
    to be fair she wasent aiming for carley/doug she was aiming for ben, and it was him so it was a good hunch.

    Oh, she was aiming for Carley. At point blank, she shot her right in the face.
  • edited August 2012
    ComixFan wrote: »
    No. At this point I think putting a character that would *have* to leave the group at some point because she "needed to be elsewhere" was a mistake from the start. Glen should have been the only Cameo group member and his departure was handled exceptionally well. Lily's should have been as well, not sacrificing two characters just to send her packing. Her coming back will only serve as a reminder of TellTale's blunder in this regard.

    Just because Lilly ends up in Woodbury doesn't neccesarily mean she headed there straight away, she probably knew about the group heading to Savannah and therefore could have headed that way herself. She could still show up in 4 or 5 so long as she has time to end up in Woodbury. Anyone wanna throw together a timeline for this stuff?
  • edited August 2012
    I'd like there to be a season 2 where Lily shows up. Just in time for me to put a bullet between her eyes.
  • edited August 2012
    No, I think her part in the series is done. Actually when I realized she is a character that shows up later in the comic, I kinda wanted her gone only because I know she survives and 90% of the fun in this game is not knowing whos gonna bite it next. Now that characters like her, Glen and Hershal are out, it really means that we're in unpredictable territory from here on out.
  • edited August 2012
    wrex08 wrote: »
    What, Lilly shoots Lori? I think I found my new favourite character right here.

    Totally! Lily's my girl! She redeems herself for killing the Governor. In my opinion Carley kinda deserved it. She always wanted to stay in the gray, not taking responsibility and decisions. Well except Lee (who's a man) there was nobody for Lily to talk to. Katjaa is with her husband, Ben is a moron, Duck is Robin...oh and I forgot. I"M BATMAN!!! :D :D
    But yeah, I think Lily needed some heart to heart conversation with a woman and if Carley actually did try to help somehow, because despite being a good shot, she was pretty useless. But no, she had to stay on everybody's good side. And for the record Lily was right - it was either Carley or Ben. It wasn't me obviously because I found out, Kenny despite being an asshole had too much in stake, it couldn't have been the kids as well so... Carley or Ben. It's Ben's fault for not being a man!
    It's funny how most were willing to accept Kenny offing Larry (because it was dangerous) but Lily killing Carley is soo bad. You know Larry could've actually survived but a traitor who led a group of 10-15 bandits + walkers and got poor little Robin biten, that's not a threat?
    I'm glad Lily got away. She was too awesome for this group. Except Lee and Clem. I would've run with Lily and Clem and ditch the others. Prior to Carley's death I probably would've taken her with me if she asked too nicely... having 2 women is definitely better than only 1 :D
    All in all, Lily is a survivor and a leader, one who had too much with stupid group. I bet most of our group will die. She is destined for greater stuff :P
  • edited August 2012
    She might make it back by 5 but not in 4 because it'll happen days after 3 at the most. It really depends on the amount of in game time that goes by. She has a whole story arch outside of the game to go trough and if there is enough time between 4-5 she might comer back depending on what happened in her other story.
  • edited August 2012
    She might come back in Season 2 if TellTale wants to follow the story of Lee Everett
This discussion has been closed.