Doctor Who: Series 5 (/31) Discussion

1356721

Comments

  • edited April 2010
    Is that a bad thing?

    no it wasnt a critsism its just all
    monsters like warewolfs mummys lockness monster vampires devils ect are aliens not a knock agianst it. I was just noting its never a "real" human monster of legend
  • edited April 2010
    no it wasnt a critsism its just all
    monsters like warewolfs mummys lockness monster vampires devils ect are aliens not a knock agianst it. I was just noting its never a "real" human monster of legend

    I thought the LochNess monster was from earth, given it was in elague with the silurians, who live under the sea (and predate the human race). But yeah, i get where you're coming from. It would be nice to see more actual Earthican (that should be a word!) creatures.
  • edited April 2010
    Well, the
    human-celled daleks
    were sort of from Earth, and of course we have these magical creatures called, ehr, homman? Huumin?
  • edited April 2010
    GaryCXJk wrote: »
    Well, the
    human-celled daleks
    were sort of from Earth, and of course we have these magical creatures called, ehr, homman? Huumin?
    toclafane?
  • edited April 2010
    Oh man, it's like I'm back at Gallifrey One! Hee!
  • edited April 2010
    Thoughts? I thought that episode was fantastic! And it made me jump a fair few times!
  • edited April 2010
    I liked when
    Amys thought her hand was turned to stone and the doctor had to bite it XD
  • edited April 2010
    I was a bit dubious about the Weeping Angels coming back, but I thought this was fantastic. Somehow Steven Moffet managed to make them scarier than they were in Blink. And awesomer (even though that's not a word).
  • edited April 2010
    I liked when
    Amys thought her hand was turned to stone and the doctor had to bite it XD
    This series seems to be full of Doctor-ish moments. The Jammy Dodger 'Self-Destruct' was another.

    There were a lot of nice moments in this episode, and I sort-of enjoyed it, but I'll reserve my full judgement until I see next weeks episode. The preview was... confusing.
  • edited April 2010
    Im also happy that
    the angels kill ppl in the traditinal sense rathe then let them "live to death" and that the doctor and death theme was touched apon agian
  • edited April 2010
    I'm really starting to love the New Doctor's Theme (the one that played when
    he was talking about not keeping himself in a trap
    )
  • edited April 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    I'm really starting to love the New Doctor's Theme (the one that played when
    he was talking about not keeping himself in a trap
    )

    I put it on my mp3 I got one off youtube that was taken from tv with talking and noises cut out its not perfect but It will do till the new soundtrack Cd comes out
  • edited April 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    I thought the LochNess monster was from earth, given it was in elague with the silurians, who live under the sea (and predate the human race).

    No, it wasn't from Earth, or in league with the Silurians.



    Doesn't Graham Norton count as a home-grown menace?
  • puzzleboxpuzzlebox Telltale Alumni
    edited April 2010
    I was a bit dubious about the Weeping Angels coming back, but I thought this was fantastic. Somehow Steven Moffet managed to make them scarier than they were in Blink.

    Inevitable comparison to Blink:

    Blink managed to make me squeal a couple of times. :o Somehow the Angels weren't as scary for me this time around though... maybe because I knew what to expect? Or maybe because
    most of them had eroded faces - unexpectedly being confronted by a grotesque, snarling stone face and grabby clawing hand was probably what I found most frightening in the first encounter. Sure, this time there were more of them, but they were more feeble.

    Mostly I just didn't feel the same sustained level of tension throughout the episode, although parts of it were still very tense - especially the "To be continued..." ending (nice speech!).
    This series seems to be full of Doctor-ish moments. The Jammy Dodger 'Self-Destruct' was another.

    The Jammy Dodger was awesome. The Doctor: defending the Earth armed only with a sonic screwdriver and a tasty biscuit. :p

    I'm really liking his mannerisms too - have you noticed the little skippity thing he does sometimes when walking?
    Im also happy that
    the angels kill ppl in the traditinal sense rathe then let them "live to death" and that the doctor and death theme was touched apon agian

    Why is it they
    actually kill people now
    ? I missed that explanation.

    In other news, one of my flatmates insists that Matt Smith looks like a young Gordon Ramsay. I am highly skeptical.

    Attachment not found.
  • edited April 2010
    No, it wasn't from Earth, or in league with the Silurians.



    Doesn't Graham Norton count as a home-grown menace?
    My memory is probbaly kinda dodgy, which is understandable because it read it in a book(some villains factbook thing) 3 years ago.
  • edited April 2010
    I think the thing I found creepiest was the whole
    anything that bears the image of an angel becomes itself an angel
    thing. I found it a nice touch.
  • edited April 2010
    I think the thing I found creepiest was the whole
    anything that bears the image of an angel becomes itself an angel
    thing. I found it a nice touch.
    my desktop is gona kill me!
  • edited April 2010
    my desktop is gona kill me!

    Run while you still can!
  • edited April 2010
    I put it on my mp3 I got one off youtube that was taken from tv with talking and noises cut out its not perfect but It will do till the new soundtrack Cd comes out
    You owe me. The site actually has all the different themes as well - head to this page and scroll all the way to the bottom. Nice little collection.

    For those who aren't aware, during the broadcast of 'Rose', the first new episode of Doctor Who in over a decade (twice that if you discount the movie, which you can't, cause it's totally been established as canon in the show, so ignore this entire parenthesis), the voice of Graham Norton, who had been hosting a live reality show that was on just before Doctor Who, was inadvertently broadcast over the top of the episode for a few seconds. While not an earth-shattering event, it was very annoying and a great deal of Doctor Who fans were not happy!

    So when something similar happens right at the end of this week's episode (a little advert for Graham Norton's next show appeared at the bottom of the screen - most American shows do this, but we don't, hence the annoyance), it's bound to cause a fair bit of frustration, as well as shatter the mood of a brilliantly planned cliffhanger.
  • edited April 2010

    I think he meant the one in the background of [url] This trailer[/url]. That was the one i was refferencing anyway.

    Oh, and This website Sells officially licensed full size replica daleks (for about £3000), cybermen, and soon weeping angel statues. If only i was 15 years older, i could claim a mid-life crisis and buy one of them... Far better than a flashy car anyday!
  • edited April 2010
    Oh, the Eleventh Doctor's theme. I see what you mean. I thought you meant the theme for the show itself. My bad.
  • edited April 2010
    Oh, the Eleventh Doctor's theme. I see what you mean. I thought you meant the theme for the show itself. My bad.

    I still put it on my mp3 thanks ^^
  • edited April 2010
    You're welcome. It's an awesome version.
  • edited April 2010
    You're welcome. It's an awesome version.

    It took some getting used to, but i'm beginning to like it as much as the others!
  • edited April 2010
    This episode should be 3D for the
    Angel coming out the TV effect
  • edited April 2010
    This episode should be 3D for the
    Angel coming out the TV effect

    I second that.
  • edited April 2010
    oh yes. that would be awesome indeed.

    I am liking how Moffat is playing with the weeping angels, being able to control the voice of the dead, that kind of thing. and with Bob it plays out kinda funny in the good way
  • edited April 2010
    I think that the Angels were controlling the voices of the dead with the neural relay thingee. Like the Vashta Nerada did.
  • edited April 2010
    I literally screamed everytime the angel came closer to Amy. Freaking angel. For a moment I thought the angel would get to me as well.

    And yes, the angels did snap the necks to get to the neural thingies. That's the only way they could speak.

    Oh, and I was promised tea.
  • edited May 2010
    Flesh and Stone was my fav episode of series Fnarg
  • edited May 2010
    I thought it was a great episode as well. Still not sure what my favourite episode so far is (probably the first one), but then we're not even halfway through, so that's not a big problem.

    Did anyone else find River Song verging on the wrong side of annoying? Not quite sure why, but she just irritated me.
  • edited May 2010
    Flesh and Stone was my fav episode of series Fnarg

    I didn't really think it was up to the standards of previous episodes. At least we got some background info about the crack. Also, the date is in eight weeks time, so ties in with the series finale (s).

    Also,
    Does anyone else think that Riversong will kill the doctor at some point? It seemed a bit too obvious to me
  • edited May 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    Also,
    Does anyone else think that Riversong will kill the doctor at some point? It seemed a bit too obvious to me

    As you said, I think it's far too obvious - besides,
    it'd be a regeneration at most
    , but I don't think it's even that. Maybe we'll find out in a later episode or when
    River returns for the season finale (I reckon, anyway)
    .
  • edited May 2010
    My guess is
    she killed captin jack XD
  • puzzleboxpuzzlebox Telltale Alumni
    edited May 2010
    Friar wrote: »
    I didn't really think it was up to the standards of previous episodes.

    No way, are you kidding? It was massively awesome!! :D

    The dialog was fantastic, some parts were a near-constant barrage of great lines. Like all of these:
    Father: The whole place is a death trap!
    Doctor: No, it's a time bomb. Well, it's a death trap and a time bomb. Aaaand now it's a dead end. [pause] Nobody panic.


    Father: Dr Song, do you trust this man?
    Song: I absolutely trust him.
    Father: He's not some kind of madman then.
    Song: [pause] I absolutely trust him.


    Doctor: Oh, that's bad. That's extremely very not good.


    Amy: So what's wrong with me?
    Song: Nothing, you're fine.
    Doctor: Everything, you're dying.
    Song: Doctor!
    Doctor: Yes, you're right, if we LIE to her she'll get all better, right!


    Father: Doctor, we're too exposed here, we have to move on.
    Doctor: We're too exposed everywhere, and Amy can't move, and anyway, that's not the plan.
    Song: There's a plan?
    Doctor: I don't know yet, I haven't finished talking.

    I'll definitely make regular use of "that's extremely very not good". :)

    And the Doctor
    losing it with River Song and getting all angry and shouty?
    That was pretty cool.

    Oh and I love that they're setting up the season finale already.
  • edited May 2010
    I found it particularly eerie to see
    the Angels finally move
    . Right before
    Amy gets teleported away
    .

    I am also very curious as to
    what the deal with Amy is
    .
  • Something I thought odd was that
    the angels appeared able to move while looking at each other. If that was possible then the main characters of Blink would have been zapped back in time.
  • edited May 2010
    Something I thought odd was that
    the angels appeared able to move while looking at each other. If that was possible then the main characters of Blink would have been zapped back in time.

    they might have
    absorbed so much power that there defence wasnt working propoly they didnt know amy wasnt looking and there defence assumed it was or maybe they where so scared it was on the frits
  • edited May 2010
    They might just not have paid attention to each other, purely on their victims, which is why the quantum lock didn't work; they didn't really look at each other at all anyway.
  • edited May 2010
    Twas an entertaining episode, I just didn't like how they ended up dealing with the Angels. It seemed... anticlimactic. Father Octavian's
    death
    just seemed random as well,
    though brutal
    . But as puzzlebox has already noted, there's some moments of great writing in it!
    I think that the Angels were controlling the voices of the dead with the neural relay thingee. Like the Vashta Nerada did.

    I can't take that episode seriously anymore. Not since Top Gear made comparisons between men in white spacesuits with blacked out visors and the Stig, saying that he had to chew his own face off rather than reveal his identity...
Sign in to comment in this discussion.