The Newly Regenerated Doctor Who Thread

11213151718103

Comments

  • edited April 2011
    Ribs wrote: »
    It still was the lamest of the RTD Deus Ex Machinas and turned one of the better episodes into one of the worst stories Doctor Who has ever had.

    If you think that was the worst then what about how quickly they stopped
    the return of the Time Lords by having the Doctor simply shoot a random machine just to have a long winded goodbye to all of his companions
    .
  • edited April 2011
    I'll admit the long-winded goodbye went on too long and had a few WTF moments (Mickey and Martha got married? WHAT?), but the shooting of the machine actually worked. It showed that no matter how angry or desperate the Doctor is, he'll never kill someone in cold blood. Very true to the character.
  • edited April 2011
    Pretty bloody expensive though. How'd they afford it? (I will keep asking questions like this until you drop it)

    And Ribs: like I said, I didn't think much it, but that's just me. I'm not saying nobody else should like it, just trying to explain why I didn't - basically, it made no sense. But again, that's just me.

    Oh no. That was just one of many, many problems that three-parter had. Trust me, you don't want to get me started on the RTD-written episodes.

    I get what you're saying. Not everyone likes the same episodes. I liked the Beast below, which many people hated (No idea why though), and didn't like the empty child/doctor dances that much (first time round. I quite like it now.)

    Oh yeah, I wasn't sure if they'd changed the opening credits. I thought they had, but wasn't sure. At least they included Rory in the titles now. It's a shame about river not being there. Oh and BBC america appeared along BBC Wales/Cymru in the credits, just before the trailer.
  • edited April 2011
    Hey, I liked The Beast Below too! It just suffered from what I like to call 'TMTF Syndrome' - Too Much, Too Fast. There was so much plot stuffed into 45 minutes, it could have easily been a two-parter, and I think I'd probably have preferred it if it had. Still a good episode, just felt a bit rushed for my tastes.

    But again, that's just me!
  • edited April 2011
    I'll admit the long-winded goodbye went on too long and had a few WTF moments (Mickey and Martha got married? WHAT?), but the shooting of the machine actually worked. It showed that no matter how angry or desperate the Doctor is, he'll never kill someone in cold blood. Very true to the character.

    Well that is true but my problem was the big build up to the return of the Time Lords
    just so they could spend a couple of seconds on Earth before getting sent back
    . Also there's something that just bugs me,
    why did Wilfred get in that chamber?
  • edited April 2011
    Mr Nutt wrote: »
    Also there's something that just bugs me,
    why did Wilfred get in that chamber?

    He went into the chamber to save the random dude who was trapped in the other half.
  • edited April 2011
    Another problem with the End of Time is how the Doctor survives falling from Space, despite dying from a 100m fall in Logopolis.
  • edited April 2011
    Ribs wrote: »
    Another problem with the End of Time is how the Doctor survives falling from Space, despite dying from a 100m fall in Logopolis.

    ...Maybe he landed on his head in Logopolis?
  • edited April 2011
    Ribs wrote: »
    Another problem with the End of Time is how the Doctor survives falling from Space, despite dying from a 100m fall in Logopolis.

    This regenoration can handle falling better.
  • edited April 2011
    ...Maybe he landed on his head in Logopolis?
    Nope. The sharp pieces of glass obviously broke his fall.
    ;)

    Just watched Doctor Who confidential (do you guys get that in the states? It's a making of documentary type thing). They gave it a completely new intro, which is nice.
  • edited April 2011
    Friar wrote: »
    Nope. The sharp pieces of glass obviously broke his fall.
    ;)

    no-prize.jpg
  • edited April 2011
    Oh, those were a wonderful idea. I miss stuff like that.
  • edited April 2011
    I would like to add how amazing it is that liking Doctor Who in Britain is a somewhat cliched thing and that liking it over here is geek cred.
  • edited April 2011
    Ribs wrote: »
    I would like to add how amazing it is that liking Doctor Who in Britain is a somewhat cliched thing and that liking it over here is geek cred.
    It's not that clichéd. If you take audience figures, it works out at about 1 in 10 people in the UK like the program enough to watch it each week. Although, in the US, it's probably closer to one in a hundred. I guess us brits just have better taste than you americans. :p
  • edited April 2011
    Friar wrote: »
    It's not that clichéd. If you take audience figures, it works out at about 1 in 10 people in the UK like the program enough to watch it each week. Although, in the US, it's probably closer to one in a hundred. I guess us brits just have better taste than you americans. :p

    More then 1/3rd of all people watching TV in the UK were watching yesterday, and 1/10th the country.
    Less then 1/300th of the United States watched the Series Five premiere (data not available until the week proper for Series Six) which was the highest rated episode to date.

    In other news, I've been having fun with the tags lately but no one else has sad face. I had to remove my 'bow ties are cool' so someone must replace it.

    Relatedly: Here is a much better summary of Doctor Who then the Fine Brother's version, done in less time too.
  • edited April 2011
    One quarter of all Brits watched Wallace and Gromit: A matter of loaf and death.

    As far as I'm aware, that's more people than did any other one thing in 2008, so this is basically the definition of British. Feeling proud yet? :D
  • edited April 2011
    coolsome wrote: »
    This regenoration can handle falling better.

    The Doctor is like Doomsday out of "Superman". If something kills him, he comes back to life immune to it:

    So, the Doctor cannot die of:

    1) old age
    2) scarecrows (don't ask....)
    3) radiation poisioning
    4) hitting the ground really hard
    5) spectrox toximaea
    6) suicide or hitting his head on the console *really* hard, depending who you believe
    7) shooting
    8) shell shock
    9) timey-wimey stuff
    10) radiat- no, wait, that's not gonna work, then, is it?
  • edited April 2011
    One quarter of all Brits watched Wallace and Gromit: A matter of loaf and death.

    As far as I'm aware, that's more people than did any other one thing in 2008, so this is basically the definition of British. Feeling proud yet? :D

    I watched both! :p
  • edited April 2011
    The Doctor is like Doomsday out of "Superman". If something kills him, he comes back to life immune to it:

    So, the Doctor cannot die of:

    1) old age
    2) scarecrows (don't ask....)
    3) radiation poisioning
    4) hitting the ground really hard
    5) spectrox toximaea
    6) suicide or hitting his head on the console *really* hard, depending who you believe
    7) shooting
    8) shell shock
    9) timey-wimey stuff
    10) radiat- no, wait, that's not gonna work, then, is it?
    Ah, but maybe it was a different kind of radiation. Remember in Smith and Jones when he did that mugging bit with the radiation and the shoe? Barefoot on the Moon indeed.
  • edited April 2011
    The Doctor is like Doomsday out of "Superman". If something kills him, he comes back to life immune to it:

    So, the Doctor cannot die of:

    1) old age
    2) scarecrows (don't ask....)
    3) radiation poisioning
    4) hitting the ground really hard
    5) spectrox toximaea
    6) suicide or hitting his head on the console *really* hard, depending who you believe
    7) shooting
    8) shell shock
    9) timey-wimey stuff
    10) radiat- no, wait, that's not gonna work, then, is it?

    A-Seven died from the Surgery. So he's immune to surgery.

    B-The Doctor is pretty much a demigod by this logic, bringing said logic full circle to Last of the Time Lords.
  • edited April 2011
    One quarter of all Brits watched Wallace and Gromit: A matter of loaf and death.

    As far as I'm aware, that's more people than did any other one thing in 2008, so this is basically the definition of British. Feeling proud yet? :D

    Odd thing is, I think it'll be far more people than are going to be watching the royal wedding (in the UK at least). That would be awesome. Not quite as awesome as if Doctor Who's ratings beat it mind you, but still awesome.

    Oh, and don't forget 10 was killed by a dalek too! He should be immune to dalek weaponry now.
  • edited April 2011
    Im not gonna watch the Royal wedding
  • edited April 2011
    Friar wrote: »
    Odd thing is, I think it'll be far more people than are going to be watching the royal wedding (in the UK at least). That would be awesome. Not quite as awesome as if Doctor Who's ratings beat it mind you, but still awesome.

    Oh, and don't forget 10 was killed by a dalek too! He should be immune to dalek weaponry now.

    City of Death got 15+ million viewers the first time it aired, which by my calculations is 1/4 the country. Assuming more then one person was watching per TV set (as you should), perhaps 3/4 of the country were all watching doctor who.
  • edited April 2011
    Well...in America, about sixty percent of households watched the season finale of M*A*S*H according to Wikipedia.
  • edited April 2011
    Ribs wrote: »
    City of Death got 15+ million viewers the first time it aired, which by my calculations is 1/4 the country. Assuming more then one person was watching per TV set (as you should), perhaps 3/4 of the country were all watching doctor who.
    IIRC, that was due to a strike at ITV at the time which meant that BBC 1 and 2 were the only channels airing. Still a big achievement though.
  • edited April 2011
    Mark Gastiss Just tweeted this picture:
    royal-wedding-dale_1880121i.jpg
    WOULD YOU LIKE SOME TEA

    (WHY DON'T THEY INVITE A SMALL ARMADA OF DALEKS TO THE ROYAL WEDDING AND USE ALL FOOTAGE FOR THE SEASON FINALE)
  • edited April 2011
    Ribs wrote: »
    (WHY DON'T THEY INVITE A SMALL ARMADA OF DALEKS TO THE ROYAL WEDDING AND USE ALL FOOTAGE FOR THE SEASON FINALE)

    Because you know that far too many people would be cheering for them. You know that.
  • edited April 2011
    Because you know that far too many people would be cheering for them. You know that.

    Yes. I believe the Daleks inspire more patriotism than the royal family. God save the emperor Dalek.
  • edited April 2011
    So this week's Big Finish podcast is out, but the key bit is: Clips from The first Fourth Doctor Adventure. Yays yays.

    Also: Moffat says the cracks in time erased all public knowledge of Aliens from the RTD era. This creates a plothole, as Adelaide Brooke would never go into space and cause First Contact if not for the Dalek Invasion of 'Journey's End'
  • edited April 2011
    Ribs wrote: »
    So this week's Big Finish podcast is out, but the key bit is: Clips from The first Fourth Doctor Adventure. Yays yays.

    Also: Moffat says the cracks in time erased all public knowledge of Aliens from the RTD era. This creates a plothole, as Adelaide Brooke would never go into space and cause First Contact if not for the Dalek Invasion of 'Journey's End'

    Maybe she saw an Atraxi ship instead? That part of the episode was set in 2008 afterall (the same year as the dalek invasion). Although that theoretically shouldn't have happened either. Hmmm...

    Also, looking forward to the wire making an appearance on friday!
    TheWire.jpg ;)
  • edited April 2011
    Matt Smith is such a dork. (in all the good cool ways
  • edited April 2011
    Something for the ladies on TTG:
    article-1143446-037D7A2C000005DC-15_468x703.jpg
  • edited April 2011
    That image will haunt my nightmares. I despise you, your family and everything you stand for.
  • edited April 2011
    That image will haunt my nightmares. I despise you, your family and everything you stand for.

    What about me:D
    tumblr_l13kao4EyY1qa1bdoo1_500.jpg
  • edited April 2011
    That one I can cope with. Don't ask me why.
  • edited April 2011
    r6cib.jpg
  • edited April 2011
    Is it just me or does in not feel like 5 days have passed? It's really weird.
  • edited April 2011
    Is it just me or does in not feel like 5 days have passed? It's really weird.

    Probably just a bit of localised time distortion. :p
    But yeah, it seems odd that it's only two days until the next episode. I've kind of gotten used to waiting ages for the next new one.
  • edited April 2011
    I blame wibbly wobbly timey wimey... stuff.

    Maybe it's because work's been an absolute nightmare, but I honestly can't remember much about the bast few days. Or maybe it's the weather. It does mess with me. Hope I remember to watch the show on Saturday.
  • edited April 2011
    So: The last scene will feature a huge twist, apparently. All I know is that
    It involves a Regeneration in some way
    and I'm going to try and keep it that way.

    In other news, there are now details around the webzone of who River Song really is. There is a possibility it's from a fake scene, but please for the love of god be careful.

    (Don't Quote me if you don't want to see the spoiler, as it forces it to be shown :P)
Sign in to comment in this discussion.