Doctor Who: Series 5 (/31) Discussion

2456721

Comments

  • edited April 2010
    I loved Matt Smith, to be honest. Sure, yeah, David Tennant was great, and I'm sad that he had to leave, but it's not like it's the first time that's happened, right? I just loved how crazy he can be, but it's a different kind of crazy than Tennant's Doctor. It's like he's goofy and magnificent at the same time.

    Also, while I've never noticed it before, now I realized why Steven Moffat being put in charge is such a relief to fans; he's just that good. The Beast Below was such a great episode, beginning with several things that looked irrelevant to each other, but tied together neatly at the end, just like The Girl In The Fireplace (which apparently also contained references about The Doctor's true name and why he can't say it).

    Oh, also, some people called it season 5, some 31, but it was actually produced as season 1. So, yeah, major change.
  • edited April 2010
    Matts Doctor reminds me a bit of Selvester McCoys Doctor
  • edited April 2010
    Matts Doctor reminds me a bit of Selvester McCoys Doctor

    I haven't really seen any of Sylvester's episodes. I saw the movie, but he was dead for most of that, and i saw one serial about Cheetah people (which i thought was awful!). Any reccomendations of particular episodes he was in?
  • edited April 2010
    tredlow wrote: »
    Oh, also, some people called it season 5, some 31, but it was actually produced as season 1. So, yeah, major change.

    It's going to become confusing if they keep resetting it.
    "Hey, have you seen the latest season of Dr Who? You know, season 2 aka 8 aka 12 aka 38?"
  • edited April 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    I haven't really seen any of Sylvester's episodes. I saw the movie, but he was dead for most of that, and i saw one serial about Cheetah people (which i thought was awful!). Any reccomendations of particular episodes he was in?

    Remembrance of the Daleks, Curse of Fenric and Battlefeild are my fav from his era
  • edited April 2010
    The Doctor and Pond continue to be excellent in the second episode. Like others have said; the story probably would have worked better as 2 parts. My favorite bit had to be the part that leads into next week though.
    Churchill calling the Doctor was hilarious.
    I can't wait for that episode.
  • edited April 2010
    I got bored, so i made this wallpaper :
    the11doctors.png
    Click here for larger image
  • edited April 2010
    tredlow wrote: »
    Oh, also, some people called it season 5, some 31, but it was actually produced as season 1. So, yeah, major change.
    In Doctor Who Magazine, Master Moffat comments on that, and ends up calling it Series Fnarg, just to avoid confusion. I hereby propose that we all follow suit. I mean, he's Steven Moffat, and you don't argue with him.

    Here's to Series Fnarg!
  • edited April 2010
    Is it tomorrow that it premiere's over in the states? I hear that the doctor who team managed to get out of the UK alright.
  • edited April 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    Is it tomorrow that it premiere's over in the states?

    Yep. 9 PM Eastern on BBC America. "The Ultimate Guide" is at 8 PM.
  • edited April 2010
    'The Ultimate Guide'? Some sort of documentary on how the show has developed, I guess. I MUST SEE IT! Wonder if someone's put it up on YouTube or something...
  • edited April 2010
    It has released in Australia! To all the Aussies out there you can watch it on iview now!
  • edited April 2010
    'The Ultimate Guide'? Some sort of documentary on how the show has developed, I guess. I MUST SEE IT! Wonder if someone's put it up on YouTube or something...

    It could just be an hour or so of clips from previous episodes. But hey, i still want to watch it!
  • edited April 2010
    I cant wait till Victory of the Daleks Spitfighters in space fighting Dalek sausers is the definition of awsome
  • edited April 2010
    Dude, spoilers! Not everyone lives in the UK.

    But yeah, I'm looking forward to it as well. An hour and 20 minutes to go..!
  • edited April 2010
    Dude, spoilers! Not everyone lives in the UK.

    But yeah, I'm looking forward to it as well. An hour and 20 minutes to go..!

    its on every trailer though I didnt think it was that big a spoiler since it didnt even air when i posted it
  • edited April 2010
    I have just watched Dr Who just before I won't give anything away.

    The game coming out is free as the air.

    Click me to find out more

    Matt Smith reminds me a little of Peter Davidson, that was my first Dr Who back in 1981.

    I think this thread is great.

    As anyone in the US seen anything of the new look style Dr Who yet? When do you chaps get a whiff of it?

    Try this for size, Dr Who trailer maker

    TRAILER MAKER
  • edited April 2010
    I have just watched Dr Who just before I won't give anything away.

    The game coming out is free as the air.

    Click me to find out more

    Matt Smith reminds me a little of Peter Davidson, that was my first Dr Who back in 1981.

    I think this thread is great.

    As anyone in the US seen anything of the new look style Dr Who yet? When do you chaps get a whiff of it?

    I think the first episode airs tonight over there. I haven't seen this weeks episode yet (ruddy Football postponed the HD episode til 8.30PM). Was it better then the average Dalek episode?
  • edited April 2010
    Friar, Apparently it is worse than your average dalek episode
  • edited April 2010
    one thing bugged me about this series
    this series death count is rubbish so like 5 or 6 soilders have died
  • edited April 2010
    one thing bugged me about this series
    this series death count is rubbish so like 5 or 6 soilders have died
    One thing that bugged me about prior series is that the deathcount was always far too high. The only episodes without death were generally Moffats Episodes anyways (although 4 people sort of but not really died in Silence in the library)

    Anyway, that episode felt more like a set-up for future episodes. And why did the
    Dalek spaceship
    look like a brewery/food preperation room? They never used to have a chrome interior!
  • edited April 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    One thing that bugged me about prior series is that the deathcount was always far too high. The only episodes without death were generally Moffats Episodes anyways (although 4 people sort of but not really died in Silence in the library)

    Anyway, that episode felt more like a set-up for future episodes. And why did the
    Dalek spaceship
    look like a brewery/food preperation room? They never used to have a chrome interior!

    I like high death counts I guess Im pychopathic XD but one thing buged me was
    the old daleks wernt pure enough to open the thingy-mo-bob yet they where made from davros cells hes 100% kaled and as pure Dalek as you get
  • edited April 2010
    'The Ultimate Guide'? Some sort of documentary on how the show has developed, I guess. I MUST SEE IT! Wonder if someone's put it up on YouTube or something...

    It was pretty much a summing-up of the current (2005 onwards) version of the show and a few tidbits of what is coming in the new season (namely, more Daleks, more Cybermen, more Weeping Angels, and more River Song).
  • edited April 2010
    I just realised that this episode was purely to be used as a prelude to the first adventure game, where the adversaries are the new daleks.

    I thought those Daleks were made from Sec, anyways. I thought the Cult of Skaro were unpure
  • edited April 2010
    ive never watched doctor who before and i got the free 9 minute sneek peak off of itunes and was hooked. i dont know what is going on though, because i thought david tennant was the doctor and then there's a new guy as the doctor? weird.
  • edited April 2010
    Ach! Noob! Run away! :p

    Let me explain. David Tennant was the Doctor. However, in order to allow other actors to play the part, whenever the Doctor 'dies', he regenerates into a completely new body. Same character, different actor. The new guy, Matt Smith, is the 11th actor to play the Doctor. Each actor has their own way of playing the character, but they are all, and this is important, playing the same character.

    Hope that helps.
  • puzzleboxpuzzlebox Telltale Alumni
    edited April 2010
    This week's episode was kind of "meh" for me. None of it struck me as particularly exciting, although it was enjoyable enough to watch.

    For anyone super-nerdy or just interested in history, the cabinet war rooms in London are open to the public. I keep meaning to go check them out. Apparently everyone just left when the war was over, closed the door and never had reason to bother going back in. Everything was very well preserved, including all the original equipment, like the ranks of typewriters they used to make copies of documents (obviously photocopiers hadn't been invented). I never really thought about the operational logistics of running a war without modern technology before, but that kind of makes it hit home. I think it would be interesting to see.

    I'm pretty geared up about the return of the Weeping Angels next week! Blink remains one of my most favouritest episodes ever. :D
  • edited April 2010
    I went to the Cabinet war rooms two years ago and they are definitely worth a look. Part of the reason I enjoyed this last episode was because it took place in the war rooms.
  • edited April 2010
    I went to the Cabinet war rooms two years ago and they are definitely worth a look. Part of the reason I enjoyed this last episode was because it took place in the war rooms.
    They really did a great job recreating them, seeing as it was a disused military bunker in wales they used!
  • edited April 2010
    Yeah, I have to say, watching that episode, I could not tell whether they filmed on site or not, they did such a good job.
  • edited April 2010
    They used a set. The real War Rooms didn't actually have that giant map with the models on it.

    In the Doctor Who Confidential that went with this episode, Mark Gatiss (who wrote the episode) went to the actual War Rooms with a tour guide and we got to learn all about them. Actually pretty informative.
  • edited April 2010
    Ach! Noob! Run away! :p

    Let me explain. David Tennant was the Doctor. However, in order to allow other actors to play the part, whenever the Doctor 'dies', he regenerates into a completely new body. Same character, different actor. The new guy, Matt Smith, is the 11th actor to play the Doctor. Each actor has their own way of playing the character, but they are all, and this is important, playing the same character.

    Hope that helps.

    oh, ok. I like the guy that plays him now, matt smith. hes cool.
  • edited April 2010
    I hope the no death arnt in all Moffet story's The Doctor landing and death following is a central theme even in classic era
  • edited April 2010
    Well, we do have Weeping Angels and vampires coming up...
  • edited April 2010
    Well, we do have Weeping Angels and vampires coming up...

    Neither of which really kill people. Weeping angels make you live to death, and don't vampire bites turn you into vampires? I may be getting confused with Zombies there though...

    I have high hopes for the Silurians and the new Cybermen though!
  • edited April 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    Neither of which really kill people. Weeping angels make you live to death, and don't vampire bites turn you into vampires? I may be getting confused with Zombies there though...

    it depends on the depliction some kill some turn ppl into vampires an some do both based on what they wana do
  • edited April 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    Neither of which really kill people. Weeping angels make you live to death, and don't vampire bites turn you into vampires? I may be getting confused with Zombies there though...

    I have high hopes for the Silurians and the new Cybermen though!

    Killing you nicely still counts as killing. And I think the Old!Who vampires were more the killing kind than the turning kind (hemovores and Great Vampires).
  • edited April 2010
    Bit of a spoiler, but
    they aren't proper vampires. Just aliens who seem an awful lot like vampires.
  • edited April 2010
    Bit of a spoiler, but
    they aren't proper vampires. Just aliens who seem an awful lot like vampires.

    its allways that!
  • edited April 2010
    Is that a bad thing?
Sign in to comment in this discussion.