The Newly Regenerated Doctor Who Thread

16768707273103

Comments

  • edited September 2012
    Friar wrote: »
    And I loved the fact that Matts last lines in the Tardis mirrored those of the end of Season 6. Right down to the emphasis on syllables. And I like the fact that Stephen Moffat is slowly retconning the series.
    Ah yes, one other element I didn't like. They have got to stop being so blatant with the show's title.
    Dalek-lady saying it was fine, but then you got the chorus of Daleks, and the the Doctor himself...
    Too much. WAY too much.
  • edited September 2012
    Ah yes, one other element I didn't like. They have got to stop being so blatant with the show's title.
    Dalek-lady saying it was fine, but then you got the chorus of Daleks, and the the Doctor himself...
    Too much. WAY too much.

    It's his name. Get over it. :p

    Also; Mitchell and Webb will be playing Robots next week! That's very exciting.
  • edited September 2012
    You know
    Now the Daleks don't know who The Doctor is they might take him to the Fields Of Tranzalor and ask him Doctor Who?
  • edited September 2012
    Dalek: EGGS EGGS EGGS AHH!!
    Dr: Do you know whats happening..theres never been a Time Lord Dalek meta crisis before
    Dalek: BECAUSE THERE CAN'T!!!
    Dr: Im sorry im so sorry
    Dalek: NOO NOO EMERGENCY NOOOO!!!!..IDENTIFY YOUR SELF!!
  • edited September 2012
    coolsome wrote: »
    I guess
    Clara Oswin isnt the new companion after all
    ?
    Why not? The character in it last night was called Oswin Oswald, wasn't she?

    I thought "Asylum of the Daleks" was a bit on the superficial side. And as far as making Daleks scary again, does taking away their guns really do it?!
  • edited September 2012
    OK, I'm sorry if this is going to make me sound dumb or uninformed but... why are the Daleks still around? Aren't they supposed to be dead? I know that during the 9th and 10th Doctor runs, there was always an excuse for there to be more Daleks. Did I miss something with the 11th that explains how the Daleks are back in full force?
  • edited September 2012
    OK, I'm sorry if this is going to make me sound dumb or uninformed but... why are the Daleks still around? Aren't they supposed to be dead? I know that during the 9th and 10th Doctor runs, there was always an excuse for there to be more Daleks. Did I miss something with the 11th that explains how the Daleks are back in full force?

    At the of Victory of the Daleks, Doctor Who lets them go to form an army so he can save Earth (which they'd destroy if he did otherwise)
  • edited September 2012
    Ribs wrote: »
    At the [end] of Victory of the Daleks, the Doctor lets them go to form an army so he can save Earth (which they'd destroy if he did otherwise)
    Fixed that for ya.
  • edited September 2012
    Fixed that for ya.

    You only made it more vague! It could be any Doctor, but I specified it to Doctor Who himself.
  • edited September 2012
    ...but that's his name. The Doctor. It's not Doctor Who, no matter what Mr Eccleston thinks.
  • edited September 2012
    Hey, look, a prequel to Asylum of the Daleks! (US Only)
  • edited September 2012
    Ribs wrote: »
    You only made it more vague! It could be any Doctor, but I specified it to Doctor Who himself.

    There are probably several Doctor Who's around. There's at my local GP called Doctor Ware, which is close enough.
    Ribs wrote: »
    Hey, look, a prequel to Asylum of the Daleks! (US Only)

    That sounds just like the pre credits sequence...
  • edited September 2012
    Friar wrote: »
    There are probably several Doctor Who's around. There's at my local GP called Doctor Ware, which is close enough.

    Its obviously
    The Master
    .
  • edited September 2012
    Friar wrote: »
    That sounds just like the pre credits sequence...

    Well, it isn't.

    Edit: Neil Gaiman announced during his Hugo speech that he's doing another episode this year. Word is it's a Cyberman episode.
  • edited September 2012
    Oh, fuck YES.
  • edited September 2012
    Here's a trailer for Dinosaurs on a Spaceship, featuring a line from David Mitchell's character: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWdKU752rK4&feature=youtube_gdata_player
  • edited September 2012
    I just hope the amount of big stars in the episode isn't compensating for a lack of a decent plot.
  • edited September 2012
    Friar wrote: »
    I just hope the amount of big stars in the episode isn't compensating for a lack of a decent plot.

    It's not really a lot, I think. I don't think any of them are anywhere near as famous as Michael Sheen, and that was barely publicized last season! :P
  • edited September 2012
    Ribs wrote: »
    It's not really a lot, I think. I don't think any of them are anywhere near as famous as Michael Sheen, and that was barely publicized last season! :P

    Well In terms of recognisable voices/faces, I'd say David Mitchel, 'Ron's Dad' and 'Mr. Flich' are pretty high up there. And Matt smith is a pretty big star too.

    Also, I actually didn't recognise the name of Michael Sheen, and had to look it up.
  • edited September 2012
    Friar wrote: »
    Well In terms of recognisable voices/faces, I'd say David Mitchel, 'Ron's Dad' and 'Mr. Flich' are pretty high up there. And Matt smith is a pretty big star too.

    Also, I actually didn't recognise the name of Michael Sheen, and had to look it up.

    How did you not recognize him? He's played Tony Blair in about any true-life story featuring Tony Blair you can imagine!
  • edited September 2012
    Ribs wrote: »
    How did you not recognize him? He's played Tony Blair in about any true-life story featuring Tony Blair you can imagine!

    I've only seen one drama based on Tony Blair, and that had Robert Lindsay as the leading man. That was several years ago too.
  • edited September 2012
    Here's next week's movie poster promo image:
    7893544378_e5fb550bac_c.jpg

    Looks absolutely magical.
  • edited September 2012
    It looks more like a quickly cobbled together Photoshop job to me.
  • edited September 2012
    It looks more like a quickly cobbled together Photoshop job to me.

    Yes, but look how happy he is! He's hanging out with the same rag-tag group that got rid of Adric!
  • edited September 2012
    Ribs wrote: »
    Yes, but look how happy he is! He's hanging out with the same rag-tag group that got rid of Adric!

    With the Death star in the back drop!

    Also, the Asylum of the Daleks Prequel for non-USians.
  • edited September 2012
    Behind the scenes. Of Asylum of the Daleks.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mmxKlUYjKuA
  • edited September 2012
    You know what they should do? Make a whole bunch of those clips for each episode Enough to fill a 30 minute spinoff show. Oh wait. DAMN YOU BBC.
  • edited September 2012
    Out of nowhere, my online rental service has told me that my next rental will be The Eternity Clock, so expect to hear my thoughts on it later this week. I've really not heard good things though, so I'm not holding much hope.
  • edited September 2012
    What if the Daleks final end came in there first episode "The Daleks" and everything else is just there early timeline.
  • edited September 2012
    coolsome wrote: »
    What if the Daleks final end came in there first episode "The Daleks" and everything else is just there early timeline.

    Well, "Planet of the Daleks" is unambigously set after "The Daleks" for the Thals if not for anybody else. Oh, and for the Doctor.

    In other news, according to the Telegraph website "The King's Demons" is lost!

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/doctor-who/9528099/Doctor-Whos-best-historical-figures.html

    For a million pounds I can supply a copy of this. I'll even throw in "Timelash!"

    And those rubbishy Adventure Games are coming to Steam -

    http://www.doctorwhonews.net/2012/09/gunpowder-plot-game-070912112008.html
  • edited September 2012
    And those rubbishy Adventure Games are coming to Steam -

    http://www.doctorwhonews.net/2012/09/gunpowder-plot-game-070912112008.html
    Will they (or IT, rather, since there's only one mentioned) be free to British users? Will I care? Survey says...

    bygraves_duhduhh.jpg

    Oh, and remember I said I was getting PS3 version of The Eternity Clock as a rental? Well, it's arrived, and I was going to play it. But then it said it needed a patch. "Fine", thinks I, "I gather it needed one anyway".

    THE PATCH IS A FUCKING GIGABYTE.

    So I'll actually be able to start playing it in about three hours. Jesus Christ... Bad omen or what?
  • edited September 2012

    THE PATCH IS A FUCKING GIGABYTE.

    So I'll actually be able to start playing it in about three hours. Jesus Christ... Bad omen or what?

    A gigabtye!? But how!? that game makes TTG games look like Quantic Dream ones!
  • edited September 2012
    I genuinely don't know how the patch can be so big. Maybe I'm actually downloading the game itself? Who knows. It certainly doesn't inspire much confidence when the first thing I have to do is sit on my arse for three hours.

    God I miss the days when console games didn't have patches.
  • edited September 2012
    OK, so here we go. Finally. Jotting down notes as I go.

    - Taking a long time to get to the main menu. As in, a good 10 seconds of black screen in between the logos.
    - I don't think there's drop-in drop-out co-op - you have to select it when starting / continuing a game.
    - You can adjust puzzle difficulty? How's that work then? Oh well, I guess we'll see.
    - OK, plot. The TARDIS has just gone nuts and landed somewhere. I have to walk outside and... my God, is that the walk animation? Why do Matt's shoulders seem so stiff? That's just embarrassing.
    - LOADING.
    - I'm in the Bank of England, apparently. And the TARDIS has vanished. How's that work? I can use the Sonic Screwdriver to scan stuff by just aiming it with the right control stick, which is very Doctor-y. Wonder how long it'll take to become annoying.
    - In order to open a locked door, I have to aim with the right control stick, hold R2 to initiate a minigame and then use the right control stick again to alter the pattern of a waveform to match one already displayed. I'm surprised how clunky this feels.
    - To reach the first collectable hat, I had to clamber along a pipe. Once again, the animations looks terrible. Poor Matt Smith... His arms will never look right in these games, will they?
    - OK, the music's starting to annoy me now. It's that theme that plays when Matt Smith does something particularly awesome (Every Star, Every Planet)... and it's all throughout this first level. I know it's a good theme, but really?
    - RE: Character animations. You do know that when a character runs, their coat does tend to billow behind them if it's undone? Hell, even I knew that when I did my Prince of Persia mod. Why is it so hard for professional developers to get this right?
    runleft.gif (see?)
    - Ooo, I got a trophy for scanning a bunch of objects with the Sonic. I like that.
    - A nice bit of puzzling here with crates. I don't normally like crate puzzles, but it was tricky without needing me to move the crates too much so it was well within acceptable limits.
    - The Doctor's quips are actually quite nice. Very Doctor-y.
    - There's a few mysteries strewn around here and there, including a crypt with an energy signature - the Doctor's, in fact. He's been here before, apparently. The plot has me intrigued.
    - ...and we're with River now. Oh dear. I've never been the biggest fan of Alex Kingston as River Song, and I wasn't looking forward to her sections. Is she... is she trying to be sexy? Oh dear.
    - Sneaking behind guards? Ducking into doorways? Oh DEAR.
    - So to take out a guard, you sneak up behind them and... kiss them. Well, it's in character, I suppose...
    - Why are the guards Scottish? Seriously, they have a Scottish lilt! It's weird!
    - This sneaking mechanic is very frustrating. Once you kiss someone, they do something, usually open a door. But the second time you do this, there's another guard patrolling, and it's hard to tell when the patrolling guard can see you and when he can't, and there's no nearby cover to duck behind while you're waiting for the kissable guard to open the door for you, so there's a damn good chance you'll get caught before you get the chance to escape. The checkpoints aren't far apart, but it's still a pain.
    - FUCKING STEALTH SECTIONS CAN FUCKING FUCK OFF.
    - Being able to move the camera left or right would be a massive help in these stealth sections. But then, not being forced to do stealth sections at all would be even better. OH WELL.
    - Waugh! That camera shift as I change corridors was NOT smooth.
    - OK, there's a puzzle that's basically Domino's. Only they don't explain it very well, and the puzzle's not very well designed. Grr.
    - ...and apparently I've missed two of River's Diary pages. Have to replay the level to find them.
    - NON-SKIPPABLE CUTSCENES ARE BULLSHIT. Someday developers will learn this.
    - Yep, replaying that Domino minigame just re-established how frustrating it is.
    - So, the Doctor and River are met and are having an in-level conversation, and the lines appear to have been recorded at different times, because they don't seem to flow together that well, especially when River has two and they don't mesh at ALL. Kinda annoying, but not a gamebreaker or anything.
    - Ah, but this is! There's a two-person pushable object that River and the Doctor need to push in tandem, and once you push the block all the way to one side, the AI controlled partner just stands there and won't let you pull it back. So if you push it the wrong way in hopes of finding a hidden hat, then you've fucked the game up and you need to quit and reload your game to fix it. Outstanding.
    - Blimey, it takes forever to climb up a ladder.
    - CYBERMEN! They were always my favourite monster. But that is NOT the right voice! Oof.
    - Another minigame. I won it somehow, but buggered if I know HOW. I wish the explanations of these things were automatic rather than needing you to actually prompt them, given how convoluted they are.
    - REALLY liking these quips. They've gotten that right, if nothing else.
    - Did... did the Doctor just mention the Yeti Intelligence? Oh, be still my beating heart!
    - Right, so as you may have guessed, I'm in the Underground, and I'm running from Cybermen. So I have to complete a puzzle I don't quite understand, climb across a pipe (three times) and then have River shoot a door open, all while the Cybermen are marching. And guess what? The game doesn't tell you how to get River to shoot things! So if you can't figure it out in the 10 seconds or so you get via a flawless run, then you have to do it all over again. FUCK YOU GAME.
    - Oh, for fuck's sake, now the AI partner's fucking up and not crossing the pipe. Which means I'll have to do the section AGAIN. How the fuck does a game this buggy get released? GOD!
    - Ah. Apparently River fires whenever the hell she feels like it. GRR...
    - Oh, and one more minigame to boot. This one's self-explanatory, but there's not enough time in each round to actually do it half the time, which is VERY frustrating.

    I kind of stopped playing around this point.

    It's an interesting game, but deeply, DEEPLY flawed in its execution, with a large focus on stealth gameplay and minigames that aren't properly explained, as well as glitchy AI and frustrating timed elements. I'll keep at it if only to see how completely insane the plot gets, but I probably won't enjoy it.
  • edited September 2012
    Did the Doctor just
    kill someone in cold blood who was begging for there life!?
    !!
  • edited September 2012
    Solomon could have ejected the object being tracked. But essentially, yes. The Doctor effectively killed a very nasty person who not only wounded one of his 'gang' but also committed mass murder.

    Same old argument about it being too short, but otherwise absolutely fantastic. Brilliant episode.
  • edited September 2012
    I'm not debating that
    he didn't deserved it cos I was hoping he would die it just that 11 is going down the dark path 10 did near the end of his life.
  • edited September 2012
    I see what you're saying. It's like what Donna said. The Doctor needs someone to stop him, and without the Ponds around, he doesn't have anyone to do that, so he tends to end up being rather dark as a result. I'm guessing the new companion will help reverse that, however she comes into being.

    Also a plus, I could understand most of the dialogue this time round! Huzzah!
  • edited September 2012
    Mitchell and Webb
    where awesome in this!
  • edited September 2012
    They were also hardly in it, which is a shame. But they were fun incidental characters, I agree.
Sign in to comment in this discussion.