Kenny - Jane

123457»

Comments

  • edited September 2014

    Kenny killed Jane in the fight if Clem doesn't do anything like Jane suggested. Jane thought she was the better survivor but she wasn't. Her lies an instability got her killed. Killing a stronger survivor to save Jane is irrational by your logic. If emotions don't play a role then there is no fear of Kenny who isn't attacking you but is only disposing a liar and possible murderer. Killing Jane is the smartest move since Jane is obviously unable to keep us safe.

    zykelator posted: »

    Well like ive said before, Kenny fans base their choice on irrational factors (feelings and stuff). I like to base my choices on objectivit

  • Jane lets Kenny die to stop a fight she instigated and then asks for Clem's forgiveness after. Kenny doesn't ask a 11-13 yr old for help in killing a group member...but Jane does then Claims they can be free. Every thread you post just exposes what you feel. Emotions are tricky and can lead you to make irrational choices.

    Jane was right about one thing. Clem should stay out of it during the fight as it wasn't her battle! Jane shouldn't have been playing mind games with someone she thought was just like Carver. Not rational at all.

    zykelator posted: »

    First of all, its possible that Arvo leaves with everything he had(except the gun), if Clementine convinces her, but he will still rob you. Kenny has let bunch of people die and he is all about revenge and asking sorry later.

  • edited September 2014

    Last thing I'm posting on this thread.

    The game gives you choices for a reason. (Even if some choices don't change anything but what said, yet still get counted as major choices, those count too.)

    My body can't decide if it's awake or tired, where's Lee or Clem when you need them to make decisions for you because everything in life must depend on them?!

    Also, these arguments are all pointless considering how you've all pointed out the pros and cons of both characters, like I saw someone else post, they're both pretty much the same type of character, both care about Clem more than others or themselves, makes plenty of mistakes, etc. Pay attention and both of them are right about each other. the choice is really about the player, not Clem, it's who you like more, or hate, this choice is for the player to make, based on how they felt towards the characters. Kenny fans obviously like Kenny more, Jane fans like Jane more, and for people who didn't like either of them, go solo.

    I like Kenny more so my vote goes to the Kenny fans, either way, I'm gonna see all the different paths for season 3 anyway, so I guess I shouldn't be arguing. XD

  • Only reason she risked her life was because emotions... She started to care about Clementine and you do stupid things to protect the people you care about. Even she admits that the plan was stupid. What Jane did was stupid, what Kenny did was wrong.

    Jane lets Kenny die to stop a fight she instigated and then asks for Clem's forgiveness after. Kenny doesn't ask a 11-13 yr old for help in

  • You're ignoring all context in both situations when it completely matters.

    zykelator posted: »

    Theres nothing wrong with my comparison... He tried to kill someone based on a fucking assumption. You dont do such extreme things if you arent 100% sure.

  • I never said he was faultless, but the guy beating the shit out of him doesn't get a pass. They were all in that firefight and the only person who saw the need to beat him was Kenny.

    ThinkKritz posted: »

    A teenager who gets his friends to steal a group of people's supplies even if a person who isn't there took a gun from him because he was po

Sign in to comment in this discussion.