We know that it's a flash grenade, but Rhys doesn't (at least, in my playthrough). So, to him it still looks like Fiona is holding an explosive grenade. That's another reason why I picked Jack - Fiona's plan seems pretty much suicidal, and I don't like to put my friends in danger.
Well, if you think about it, it was humour AND reason over YOLO.
That was basically Fiona's big plan. Let's just toss this random grenade looking thing that may or may not work, and hope it all works out. At least Jack's plan would work. The only worry I had with him was whether or not he'd just murder everyone for kicks once he saved Rhys' life. Oh, and HAIL TO THE KING, BABY!!!!
Jack because I wanted to see some cool, explosive, awesome robot arm action. Sure, there might be some casualties, and it's probably the bad decision... but explosions and psycho robot drones tho.
Fiona. Jack killed Roland, tourtured his daughter, kidnapped Lillith, scooped a mans eyes out with a spoon and killed Bloodwing. I haven't played the Pre-Sequel yet so I haven't even counted that yet.
Jack. I know better, but the guy has a natural 20 in charisma. I can't help it.
Plus that giddy little laugh he does when you side with him is just so perfect.
Well, technically Fiona used a spork, and the victim in question was helpless and catatonic. Jack was attacked by some madman with a spoon! It was self-defence from an unprovoked (unprovoked, I tell you!) assault on his person! So tell me, who's the REAL monster, here?
"casually ignores the part of Jack's story about burning an entire town to the ground and laughing as the poor bastard who'd had his eyes gouged out flailed around screaming while his children watched"
Fiona's plan was shit, it was literally "Let's throw a grenade". The Jack choice also seems to move the story forward with the whole starting of the transformation into Handsome Rhys.
Well, if you think about it, it was humour AND reason over YOLO.
That was basically Fiona's big plan. Let's just toss this random grenade… more looking thing that may or may not work, and hope it all works out. At least Jack's plan would work. The only worry I had with him was whether or not he'd just murder everyone for kicks once he saved Rhys' life. Oh, and HAIL TO THE KING, BABY!!!!
I chose Fiona on my second playthrough, just to see what would happen. She seemed so confident that I assumed there was more to her plan than what was immediately apparent to Rhys and Jack.
There. Was. Not.
It actually got worse. She went from threatening to destroy something they needed (and quite possibly ending their lives) to ACTUALLY following through on that threat. "facepalms"
Crazy Pandorans and their complete lack of self-preservation instincts.......
Fiona's plan was shit, it was literally "Let's throw a grenade". The Jack choice also seems to move the story forward with the whole starting of the transformation into Handsome Rhys.
So... It means that's the choice of the most hardcore fans?
Though I dunno all those % are tricky, I have 3 saves and chose Jack in 2 of them. But if it had to be only one, I'd chose Fiona. Cause I'm pretending to be a "good person". xD
I chose Fiona on my second playthrough, just to see what would happen. She seemed so confident that I assumed there was more to her plan tha… moren what was immediately apparent to Rhys and Jack.
There. Was. Not.
It actually got worse. She went from threatening to destroy something they needed (and quite possibly ending their lives) to ACTUALLY following through on that threat. "facepalms"
Crazy Pandorans and their complete lack of self-preservation instincts.......
You know, TPS can make you hate him even more, but since you've already played BL2 it probably just won't change anything. He's not a "good guy", he never was. The others are also to blame, I mean we can say that Roland, Lilith and others deserved it but they also had a reason to do all they've done.
Jack. I'm going in with the intention of Rhys being a self-serving coward and I just don't see any reason he'd trust Fiona yet, anyway.
I'm hoping this blows up in his face big time. Then maybe I can see about Rhys changing away from being a jerk.
Considering that Rhys has cybernetic implants coming out of his every orifice and that they don't know how an EMP would affect little Gorty? I should think not. And even IF it saved THEM, that doesn't solve their Vaughn/Sasha problems.
Like Jack said, "SHE DOESN'T EVEN HAVE A PLAN!".
Whatever, either way it works out, obviously (even if the way it works out is Jack just TAKING control and doing his own thing, after Fiona's plan fails epicly).
This^
Also, Jack looks super pissed off if you choose Fiona. I'm way more worried about what he'd do then than what he may do if you choose his plan initially. You don't fuck with Jack.
I just played the Fiona ending and it was SO underwhelming! Like, really? That's it? That's the plan?!!
#TeamJack all the way (until it completely bites me in the ass 90 seconds in)...
Considering that Rhys has cybernetic implants coming out of his every orifice and that they don't know how an EMP would affect little Gorty?… more I should think not. And even IF it saved THEM, that doesn't solve their Vaughn/Sasha problems.
Like Jack said, "SHE DOESN'T EVEN HAVE A PLAN!".
Whatever, either way it works out, obviously (even if the way it works out is Jack just TAKING control and doing his own thing, after Fiona's plan fails epicly).
Yeah... all this time later and I'm still pissed off about the way that things went down with Roland. Looking back on it, that was probably a huge part of why I didn't choose Jack.
Jack because I wanted to see some cool, explosive, awesome robot arm action. Sure, there might be some casualties, and it's probably the bad decision... but explosions and psycho robot drones tho.
He does actually. It looks as though he somehow manages to gain control of Rhys' nervous system, because their actions are completely synchronised at the end.
Besides, we don't even know if all three grenades were flash grenades. The one Fiona threw might be EMP (then Rhys is fucked) or explosive one (then literally everyone is fucked).
I just played the Fiona ending and it was SO underwhelming! Like, really? That's it? That's the plan?!!
#TeamJack all the way (until it completely bites me in the ass 90 seconds in)...
Trust Fiona ending since it fits better for the story I'm creating for my game. Also, it a choice between a Girl that Rhys just met and have been treated as a Friend/ally or Jack who is crazy, kills people for fun and issues, and has a Hero complex.
I trusted Jack initially. Then I went back and played through Fiona's just to see what would happen. I preferred Jack's plan way more; it was more fun, and it made more sense to me.
I did trust Jack, but i don't know, i saw both decisions tho, picking Jack, it looks like his plan is going to work more likely, but the fact that he controls Rhys, is bad just because he can do what he wants, and picking Fiona, well her plan might wont work, but trusting her is kind off better because after all YOU play her and she will save them probably because Sasha is in troublr, what do you think about this?
Trust Fiona ending since it fits better for the story I'm creating for my game. Also, it a choice between a Girl that Rhys just met and have been treated as a Friend/ally or Jack who is crazy, kills people for fun and issues, and has a Hero complex.
Jack's ending gave me a serious adrenaline rush. That eccentric electronic music, Jack's shady, erratic, and generally badass behavior, Rhys' incredible hesitance as he puts the life of his friends on the line while sacrificing control over his body... It was awesome.
I looked up Fiona's ending later and laughed. Weirdass fiddle music and a one-liner.
I trusted Jack initially. Then I went back and played through Fiona's just to see what would happen. I preferred Jack's plan way more; it was more fun, and it made more sense to me.
Jack's ending gave me a serious adrenaline rush. That eccentric electronic music, Jack's shady, erratic, and generally badass behavior, Rhys… more' incredible hesitance as he puts the life of his friends on the line while sacrificing control over his body... It was awesome.
I looked up Fiona's ending later and laughed. Weirdass fiddle music and a one-liner.
Jack's ending gave me a serious adrenaline rush. That eccentric electronic music, Jack's shady, erratic, and generally badass behavior, Rhys… more' incredible hesitance as he puts the life of his friends on the line while sacrificing control over his body... It was awesome.
I looked up Fiona's ending later and laughed. Weirdass fiddle music and a one-liner.
Comments
'Thought'
We know that it's a flash grenade, but Rhys doesn't (at least, in my playthrough). So, to him it still looks like Fiona is holding an explosive grenade. That's another reason why I picked Jack - Fiona's plan seems pretty much suicidal, and I don't like to put my friends in danger.
Well, if you think about it, it was humour AND reason over YOLO.
That was basically Fiona's big plan. Let's just toss this random grenade looking thing that may or may not work, and hope it all works out. At least Jack's plan would work. The only worry I had with him was whether or not he'd just murder everyone for kicks once he saved Rhys' life. Oh, and HAIL TO THE KING, BABY!!!!
I'm kinda surprised only 35% chose to trust Jack
Jack because I wanted to see some cool, explosive, awesome robot arm action. Sure, there might be some casualties, and it's probably the bad decision... but explosions and psycho robot drones tho.
Srsly? xD And I'm surprised it's 35%, that's still a lot.
Fiona. Jack killed Roland, tourtured his daughter, kidnapped Lillith, scooped a mans eyes out with a spoon and killed Bloodwing. I haven't played the Pre-Sequel yet so I haven't even counted that yet.
#NeverForget
I chose first Fiona then Jack, Fiona seems to be the "right" choice but Jack seem to be much funnier and interesting choice.
You should play TPS, it might change your perception of him...
Waiting for The Handsome Collection to come out first.
Dem hand gesture's. Freaking majestic. Plus it will be incredibly entertaining to see Dumb and Dumber's faces when the entire facility turns on them.
Of course, then we'll have to contend with Jack's tendency to get carried away with his murderin'.......but a problem for another minute, right?
In fairness both Fiona and Jack have done that now xD
Immediately after the episode came out, the ratio was something like 20% chose Fiona.
Yeah, when I first played the Jack choice was over 70%!
Well, technically Fiona used a spork, and the victim in question was helpless and catatonic. Jack was attacked by some madman with a spoon! It was self-defence from an unprovoked (unprovoked, I tell you!) assault on his person! So tell me, who's the REAL monster, here?
"casually ignores the part of Jack's story about burning an entire town to the ground and laughing as the poor bastard who'd had his eyes gouged out flailed around screaming while his children watched"
Fiona's plan was shit, it was literally "Let's throw a grenade". The Jack choice also seems to move the story forward with the whole starting of the transformation into Handsome Rhys.
I chose Fiona on my second playthrough, just to see what would happen. She seemed so confident that I assumed there was more to her plan than what was immediately apparent to Rhys and Jack.
There. Was. Not.
It actually got worse. She went from threatening to destroy something they needed (and quite possibly ending their lives) to ACTUALLY following through on that threat. "facepalms"
Crazy Pandorans and their complete lack of self-preservation instincts.......
So... It means that's the choice of the most hardcore fans?
Though I dunno all those % are tricky, I have 3 saves and chose Jack in 2 of them. But if it had to be only one, I'd chose Fiona. Cause I'm pretending to be a "good person". xD
It is probably an EMP but that doesn't really help the situation.
Or it can make it worse. Once you realize the things he's done during TPS and supposedely even before that...
You know, TPS can make you hate him even more, but since you've already played BL2 it probably just won't change anything. He's not a "good guy", he never was. The others are also to blame, I mean we can say that Roland, Lilith and others deserved it but they also had a reason to do all they've done.
the kind has regain his throne
rhys is a jerk only if you chose to be a jerk
Considering that Rhys has cybernetic implants coming out of his every orifice and that they don't know how an EMP would affect little Gorty? I should think not. And even IF it saved THEM, that doesn't solve their Vaughn/Sasha problems.
Like Jack said, "SHE DOESN'T EVEN HAVE A PLAN!".
Whatever, either way it works out, obviously (even if the way it works out is Jack just TAKING control and doing his own thing, after Fiona's plan fails epicly).
I trusted Jack.
It seemed like the smarter thing to do.
I just played the Fiona ending and it was SO underwhelming! Like, really? That's it? That's the plan?!!
#TeamJack all the way (until it completely bites me in the ass 90 seconds in)...
This^
Also, Jack looks super pissed off if you choose Fiona. I'm way more worried about what he'd do then than what he may do if you choose his plan initially. You don't fuck with Jack.
We already know Jack will get control eventually so I think it's best to get on the good side of the psychotic murderer inside my head early on.
Yeah... all this time later and I'm still pissed off about the way that things went down with Roland.
Looking back on it, that was probably a huge part of why I didn't choose Jack.
Mr. Torgue, I didn't know you visited the Telltale Forums.
He does actually. It looks as though he somehow manages to gain control of Rhys' nervous system, because their actions are completely synchronised at the end.
Besides, we don't even know if all three grenades were flash grenades. The one Fiona threw might be EMP (then Rhys is fucked) or explosive one (then literally everyone is fucked).
Trust Fiona ending since it fits better for the story I'm creating for my game. Also, it a choice between a Girl that Rhys just met and have been treated as a Friend/ally or Jack who is crazy, kills people for fun and issues, and has a Hero complex.
I trusted Jack initially. Then I went back and played through Fiona's just to see what would happen. I preferred Jack's plan way more; it was more fun, and it made more sense to me.
I did trust Jack, but i don't know, i saw both decisions tho, picking Jack, it looks like his plan is going to work more likely, but the fact that he controls Rhys, is bad just because he can do what he wants, and picking Fiona, well her plan might wont work, but trusting her is kind off better because after all YOU play her and she will save them probably because Sasha is in troublr, what do you think about this?
Keep in mind, Jack is Rhys' hero, and is reknowned for his intellect. Choosing him is a big risk, but he actually had a plan.
It's far from out of character for Rhys to choose Jack.
Jack's ending gave me a serious adrenaline rush. That eccentric electronic music, Jack's shady, erratic, and generally badass behavior, Rhys' incredible hesitance as he puts the life of his friends on the line while sacrificing control over his body... It was awesome.
I looked up Fiona's ending later and laughed. Weirdass fiddle music and a one-liner.
I laughed at her ending, too... after watching Jack's awesomeness, hers was pretty anticlimactic.
I trusted Jack too, simply because I didn't want to owe Fiona anything. And I kinda wanted to show her I can do stuff too.
I love that the whole thing just inexplicably transforms into a highland jig.