Then in Episode 3 she went insane, for reasons that don't even work within the narrative. .
Did you miss the part where Kenny drops 45lbs of salt lick onto her father's head after she begged him not to? Not the best way to see your Dad go out, especially by your current nemesis. While being held captive by cannibals. During a Zombie Apocalypse
Did you miss the part where Kenny drops 45lbs of salt lick onto her father's head after she begged him not to? Not the best way to see your Dad go out, especially by your current nemesis. While being held captive by cannibals. During a Zombie Apocalypse
Not to mention that he may have been alive the whole time, but fuck it i'm Kenny and i'm a hypocrite.
She may not of had the biggest heart or cared for Kenny but at least she took care of him and his family no matter how they(kenny) felt about her.
She's nothing like Shane in the TV show...
Shane is obsessed over his friend's wife and does not give a fu** for the group (except maybe for Carl).
Lilly might be headstrong but she does care for the group. She deals with the shit no one else bothers to. To be honest most of those in the group look a bit dumb. In episode 2 like half the party complained that they won't receive food. I mean c'mon... it's obvious there's not enough food for everybody. Food won't magically appear (just as Carley won't magically return ). Lol, I'm such a horrible person for saying things like that.
Lilly never betrayed my Lee and though she killed Carley/Doug she though she was doing what was right at the time. There was a traitor and it needed to be dealt with. Plus she has been through a lot since ep 2.
Shane hasn't gone through anything and he's a cop. He's supposed to be mentally healthy and not snap without strong external motivators.
She didn't have to kill someone just to get the job done
and also rid the world of one of the sickest dictators alive. It was a necessary evil.
Plus she was manipulated into thinking Rick's group were the enemy. I can't get why people blame her for that.
They probably blame her cause she was the one who shot Lori? Lol. Did it even matter if the Governor died after they captured the Prison? Not like they could've stayed there cause of the fences. He was bound to be a walkers meal along with the rest of his gang. Rip Lilly you crazy ass bitch.
She's nothing like Shane in the TV show...
Shane is obsessed over his friend's wife and does not give a fu** for the group (except maybe for Carl).
Lilly might be headstrong but she does care for the group. She deals with the shit no one else bothers to. To be honest most of those in the group look a bit dumb. In episode 2 like half the party complained that they won't receive food. I mean c'mon... it's obvious there's not enough food for everybody. Food won't magically appear (just as Carley won't magically return ). Lol, I'm such a horrible person for saying things like that.
Lilly never betrayed my Lee and though she killed Carley/Doug she though she was doing what was right at the time. There was a traitor and it needed to be dealt with. Plus she has been through a lot since ep 2.
Shane hasn't gone through anything and he's a cop. He's supposed to be mentally healthy and not snap without strong external motivators.
Lilly DID back her father up for throwing a kid out to be eaten by a bunch of dead folks. Only because it was her father you say? That makes it even worse. But I don't see how people can blame her for what she did at the prison, because she and EVERY other single person in Woodbury was MANIPULATED into thinking that Rick's group was evil. And she took out the governor. She gets props for that.
She took out Carley for no reason: She loses some of said props.
Was willing to let me die outside the pharmacy: Loses slightly more props.
Would let Larry reanimate and kill everyone in the meat locker, including Clem: Loses many props.
Steals RV: Gains props. (crappy radiator, can't go far)
Has awesome voice actress in the game. Love it when she screams after Larry gets crushified (just the way she did it so well, i'm not THAT bad of a person): Gains more props.
Leaves me to die at the Dairy: Understandable, props unaffected.
She currently has -4 props in my game. Kenny has 13, Clem has ∞, and Larry has -6,486.
Lilly DID back her father up for throwing a kid out to be eaten by a bunch of dead folks. Only because it was her father you say? That makes it even worse. But I don't see how people can blame her for what she did at the prison, because she and EVERY other single person in Woodbury was MANIPULATED into thinking that Rick's group was evil. And she took out the governor. She gets props for that.
She took out Carley for no reason: She loses some of said props.
Was willing to let me die outside the pharmacy: Loses slightly more props.
Would let Larry reanimate and kill everyone in the meat locker, including Clem: Loses many props.
Steals RV: Gains props. (crappy radiator, can't go far)
Has awesome voice actress in the game. Love it when she screams after Larry gets crushified (just the way she did it so well, i'm not THAT bad of a person): Gains more props.
Leaves me to die at the Dairy: Understandable, props unaffected.
She currently has -4 props in my game. Kenny has 13, Clem has ∞, and Larry has -6,486.
You have to keep in mind that many of those change depending how you play the game. In my game Kenny is more -number than anyone could possible be
I am so sick of people defending Lilly by saying she snapped under pressure. What if she did. So what? Why should I forgive her just because she snapped? All I care about is that she killed an innocent over a hunch and that victim was a good friend of mine. Telltale needs to bring her back so I can put a bullet through her head.
I am so sick of people defending Lilly by saying she snapped under pressure. What if she did. So what? Why should I forgive her just because she snapped? All I care about is that she killed an innocent over a hunch and that victim was a good friend of mine. Telltale needs to bring her back so I can put a bullet through her head.
Don't be ridiculous. You're sick of people defending Lilly? How many people, except me, are doing that? Five? Six?
If you do put a bullet through her head, you won't be very different than her and if you hate her that much... why would you wanna be like her?
Lilly's actions with Carley around are WAY more unhinged than with Doug, making it in my mind a practically different character.
Lilly in Doug world, has modestly founded but ultimately correct suspicions that Ben was working with the Bandits behind the group's back. She tries to be judge, jury, and executioner, then Doug gets in the crossfire and she realizes how bad she just got.
Lilly in Carley world, has completely unfounded suspicion of Carley and intentionally kills Carley in the heat of an argument. She basically justifies it after that.
so Lilly in Carley world is undeniably the worst killer/person in the group so far. Lilly in Doug world is working for the group but taking the extreme of what she knows to be right. She is being a bit hypocritical because she kills the living with far less rationale than Kenny killing the maybe-living, but she is just forcing the group to protect themselves from Ben's two-faced cowardess.
Ben in Carley world practically lets Carley get killed in hopes of living, which makes him real scum. Whereas in Doug world, he was just saving his own ass without letting anyone take the fall. Frankly, Ben probably saved the group by bargaining with bandits for a bit.
kgruscho, I wouldn't call it an unfounded suspicion. Carley is a suspect and she acts the way that an innocent probably won't act. Just because you all like her and know that it isn't her doesn't make her less of a suspect.
If both Lee and Lilly survive to season 2, telltale should make Lilly the only available romance option for Lee. Just be sure to include lots of guilt ridden sex, violent outbursts and a nice gradual descent to insanity, like Lilly starting to treat Lee as some sort of replacement "daddy".
Or barring that, add a romance option where you get hurt because the romance itself, not the world around it, is fucked up. Would be nice to actually play a game where romantic relationships are, at least potentially, stuff of horrors, like the rest of the world.
kgruscho, I wouldn't call it an unfounded suspicion. Carley is a suspect and she acts the way that an innocent probably won't act. Just because you all like her and know that it isn't her doesn't make her less of a suspect.
Yeah, you're completely guilty when you deny being guilty and defend other people from unjustified accusations (unjustified in that Lily had no proof it was Ben). You don't see the police shoot a suspect in the face, just because they have a hunch about that person. Lily fell off the deep end and murdered an innocent person.
Has anything been written about what happens to her after.... her comic appearance?
I think that Kirkman purposefully left it ambiguous. He said he's done with the Prison arc although Lilly is still listed as alive if I'm not mistaken. His reluctance to weave Lilly back to comic book TWD doesn't mean that other medias and parties (game for example) won't continue her story.
In my opinion Carley kinda deserved it. She always wanted to stay in the gray, not taking responsibility and decisions.
da fuq?
So deciding not to take sides, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, meant she deserved getting her face blown off? Nevermind while she had her head turned.
You don't have to like Carley but to say she somehow deserved what she got boggles the mind. She never caused tension within the group and was wrongly accused of stealing supplies. Really, all she did was pick a bad time to ream out Lilly.
But yes, Lilly is a brilliantly written character and it would be cool to see her return sometime.
So deciding not to take sides, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, meant she deserved getting her face blown off? Nevermind while she had her head turned.
You don't have to like Carley but to say she somehow deserved what she got boggles the mind. She never caused tension within the group and was wrongly accused of stealing supplies. Really, all she did was pick a bad time to ream out Lilly.
But yes, Lilly is a brilliantly written character and it would be cool to see her return sometime.
What I meant was that in my opinion if a person does not participate in though choices regarding the group, well he can't throw his vote all of a sudden and demand that people take it seriously. I don't think I'm phrasing it very well but what I mean is that Carley never tried to take responsibility for the bad decision the group made. Now of all a sudden she tries to prevent the investigation of the traitor where actually she's one of the main suspects. Had she not been suspected she would probably do nothing once again.
Instead of proving her innocence she starts talking back and playing the "don't tell me what to do, I'm awesome card".
Yeah, it was kinda like she was asking Lilly to do something extreme.
As for Lilly coming back in season 1 or 2... I'm not sure they'll do it. Most of the players are still pretty pissed off with her and unless they allow us to kill her, I doubt fans will accept it as possible scenario. I would definitely love to see more of her.
The new crew really doesn't appeal to me, besides Clementine I feel nothing to the others. Kenny has changed and won't be the same. Chuck's wierd and Christa doesn't bother me and why hasn't Ben died? Although I think Omid's a funny and breath of fresh air to the group. Lilly will regain that old vibe a little
I don't hold out much hope of Lilly survivng her scene in the comic, but she still could. I'd like to know if she did or not, but that's about the extent of it. I feel that with a book, and being a major character in the game, she's run her course. Her coming back in season 1 would take some pretty magical writing I think, with the group covering so much distance so fast while she went in the opposite direction. I'd prefer to just let Lilly be, and have the writers not take a chance at screwing up her awesome character.
That's what I was hoping to hear.... Lilly for SEASON 2!!! Come on, TTG, you know you wanna!
You know, that would actually be pretty cool. If you found her after she took over the prison with the rest of the survivors from Woodbury, she wouldn't have canon-protection and could die like everyone else.
P.S If they ever decide to bring Lilly back in the comic book I would like to her to meet Rick. They are both very, very similar and have done terrible things. However, the prison scene would be something that would make their relationship quite interesting.
As for those of you who wonder if Lilly survived or not, well if there's someone who would survive that comic book scenes, it's probably her.
Comments
I really like her, I would like to see her in the next Episode
she hasn't a kind heart but she could be a real worthly character
lol holy cow talk about water on a grease fire
Did you miss the part where Kenny drops 45lbs of salt lick onto her father's head after she begged him not to? Not the best way to see your Dad go out, especially by your current nemesis. While being held captive by cannibals. During a Zombie Apocalypse
Not to mention that he may have been alive the whole time, but fuck it i'm Kenny and i'm a hypocrite.
She may not of had the biggest heart or cared for Kenny but at least she took care of him and his family no matter how they(kenny) felt about her.
She didn't have to kill someone just to get the job done
2
Not just no, but hell no.
Next season.... sure.
They probably blame her cause she was the one who shot Lori? Lol. Did it even matter if the Governor died after they captured the Prison? Not like they could've stayed there cause of the fences. He was bound to be a walkers meal along with the rest of his gang. Rip Lilly
Never betrayed Lee? Lol. I'm done.
She took on those responsibilities in order to have control.
She wasn't doing anyone any favors when she pulled that trigger. That was all about Lilly's will and her perceived loss of power.
I kinda like this one, colorfully descriptive.
She took out Carley for no reason: She loses some of said props.
Was willing to let me die outside the pharmacy: Loses slightly more props.
Would let Larry reanimate and kill everyone in the meat locker, including Clem: Loses many props.
Steals RV: Gains props. (crappy radiator, can't go far)
Has awesome voice actress in the game. Love it when she screams after Larry gets crushified (just the way she did it so well, i'm not THAT bad of a person): Gains more props.
Leaves me to die at the Dairy: Understandable, props unaffected.
She currently has -4 props in my game. Kenny has 13, Clem has ∞, and Larry has -6,486.
You have to keep in mind that many of those change depending how you play the game. In my game Kenny is more -number than anyone could possible be
Don't be ridiculous. You're sick of people defending Lilly? How many people, except me, are doing that? Five? Six?
If you do put a bullet through her head, you won't be very different than her and if you hate her that much... why would you wanna be like her?
Lilly in Doug world, has modestly founded but ultimately correct suspicions that Ben was working with the Bandits behind the group's back. She tries to be judge, jury, and executioner, then Doug gets in the crossfire and she realizes how bad she just got.
Lilly in Carley world, has completely unfounded suspicion of Carley and intentionally kills Carley in the heat of an argument. She basically justifies it after that.
so Lilly in Carley world is undeniably the worst killer/person in the group so far. Lilly in Doug world is working for the group but taking the extreme of what she knows to be right. She is being a bit hypocritical because she kills the living with far less rationale than Kenny killing the maybe-living, but she is just forcing the group to protect themselves from Ben's two-faced cowardess.
Ben in Carley world practically lets Carley get killed in hopes of living, which makes him real scum. Whereas in Doug world, he was just saving his own ass without letting anyone take the fall. Frankly, Ben probably saved the group by bargaining with bandits for a bit.
Or barring that, add a romance option where you get hurt because the romance itself, not the world around it, is fucked up. Would be nice to actually play a game where romantic relationships are, at least potentially, stuff of horrors, like the rest of the world.
Yeah, you're completely guilty when you deny being guilty and defend other people from unjustified accusations (unjustified in that Lily had no proof it was Ben). You don't see the police shoot a suspect in the face, just because they have a hunch about that person. Lily fell off the deep end and murdered an innocent person.
With that attitude you should be glad she didn't break your neck
Apparently you're not familiar enough with the Governor...
I think that Kirkman purposefully left it ambiguous. He said he's done with the Prison arc although Lilly is still listed as alive if I'm not mistaken. His reluctance to weave Lilly back to comic book TWD doesn't mean that other medias and parties (game for example) won't continue her story.
da fuq?
So deciding not to take sides, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, meant she deserved getting her face blown off? Nevermind while she had her head turned.
You don't have to like Carley but to say she somehow deserved what she got boggles the mind. She never caused tension within the group and was wrongly accused of stealing supplies. Really, all she did was pick a bad time to ream out Lilly.
But yes, Lilly is a brilliantly written character and it would be cool to see her return sometime.
What I meant was that in my opinion if a person does not participate in though choices regarding the group, well he can't throw his vote all of a sudden and demand that people take it seriously. I don't think I'm phrasing it very well but what I mean is that Carley never tried to take responsibility for the bad decision the group made. Now of all a sudden she tries to prevent the investigation of the traitor where actually she's one of the main suspects. Had she not been suspected she would probably do nothing once again.
Instead of proving her innocence she starts talking back and playing the "don't tell me what to do, I'm awesome card".
Yeah, it was kinda like she was asking Lilly to do something extreme.
As for Lilly coming back in season 1 or 2... I'm not sure they'll do it. Most of the players are still pretty pissed off with her and unless they allow us to kill her, I doubt fans will accept it as possible scenario. I would definitely love to see more of her.
Kinda the same way it says "Carley will remember that" about three seconds before she gets her head blown off?
Lilly's gone. She's gone to Woodbury. She's an official comic book character, so that's canon confirmed.
BTW, I love your user name. Fallout 3 is fantastic.
Only if you had Doug. She aimed for Carley and shot her.
Sucks we cant kill Lilly because of the comics, it'd be nice to at least kill Ben.
You know, that would actually be pretty cool. If you found her after she took over the prison with the rest of the survivors from Woodbury, she wouldn't have canon-protection and could die like everyone else.
P.S If they ever decide to bring Lilly back in the comic book I would like to her to meet Rick. They are both very, very similar and have done terrible things. However, the prison scene would be something that would make their relationship quite interesting.
As for those of you who wonder if Lilly survived or not, well if there's someone who would survive that comic book scenes, it's probably her.