I would have taken her with us in the R.V. regardless of who (Not clementine) she killed, the only thing I regret is not being able to talk her out of taking the R.V. or the fact that she left me.
But that doesn't mean im happy with who she killed or that I agree with it of course, I would have prefered the option to stop her entirely.
It makes me sad that darley died but I would prefer they die over Ben, he being a teenager and all.
Even though Lilly killed (Well she didn't really kill Doug, Doug accidentally killed himself but same thing) I took her with me because I felt sorry for her, even though Doug died. But If Lilly killed Ben and Doug didn't push him out of the way (That's how Doug died) then I would of liked Lilly even more, because I hate Ben, I never trusted him, and I was right!
Can't there be an "I don't know" option in the poll? She still killed a member of the group, a scared kid at that, but we didn't have nearly as much time with Ben as we did with Doug and Carley.
Red Panda, no offense mate but do you have to make a thread for every single thing? I feel like having the same discussion over and over and over again just because there are 50 threads that are almost similar.
As for the topic, no matter who she killed, I would've always taken her with me. Even now I view her as an alley.
Saying that you would take her if she killed Ben and leave her because she killed Carley/Doug sounds like the biggest hypocrisy ever.
Can't there be an "I don't know" option in the poll? She still killed a member of the group, a scared kid at that, but we didn't have nearly as much time with Ben as we did with Doug and Carley.
I can't change the poll but even if I could I wouldn't add it because in the game you would have to make a choice. There's no "I don't know" option. Besides, if people aren't sure they can just abstain from voting.
Red Panda, no offense mate but do you have to make a thread for every single thing? I feel like having the same discussion over and over and over again just because there are 50 threads that are almost similar.
No offense taken and yes, I do, for every single thing.
I'm sorry for making you re-discuss topics. I can see how stressed it's making you. I feel horrible. Really.
I figured Ben was the traitor even before the bandit attack on the motel, so I wouldn't have left her if she killed him, although I prefer exile to execution. Carley, on the other hand was killed without discussion or evidence and mainly because she pissed Lilly off, which is why I left her because, like Kenny said, if she would kill Carley out of anger then how do I know she won't kill him? I don't know whether I'd have left her or not if it was Doug I had with the group instead of Carley, since his death is so different and more of an accident, but I haven't done a playthrough where I saved him yet.
Other than if she kills Clem, I will take Lilly with me on the RV regardless of who she kills. Last time it was Carley, this time Ben maybe next time Kenny......Lilly is coming with me on the RV every time.
In the case of Clem, the screen would turn red and will say Lee died. Then restart. I hope Lilly does not shoot Clem because then I will be stuck in a programming loop and the game would be over.
No offense taken and yes, I do, for every single thing.
I'm sorry for making you re-discuss topics. I can see how stressed it's making you. I feel horrible. Really.
By the way, where else is this being discussed?
Nowhere but it is easier to continue it in an already existing thread instead of always making new ones.
Kiel555, I don't think Lilly would ever hurt a child willingly. She even takes care of Clem on some occasions so, no, this is not a possible scenario. Don't worry :P
People seem to make Lilly as if she's killing people for fun. Just because you all love Carley doesn't mean that Lilly couldn't have suspected her of being the traitor.
Yep, I'd have left her there. Ben made a mistake and he'll have to live with the consequences, that doesn't make him a traitor and it certainly doesn't mean he deserves to be killed. If he wanted to actually betray the group then no one would have made it out of that inn alive.
I would leave anyone who took the decision over life and death of a group member into his/her own hands. I would even have left Kenny, had I been given the chance, after what he did with Larry.
Can't there be an "I don't know" option in the poll? She still killed a member of the group, a scared kid at that, but we didn't have nearly as much time with Ben as we did with Doug and Carley.
Might as well be the 'game over' option as your group starves to death in your indecision lol
Yea lets demonize Lily for
1) Hitting the bullseye and zeroing in on the real threat to the group
2) having the balls to take action on it while the majority of you would still be talking about it while the badits rifle through the rest of your belongings and the zombies kill you all.
I figured Ben was the traitor even before the bandit attack on the motel, so I wouldn't have left her if she killed him, although I prefer exile to execution. Carley, on the other hand was killed without discussion or evidence and mainly because she pissed Lilly off, which is why I left her because, like Kenny said, if she would kill Carley out of anger then how do I know she won't kill him? I don't know whether I'd have left her or not if it was Doug I had with the group instead of Carley, since his death is so different and more of an accident, but I haven't done a playthrough where I saved him yet.
Do you really think of Ben as a traitor? In his own way he was trying to save the group. The bandits wouldn't have just left everyone alone if they weren't getting something in return. In actuality he bought the group time to finsh repairing the RV.
I left Lily cuz she killed. Not because she killed Carley or Doug. Because she killed. Ben turning out to be the traitor doesn't change that. You all have to remember that at the time of the murder, we weren't aware that Ben was the traitor, and frankly, it wouldn't have mattered to me. I understood why he did what he did, and while I will be a little more wary of him, I don't plan on getting him killed either.
I left Lily cuz she killed. Not because she killed Carley or Doug. Because she killed. Ben turning out to be the traitor doesn't change that. You all have to remember that at the time of the murder, we weren't aware that Ben was the traitor, and frankly, it wouldn't have mattered to me. I understood why he did what he did, and while I will be a little more wary of him, I don't plan on getting him killed either.
Would you have done EP3 the same way as Ben, in his shoes?
Would you have done EP3 the same way as Ben, in his shoes?
I'd like to think not, but I have clue how I would react to that situation in general. However, I also would like to think I wouldn't have killed Ben had I been in Lily's position.
I'd like to think not, but I have clue how I would react to that situation in general. However, I also would like to think I wouldn't have killed Ben had I been in Lily's position.
Would you have made that deal and kept it secret- thats the 10,000 question
I got a question: Can we all stop using the word question? I mean, I know there are alot of questions on this thread right now but really, ask yourself this question. Are all these questions really necessary? I mean, Im not trying to question the status quo but really, this is a little crazy, and it raises the question: Is this guy trolling us right now?
I don't know how I'd really feel, I mean its easy to say one thing but in the real situation after three months of getting to know Carley/Doug and defending their lives as they defended yours... things would be different.
I would probably have killed Lily on the spot, I don't like losing loose ends with people who are dangerous like the St. Johns brothers (I killed both of them.) Ironically this is very Lily minded.
Morality is just not as important as survival in a hostile environment. One thing that contrasts Lee Everett and Rick Grimes is the fact that Rick always taught Carl that survival comes first, while Lee (regardless of player interaction) guides Clem to try and be moral when there is no room for it.
Lily was just a bad egg, she was going insane and had to be taken care of. Giving away supplies is traitorous but it is not murder. The situation could have been handled later on maybe on the way to Savannah or before they got on the train.
Morality is just not as important as survival in a hostile environment. One thing that contrasts Lee Everett and Rick Grimes is the fact that Rick always taught Carl that survival comes first, while Lee (regardless of player interaction) guides Clem to try and be moral when there is no room for it.
Comments
But that doesn't mean im happy with who she killed or that I agree with it of course, I would have prefered the option to stop her entirely.
It makes me sad that darley died but I would prefer they die over Ben, he being a teenager and all.
But only because I too suspected Ben.
As for the topic, no matter who she killed, I would've always taken her with me. Even now I view her as an alley.
Saying that you would take her if she killed Ben and leave her because she killed Carley/Doug sounds like the biggest hypocrisy ever.
I can't change the poll but even if I could I wouldn't add it because in the game you would have to make a choice. There's no "I don't know" option. Besides, if people aren't sure they can just abstain from voting.
No offense taken and yes, I do, for every single thing.
I'm sorry for making you re-discuss topics. I can see how stressed it's making you. I feel horrible. Really.
By the way, where else is this being discussed?
In the case of Clem, the screen would turn red and will say Lee died. Then restart. I hope Lilly does not shoot Clem because then I will be stuck in a programming loop and the game would be over.
Nowhere but it is easier to continue it in an already existing thread instead of always making new ones.
Kiel555, I don't think Lilly would ever hurt a child willingly. She even takes care of Clem on some occasions so, no, this is not a possible scenario. Don't worry :P
People seem to make Lilly as if she's killing people for fun. Just because you all love Carley doesn't mean that Lilly couldn't have suspected her of being the traitor.
Might as well be the 'game over' option as your group starves to death in your indecision lol
How?
1) Hitting the bullseye and zeroing in on the real threat to the group
2) having the balls to take action on it while the majority of you would still be talking about it while the badits rifle through the rest of your belongings and the zombies kill you all.
Do you really think of Ben as a traitor? In his own way he was trying to save the group. The bandits wouldn't have just left everyone alone if they weren't getting something in return. In actuality he bought the group time to finsh repairing the RV.
Would you have done EP3 the same way as Ben, in his shoes?
Would you really have done EP3 the same way as Lilly, in her shoes?
I'd like to think not, but I have clue how I would react to that situation in general. However, I also would like to think I wouldn't have killed Ben had I been in Lily's position.
Present company included
Dont you know you cant answer a persons question with another question?!
Now, please, allow me to administer my litmus test to the presented party
Would you have made that deal and kept it secret- thats the 10,000 question
I was just asking a simple question
/halo
Why is it he didn't answer my question?
I would probably have killed Lily on the spot, I don't like losing loose ends with people who are dangerous like the St. Johns brothers (I killed both of them.) Ironically this is very Lily minded.
Morality is just not as important as survival in a hostile environment. One thing that contrasts Lee Everett and Rick Grimes is the fact that Rick always taught Carl that survival comes first, while Lee (regardless of player interaction) guides Clem to try and be moral when there is no room for it.
Lily was just a bad egg, she was going insane and had to be taken care of. Giving away supplies is traitorous but it is not murder. The situation could have been handled later on maybe on the way to Savannah or before they got on the train.
I like this guy already, good post
Call me maybe?